IZ*ONE Vs. I.O.I (1 Viewer)

Lovely_Cornchips

Future Canadian Hobo
.
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
11,758
Reactions Received
29,755
Points
7,116
Gender
Female
Ship
Wreck
Watch the clip and make your list to see which group wins for you in the end!

  1. Yeonjung
  2. Chaeyeon
  3. Yoojung
  4. Sohye
  5. Chungha
  6. Nayoung
  7. Won young
  8. La Vien Rose
I.O.I: 5 IZ*ONE: 3

I.O.I WINS FOR ME!

Disclaimer: Don't make this an ugly thread this is just meant for fun. Not picking the other group doesn't mean you hate them or have an issue with them.
 
Last edited:

gayzone

ahn yujin's ♡
.
Joined
12 May 2020
Messages
4,746
Reactions Received
9,470
Points
21,925
Location
always w/ iz*one
Website
iz-one.co.kr
Wreck
not to be rude but are we seriously going to compare them? i know this is for fun but to me, iz*one is iz*one and ioi is ioi. both groups cannot be compared because they both have their own strengths and weaknesses :sj_weary:
 
  • Like
Reactions: RandAlThor

Lovely_Cornchips

Future Canadian Hobo
.
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
11,758
Reactions Received
29,755
Points
7,116
Gender
Female
Ship
Wreck
not to be rude but are we seriously going to compare them? i know this is for fun but to me, iz*one is iz*one and ioi is ioi. both groups cannot be compared because they both have their own strengths and weaknesses :sj_weary:
A video was made for it and I watched it and made a mental list in my head. It's not meant to be taken seriously it's just for fun. I know the groups are different but they came about on the same show and in the same way. That's the main reason this video was made most likely to see which group people prefer from the girl groups created by produce.
 

Lovely_Cornchips

Future Canadian Hobo
.
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
11,758
Reactions Received
29,755
Points
7,116
Gender
Female
Ship
Wreck
I'm just going to keep this up to fill my thread quota since it's controversial but there is nothing controversial in it to get it removed!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RandAlThor
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
16,534
Reactions Received
40,199
Points
22,764
While i really like most of the individuals in IOI i like IZONE the group sooooo much more.

Take the vocal battle Yeonjung is better technically but she got far better songs each round. Yruis only great showcase song was wish.
Yuri had a far better show though as a person. Yeonjung was very petulant and unlikeable at times, Yuri was in harder choices v Goeun.
and handled the role splitting/drama much better despite being the same age.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lovely_Cornchips

Lovely_Cornchips

Future Canadian Hobo
.
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
11,758
Reactions Received
29,755
Points
7,116
Gender
Female
Ship
Wreck
While i really like most of the individuals in IOI i like IZONE the group sooooo much more.

Take the vocal battle Yeonjung is better technically but she got far better songs each round. Yruis only great showcase song was wish.
Yuri had a far better show though as a person. Yeonjung was very petulant and unlikeable at times, Yuri was in harder choices v Goeun.
and handled the role splitting/drama much better despite being the same age.
see I wouldn't have known that-I didn't finish watching PD48 because I got bored but I watched the first season all the way through eventually and did see Yeonjung kind of annoying people at one point. I remember Mina doing the same, but technically I think I prefer Yeonjung just based off of what was shown.

I don't even really love either group. It was just interesting to see which one got the most for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RandAlThor
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
16,534
Reactions Received
40,199
Points
22,764
see I wouldn't have known that-I didn't finish watching PD48 because I got bored but I watched the first season all the way through eventually and did see Yeonjung kind of annoying people at one point. I remember Mina doing the same, but technically I think I prefer Yeonjung just based off of what was shown.

I don't even really love either group. It was just interesting to see which one got the most for me.
Yep Yeonjung did get screwed vote wise blue v red but that helped her far more long run.

But ITNW as a former sm trainee(i found it funny that both teams had former sm girls singing main), haru haru, and pretty much the signature song of the produce series in the same place. Those are a vocals dream if you execute. There is no doubt that skill wise from the show Yeonjung comes out ahead.

Take Nayoung v Eunbi as leader.... Nayoungs task was far far simpler than Eunbis its not even close. I love Nayoung but she had to keep the kids together for 6 maybe 8 months a good chunk of that with members missing, and the only non Korean was from her company and very well known to her. Her biggest problem was that the groups life was sooo short that getting and keeping folks bought in could have been a challenge. Ill have to pick Eunbi

Chungha v Chaeyeon skill wise call it a wash.

Yena V Yoojung setting aside that she is the 4th member of the joyuriz :) also a wash.

Cute Wonyoung, Nako , Hitomi, Chaewon v Mina, Sohye yea that is izone.

Sexy i think the vid picked wrong to start with should be Chungha v Eunbi and i have no opinion.

youngest Wonyoung... that she was that good at 13 and by the projected end she still will be younger than when Somi started IOI. It is just flat nuts.

Dream girls is not a great song. LVR.

IOI - 1
IZONE - 4
even - 2
dont care - 1

even if ya break all the iffy/50v50 votes to IOI it is a tie and that i think is a good result :)
 

Emanresu

Idol
Joined
3 December 2018
Messages
3,141
Reactions Received
11,359
Points
4,106
Location
USA
Website
emanresukdrama.wordpress.com
Gender
Male
Oh cool I'll play.


1. I don't really know them well honestly. But I'll pick IOI Yeonjung. Liked her parts in the video.

2. I have to pick IZONE Chaeyeon because I'm in love with her sister ITZY Chaeryeong. don't tell her she's a stand in

3. IZONE YENA. I stan her.

4. IOI Chaeyeon is magical. I stan her.

5. IOI Sohye is Top 5 Best Things. I stan her too.

6. I'll pick IZONE Chaeyeon again.

7. My 3rd ultimate. NAYOUNG. NAYOUNG. NAYOUNG. There are only 2 people who I will ever consider picking over Nayoung in this world. Yoona and Tzuyu. That's it. Eunbi does not compete.

8. Oh man. As a song I gave to go with IZONE. LVER.



IOI 4.

IZONE 4
 

milk

Rookie
Joined
13 June 2019
Messages
1,558
Reactions Received
2,860
Points
1,136
I prefer IOI personally. I like their music and the members better (theres a few izone members I'm not fond of tbh)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lovely_Cornchips

Users who are viewing this thread