Which is the most important part of a kpop group debut? (1 Viewer)

Yili

♡ GOT7 x IGOT7 ♡
.
.
.
Joined
12 November 2018
Messages
9,508
Reactions Received
21,278
Points
6,861
Location
Atiny Pirate Ship
Gender
Female
Ship
Is it more important to you for the idols to seem very talented or for the song to be very good?

Because there is a possibility of:

a song being good but the execution of choreo or singing/rapping is not anything amazing
OR
the possibility of the idols looking and sounding very talented/charismatic but the song not being to your taste
 

Lovely_Cornchips

Future Canadian Hobo
.
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
10,321
Reactions Received
27,024
Points
6,916
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
Wreck
Good question. I think I'd prefer for a debut song to show the talent. There are MULTIPLE groups I like now whose debut caught my attention because I think it showed ability but I didn't necessarily LIKE the song. Then over time, the song grew on me.

I think FavOrite and Hi High by LOONA are good examples of this-I wasn't a fan of either song at the release but I could see potential in the group as a whole as a result of the songs. Now I actually enjoy and like both songs and think the group has grown as a whole. Though I still think I have a rocky relationship with the group as a whole.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yili

Tickita

𝕄𝕞𝕞𝕙 𝕄𝕞𝕞𝕙. 🌹
.
Joined
29 January 2020
Messages
8,242
Reactions Received
13,925
Points
7,281
Location
The Peaceful Side of Cassiopeia
Fandom
Cassiopeia
Gender
Female
Talent. It's just a debut. They've got time.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Yili

Yili

♡ GOT7 x IGOT7 ♡
.
.
.
Joined
12 November 2018
Messages
9,508
Reactions Received
21,278
Points
6,861
Location
Atiny Pirate Ship
Gender
Female
Ship
Good question. I think I'd prefer for a debut song to show the talent. There are MULTIPLE groups I like now whose debut caught my attention because I think it showed ability but I didn't necessarily LIKE the song. Then over time, the song grew on me.

I think FavOrite and Hi High by LOONA are good examples of this-I wasn't a fan of either song at the release but I could see potential in the group as a whole as a result of the songs. Now I actually enjoy and like both songs and think the group has grown as a whole. Though I still think I have a rocky relationship with the group as a whole.
I think this is applicable to me too, for example for me I haven't always loved all of Mamamoo's songs but I think they're extremely talented and so I waited for a couple years until they started putting out music that really appealed to me. To me if the group is super talented, I will still be interested in them even if the songs aren't my style at first
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lovely_Cornchips

Lovely_Cornchips

Future Canadian Hobo
.
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
10,321
Reactions Received
27,024
Points
6,916
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
Wreck
I think this is applicable to me too, for example for me I haven't always loved all of Mamamoo's songs but I think they're extremely talented and so I waited for a couple years until they started putting out music that really appealed to me. To me if the group is super talented, I will still be interested in them even if the songs aren't my style at first
The other thing is the b-sides. I think most groups will at least drop ONE song you'll like at some point. I think Woo!Ah! is really grabbing my attention as of late tbh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yili
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
11,176
Reactions Received
31,417
Points
18,364
They HAVE to execute on stage.
I perma kill debut groups for failure to execute.

In most cases i could care less about the video, its an add. I expect adds to lie.
Show me what ya got on stage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Poetry and Yili
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
11,176
Reactions Received
31,417
Points
18,364
I think this is applicable to me too, for example for me I haven't always loved all of Mamamoo's songs but I think they're extremely talented and so I waited for a couple years until they started putting out music that really appealed to me. To me if the group is super talented, I will still be interested in them even if the songs aren't my style at first
see i am just the opposite kpop is a ton of work to even follow a group. If the debut or first comeback is not enough to make me care a bit then i will move on.

MMM for example i really liked but the music drifted away for what i thought made em special. so now i pay attention to solar and moon in varitey is about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yili

Users who are viewing this thread