Thoughts You know you're a stupid stan when... (1 Viewer)

Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
2,886
Reaction score
10,944
Points
38,524
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
When a silly cover by ANOTHER group you like upsets you because they took out certain highlights that make that song THAT song <.<


Now here me out-this cover isn't bad but the raps and then them taking out a SIGNATURE move from the dance irked me. Is this stupid and petty? Oh for sure. I'm I still like WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?! Oh, you bet.

But also I know I tend to be pickier with covers fo guy groups.
 
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
2,886
Reaction score
10,944
Points
38,524
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
I can't say I remember what the original performance was like at all but this is such a great cover... I should check out more from them!
Infinite had an iconic dance move that went with the chorus and ONEUS got rid of it here and I'm big sad about it XD
 

Darth_17

Hua Chenyu's Martian
.
.
.
Joined
21 November 2018
Messages
5,226
Reaction score
22,726
Points
39,724
Ship
Infinite had an iconic dance move that went with the chorus and ONEUS got rid of it here and I'm big sad about it XD
Ohh.. Now that you mentioned it I do remember the dance break. But I feel like keeping it wouldn't have gone well with their drama version of the song. Also, they can't just cover the song exactly like the original. That would be so boring and they would probably lose the show. They're supposed to make a new arrangement and make their own unique performance based around the song.
I guess I'm the opposite of you. I love seeing new arrangements. The groups on RTK covered my faves too and it was so interesting seeing their new compositions and takes on the songs
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lady_Camellia
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
2,886
Reaction score
10,944
Points
38,524
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
Ohh.. Now that you mentioned it I do remember the dance break. But I feel like keeping it wouldn't have gone well with their drama version of the song. Also, they can't just cover the song exactly like the original. That would be so boring and they would probably lose the show. They're supposed to make a new arrangement and make their own unique performance based around the song.
I guess I'm the opposite of you. I love seeing new arrangements. The groups on RTK covered my faves too and it was so interesting seeing their new compositions and takes on the songs
I'm not talking about the dance break, I'm talking about a small dance move that wouldn't completely ruin the uniqueness of the performance. I know what the purpose of the performances on this show is...
 

Queen

Idol
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
4,169
Reaction score
13,475
Points
31,974
Gender
Female
you are not the only one there's been a couple covers from kingdom that were meh to me because they got rid of elements of the song/performance that were iconic

I think on twitter people had a field day with a blackpink cover lol
 
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
2,886
Reaction score
10,944
Points
38,524
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
you are not the only one there's been a couple covers from kingdom that were meh to me because they got rid of elements of the song/performance that were iconic

I think on twitter people had a field day with a blackpink cover lol
I never watched the show because I was more into the Queendom one and this just seemed ok. I may watch the official official Kingdom one that is hopefully more similar to Queendom.

Who did a BlackPink cover though?
 

Queen

Idol
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
4,169
Reaction score
13,475
Points
31,974
Gender
Female
I never watched the show because I was more into the Queendom one and this just seemed ok. I may watch the official official Kingdom one that is hopefully more similar to Queendom.

Who did a BlackPink cover though?
Pentagon and ONF. I thought it was OK but I did see peoples complaints about the arrangement and how changing it got rid of the vibe of the song

I liked the boyz performances but im also biased in that department 😂
 
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
2,886
Reaction score
10,944
Points
38,524
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
Pentagon and ONF. I thought it was OK but I did see peoples complaints about the arrangement and how changing it got rid of the vibe of the song

I liked the boyz performances but im also biased in that department 😂
Yeah I don't like the chorus here <.<
 

Queen

Idol
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
4,169
Reaction score
13,475
Points
31,974
Gender
Female
Yeah I don't like the chorus here <.<
same that's the biggest issue I had with it. It seems like they were trying to do an anti drop type thing but it just doesn't fit the song
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lovely_Cornchips
Joined
3 November 2018
Messages
2,886
Reaction score
10,944
Points
38,524
Location
Chanyeol's Ass
Gender
Female
Ship
same that's the biggest issue I had with it. It seems like they were trying to do an anti drop type thing but it just doesn't fit the song
Yeah but otherwise the cover isn't actually bad-I don't know. I just get irked when an iconic part is kind of erased from a song. Unless what the group does to counteract it blows my fucking mind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen

Queen

Idol
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
4,169
Reaction score
13,475
Points
31,974
Gender
Female
Who sang those pre-choruses and do they have solos :nakypog:
Honestly, I don't know Pentagon members that well and only know a few ONF members. I think the red-haired dude was ONF's Hyojin, the grey/silver haired guy might be PTG's Hui, and I think the white haired one was ONF's MK but I'm not sure
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)