Noisy songs ≠ bad songs / Noisy songs = bad songs (1 Viewer)

[Myco]

What's your opinion on this?
Which of the two is more true to your believe?

Imo it depends on the "noise", it can sound either good or bad to me.
It seems like most noisy songs have it for the hype effect, which most of the times don't fit the song at all cuz it's just made for that purpose instead of building it into the song to have a structure with the rest of it.

What do you consider a very good "noisy" song?
Call me biased or anything but imo 'Callin' by A.C.E is a great noisy song. You can hear how it blends in well especially when the drop goes into the new verse. And it isn't overused, it's just two times the noisy drop gets its spotlight, which plays a huge role into how much you can endure it.

 

[Ineul_Ze]

I think it depends.

NCT's Fire Truck is noisy and I hated that song and still do. NCT's Cherry Bomb is a noisy song but I love it. I think it all depends on the type of noise.

 

[Administrator2]

Noisy songs ≠ bad songs

 

[kuro]

I think it depends.

NCT's Fire Truck is noisy and I hated that song and still do. NCT's Cherry Bomb is a noisy song but I love it. I think it all depends on the type of noise.

funny, I hate both songs lol
I am not a noisy song lover

 

[Myco]

funny, I hate both songs lol
I am not a noisy song lover

Do you like BTS's Not Today tho?

 

[Abeamus]

Well i'd only describe a song as noisy if it's noisy in a bad way but in general songs of that nature could be good or bad and just being noisy doesn't immediately make it horrible.

Can't think of an example of a good song though.

 

[kuro]

Do you like BTS's Not Today tho?

:llama_eyes:

 

[Administrator2]

Well i'd only describe a song as noisy if it's noisy in a bad way but in general songs of that nature could be good or bad and just being noisy doesn't immediately make it horrible.

Can't think of an example of a good song though.

RBB?

 

[Abeamus]

RBB?

If that's the good option then i'm changing my answer

 

[Myco]

If that's the good option then i'm changing my answer

LOL

 

[Administrator2]

If that's the good option then i'm changing my answer

Oh, I misread. I thought you needed a noisy bad song.

 

[Administrator2]

If that's the good option then i'm changing my answer

CLC's Hobgoblin?

 

[bulletproof]

I like noisy songs usually. Not all, obvi. I like songs like Not today, Idol, Fantastic baby, Bang bang bang. I think the genre means a lot to me. SM’s noisy songs for example are usually not my cup of tea

 

[Abeamus]

Oh, I misread. I thought you needed a noisy bad song.

Oh no there's definitely no shortage of those :oof_tea:

CLC's Hobgoblin?

That'd fit for good perfectly