About My New Username... (1 Viewer)

Moguri

.
Joined
31 December 2022
Messages
66,771
Reactions Received
98,455
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
344,583
Ship
Wreck
I admit to nothing my friend
I am the nicest happy go lucky neutral person you will ever find
you called yourself a sith lord and stated that you intend to forcefully end the lifes of your sith lord competetion.

I may be jumping to conclusions here.. but for me it is not nessecary for you to admit to anything at all anymore! :passcodea:
 
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,711
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
you called yourself a sith lord and stated that you intend to forcefully end the lifes of your sith lord competetion.

I may be jumping to conclusions here.. but for me it is not nessecary for you to admit to anything at all anymore! :passcodea:
see above
is the removal of another evil person not a good deed in an of itself? or do you believe that the intent matters more than the outcome?

ie. do the ends justify the means
 

Moguri

.
Joined
31 December 2022
Messages
66,771
Reactions Received
98,455
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
344,583
Ship
Wreck
see above
is the removal of another evil person not a good deed in an of itself? or do you believe that the intent matters more than the outcome?

ie. do the ends justify the means
your murderous intentions are based on the fact that you are an evil sith lord though, so the core problem is not fixed, even if you smite him down with all your hatred. It will just make you stronger
 
  • Like
Reactions: Selfmate
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,711
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
your murderous intentions are based on the fact that you are an evil sith lord though, so the core problem is not fixed, even if you smite him down with all your hatred. It will just make you stronger
whilst true but still doesn't answer the question - even if I'm doing the act because of selfish intentions does the end outcome justify the result? (i.e the removal of a fellow evil sith)
thus you would also say that those who do deeds which are beneficial but because of non-altruist intentions aren't really a good deed?
ie. a person donates to charity only because of the tax benefits?
 

Moguri

.
Joined
31 December 2022
Messages
66,771
Reactions Received
98,455
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
344,583
Ship
Wreck
whilst true but still doesn't answer the question - even if I'm doing the act because of selfish intentions does the end outcome justify the result? (i.e the removal of a fellow evil sith)
thus you would also say that those who do deeds which are beneficial but because of non-altruist intentions aren't really a good deed?
ie. a person donates to charity only because of the tax benefits?
I think your comparison do not make too much sense, because even a selfish person that wants to save taxes by doing something good, probably has no further intentions to dominate the entire galaxy. Could you say the same? :face:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Selfmate
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,711
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
I think your comparison do not make too much sense, because even a selfish person that wants to save taxes by doing something good, probably has no further intentions to dominate the entire galaxy. Could you say the same? :face:
but the question is why does it not make sense (to you...since the intent in both situations is non-altruistic but the outcome is a good outcome no?
I mean in both situations the end benefits the doer of the action
or are you of the opinion that the benefit to the doer < than the overall good? is that your perspective?
 

Moguri

.
Joined
31 December 2022
Messages
66,771
Reactions Received
98,455
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
344,583
Ship
Wreck
but the question is why does it not make sense (to you...since the intent in both situations is non-altruistic but the outcome is a good outcome no?
I mean in both situations the end benefits the doer of the action
or are you of the opinion that the benefit to the doer < than the overall good? is that your perspective?
I see the argument you are trying to make, but I will continue to ignore it, as it does not apply here

yes in theory, having less sith lords overall is better

but we also need to consider, that the opposing sith lord could keep you busy from causing harm to others, so potentially less harm is done overall. Also like I already said, striking him down could make you a lot more powerful. One more powerful sith lord could be a bigger problem than many weaker ones. This is the entire idea of the rule of 2, as you probably know only too well, your deception will not work on me! :gengarpout:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Selfmate

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Viewing thread