Which former members are essentially erased from their groups? (1 Viewer)

[athenaaa]

Woojin was basically erased from Stray Kids after his departure from the group. They rereleased songs without his vocals in it. Has this happened to other groups?​

 

[Ahsoka]

Junhyeok from Day6. They also rereleased songs without him afterwards.

 

[Moguri]

Woojin was basically erased from Stray Kids after his departure from the group. They rereleased songs without his vocals in it. Has this happened to other groups?​

Junhyeok from Day6. They also rereleased songs without him afterwards.

what do you mean by that, they removed him from older songs?

Garam from Le Sserafim comes to mind too, they also re-released all the songs form he firs album with other members singing her parts

 

[Ahsoka]

what do you mean by that, they removed him from older songs?

Garam from Le Sserafim comes to mind too, they also re-released all the songs form he firs album with other members singing her parts

Day6s first mini was re-recorded after he left, with other members taking his portions

 

[athenaaa]

what do you mean by that, they removed him from older songs?

Garam from Le Sserafim comes to mind too, they also re-released all the songs form he firs album with other members singing her parts

Stray kids released a new album with re recordings and they members took on Woojin’s previous lines.

 

[Moguri]

Day6s first mini was re-recorded after he left, with other members taking his portions

Stray kids released a new album with re recordings and they members took on Woojin’s previous lines.

ok so the same in all 3 cases

 

[Ahsoka]

ok so the same in all 3 cases

Yep Le Sserafim stopping JYPs monopoly

 

[Moguri]

Yep Le Sserafim stopping JYPs monopoly

now I wonder if NMIXX re-recorded songs after Jinni left

 

[lexus]

Nam Taehyun since Winner don't acknowledge him anymore and they've re-released songs without his vocals. They also make it known that they are four members and not five

 

[Selfmate]

like all of them????

Garam
Jini
Soojin

 

[SkylesDaughter]

i can name some that haven’t been erased
like soojin and possibly wonho

 

[LoveYooShaSha]

like all of them????

Garam
Jini
Soojin

As per above, being erased might mean erased from discography, kinda, by re-releasing songs originally sung by that member with a version newly recorded without that member's contribution. So jini n soojin(unless I missed it) might not count here. (Idk as I'm not aware of earlier songs by gidle being re-released, no idea abt jini either)

Jessica from SNSD, idt any re-released songs like tat happened but I definitely count her as being essentially erased in some way as far as media(1 in particular)/some parts of internet hv no reference to Jessica at all.

 

[Selfmate]

As per above, being erased might mean erased from discography, kinda, by re-releasing songs originally sung by that member with a version newly recorded without that member's contribution. So jini n soojin(unless I missed it) might not count here. (Idk as I'm not aware of earlier songs by gidle being re-released, no idea abt jini either)

Jessica from SNSD, idt any re-released songs like tat happened but I definitely count her as being essentially erased in some way as far as media(1 in particular)/some parts of internet hv no reference to Jessica at all.

that's one interpretation of the word
the other is erased not from the discography but rather erased from their vocabulary
like jini, soojin and garam's (and jessica I guess) names basically are "he who must not be named"

 

[DaisySkies]

Woojin was basically erased from Stray Kids after his departure from the group. They rereleased songs without his vocals in it. Has this happened to other groups?​

i was going to say woojin too lol
but he has made his name clear with his solo career

oh! and jinni from nmixx bc after she left, they removed all the pictures of her on their insta