give me a song and i'll rate it (1 Viewer)

[lunaria]

the only acceptable answer is 10/10

this song always reminded me of "rumor", and i mean that in the best way possible. there's something haunting about the way they sing, and the instrumental gives it a somewhat dark and magical feel. the song is obviously a dance track, but it has a more subdued atmosphere that's quite calming. it's like being lost in a dream. 9/10 (sorry i couldn't give it a 10 forgive me juseyo )

 

[Michael]

Okay then....... I think you'll definitely like both Shingeki and Zembukiminoseida.

 

[milk]

 

[lunaria]

Okay then....... I think you'll definitely like both Shingeki and Zembukiminoseida.

1. i enjoyed the chanting in the beginning and the distortion of the vocals. the whispering is a nice touch as well. this song is full of feverish energy and feels rather infectious, in a good way. 7.5/10

2. i love how deep the girls' voices are here at times, and their almost rap-like delivery of their lines during some of the verses. their vocals are refreshing and unique. the instrumental is complex and packed with all sorts of different sounds, which has the potential to sound overwhelming, yet it still coalesces and the end product is pleasing to the ear. 8/10

i like seeing the diversity in sound within the k-rock genre, thank you.

 

[lunaria]

apparently blackpink likes this song, so i had to listen to it as well. i can tell you that i've never heard this before now, and that my jaw dropped when i heard the first line. i never swear aloud and i'm really not used to hearing such blatantly explicit language. it has shock value and therefore has memorability, though i can't say that will necessarily translate into longevity. one of the good things i can say about this song is that both women have impressive flow and nice tones. the beat, and the instrumental overall, is minimal, which is effective here since your focus falls solely to the striking lyrics. still, i find the instrumental too bare for my taste, and i don't enjoy exclusively rap-driven songs if the lyrics aren't anything meaningful, so this was really not for me. not to offend anyone, but i find the lyrics rather inane as well. songs about sensuality can be done well, but it's still not my favorite topic, especially expressed in such a brazen way. but props to cardi and megan for making a song about it anyways !! more power to them and just because i don't like it doesn't mean it's objectively bad. the flawless rapping ultimately saves the song from being less than a 3/10

i hope that wasn't too harsh, but this song was really not my cup of tea thanks for suggesting it though

 

[Michael]

1. i enjoyed the chanting in the beginning and the distortion of the vocals. the whispering is a nice touch as well. this song is full of feverish energy and feels rather infectious, in a good way. 7.5/10

2. i love how deep the girls' voices are here at times, and their almost rap-like delivery of their lines during some of the verses. their vocals are refreshing and unique. the instrumental is complex and packed with all sorts of different sounds, which has the potential to sound overwhelming, yet it still coalesces and the end product is pleasing to the ear. 8/10

i like seeing the diversity in sound within the k-rock genre, thank you.

You mean jrock?

I subscribe to a lot of groups on yt and usually forget about many of them. I have subscribed to Shingeki for quite a while now; and it's only recently that I began warming up to them. It's badass with heavy rock.

I know Zenbukiminoseida for much longer. It's a cute group with a touch of insanity on it that departs from the wholesome looking cute idol groups of mainstream. The first mv I watched from them was funny and a little insane. I was amazed on how cute and yet insane the girls looked like.


BTW, to the best of my understanding; the name Zenbukiminoseida means "it's all your fault".

 

[milk]

apparently blackpink likes this song, so i had to listen to it as well. i can tell you that i've never heard this before now, and that my jaw dropped when i heard the first line. i never swear aloud and i'm really not used to hearing such blatantly explicit language. it has shock value and therefore has memorability, though i can't say that will necessarily translate into longevity. one of the good things i can say about this song is that both women have impressive flow and nice tones. the beat, and the instrumental overall, is minimal, which is effective here since your focus falls solely to the striking lyrics. still, i find the instrumental too bare for my taste, and i don't enjoy exclusively rap-driven songs if the lyrics aren't anything meaningful, so this was really not for me. not to offend anyone, but i find the lyrics rather inane as well. songs about sensuality can be done well, but it's still not my favorite topic, especially expressed in such a brazen way. but props to cardi and megan for making a song about it anyways !! more power to them and just because i don't like it doesn't mean it's objectively bad. the flawless rapping ultimately saves the song from being less than a 3/10

i hope that wasn't too harsh, but this song was really not my cup of tea thanks for suggesting it though

omg I didn't know it was your first time hearing it!!! LOL! sorry for your ears, i feel so guilty now i actually posted as a joke and assumed you've heard it before sksksksks. HAHAHA I love your review, it's fine! I'm not a big fan of the song either but it's fun to meme with it LMAO!!!! it's VERY explicit, i agree and i hope you don't judge me now

 

[lunaria]

omg I didn't know it was your first time hearing it!!! LOL! sorry for your ears, i feel so guilty now i actually posted as a joke and assumed you've heard it before sksksksks. HAHAHA I love your review, it's fine! I'm not a big fan of the song either but it's fun to meme with it LMAO!!!! it's VERY explicit, i agree and i hope you don't judge me now

i thought it was a joke, but i didn't want to offend you by assuming so, so i took it seriously i would never judge you !! it was funny !

 

[lunaria]

You mean jrock?

I subscribe to a lot of groups on yt and usually forget about many of them. I have subscribed to Shingeki for quite a while now; and it's only recently that I began warming up to them. It's badass with heavy rock.

I know Zenbukiminoseida for much longer. It's a cute group with a touch of insanity on it that departs from the wholesome looking cute idol groups of mainstream. The first mv I watched from them was funny and a little insane. I was amazed on how cute and yet insane the girls looked like.


BTW, to the best of my understanding; the name Zenbukiminoseida means "it's all your fault".

yes, j-rock sorry !! i posted that rather late last night. i do know the difference, i'm just an idiot the languages and styles are veeery different from one another.

i love the contrast between their soft vocals and the heavy instrumental. it's really interesting. their concept is unique and really shows through their music !! 8/10

 

[Michael]

Seems this thread is already dying; but I want to keep posting here. I had already posted a mv about Kaqriyoterror; you said it's badass. Here is the post:

give me a song and i'll rate it - K-Pop Source — Keeping the K-Pop Forum Spirit Alive

i enjoyed the orchestral instrumental. for being the "weakest" singer in bts, his voice is still very pleasing to hear and he can hit impressive notes. i love how meaningful this song is ! 8/10 :pepeheart:

kpopsource.com

This group breaks every rule about what's an idol. I'll just leave here these two videos.