Butter's kpop discography rates (3 Viewers)

butter · 15 February 2024

MAMAMOO DISCOGRAPHY RATE - Part 1 (71 - 105th)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
71	Better Than I Thought	BLUE;S	5.55
72	Friday Night	Melting	5.50
73	Better	reality in BLACK	5.50
74	Sleep Talk	-	5.45
75	Good Night	TRAVEL	5.45
76	Another Day	-	5.40
77	Don't Be Happy	-	5.40
78	Recipe	Melting	5.35
79	Ten Nights	reality in BLACK	5.35
80	Morning	BLUE;S	5.30
81	Be Calm	Yellow Flower	5.30
82	Emotion	Melting	5.25
83	Spring Fever	Yellow Flower	5.25
84	Double Trouble Couple	-	5.20
85	Star Wind Flower Sun	Yellow Flower	5.20
86	I Miss You	Melting	5.15
87	ZzZz	reality in BLACK	5.10
88	Taller Than You	Melting	5.10
89	Nada Sousou	-	5.05
90	Rude Boy	Yellow Flower	5.05
91	Just	Melting	5.00
92	Heeheehaheho	-	5.00
93	A Memory for Life	-	4.95
94	High Tension	reality in BLACK	4.90
95	Happier Than Ever	-	4.85
96	Angel	Memory	4.70
97	Universe	reality in BLACK	4.65
98	a little bit	Pink Funky	4.55
99	Love Lane	-	4.50
100	rEALITY	reality in BLACK	4.45
101	Shampoo	-	4.40
102	I'm Your Fan	reality in BLACK	4.00
103	You Don't Know Me	-	3.10
104	Smile	-	3.00
105	Everyday	-	2.70

ani07 · 16 February 2024

pls check out hoppipolla and their solo stuff also if u have time :)

butter · 16 February 2024

MAMAMOO DISCOGRAPHY RATE - Part 2 (36 - 70th)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
36	No no no	Pink Funky	7.25
37	Just Believe in Love	-	7.20
38	mumumumuch	-	7.15
39	Rainy Season	RED MOON	7.00
40	Hello Mama	reality in BLACK	6.95
41	I Do Me	-	6.90
42	Chuck	TRAVEL	6.90
43	WOW	-	6.85
44	Diamond	TRAVEL	6.80
45	You in My Dreams	-	6.80
46	Love & Hate	Purple	6.75
47	Self Camera	Pink Funky	6.70
48	Freakin Shoes	Pink Funky	6.65
49	DAB DAB	Memory	6.60
50	Gleam	-	6.60
51	AYA	TRAVEL	6.50
52	Finally	Purple	6.50
53	25	White Wind	6.45
54	Cat Fight	Melting	6.40
55	4×4ever	reality in BLACK	6.20
56	Funky Boy	Melting	6.15
57	woo hoo	-	6.10
58	SELFISH	RED MOON	6.05
59	Sky! Sky!	RED MOON	6.00
60	My Hometown	Melting	5.95
61	Moderato	Memory	5.85
62	4season (Outro)	White Wind	5.85
63	Gentleman	-	5.80
64	Midnight Summer Dream	RED MOON	5.75
65	No More Drama	BLUE;S	5.75
66	I Love Too	Memory	5.70
67	Where R U	White Wind	5.70
68	LOVE	-	5.65
69	Bad Bye	White Wind	5.60
70	I Miss You	-	5.60

butter · 17 February 2024

MAMAMOO DISCOGRAPHY RATE - Part 3 (1 - 35th)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	HIP	reality in BLACK	9.90
2	You're the Best	Melting	9.75
3	Yes I Am	Purple	9.70
4	Décalcomanie	Memory	9.60
5	Egotistic	RED MOON	9.40
6	Piano Man	-	9.00
7	Where Are We Now	-	8.95
8	WANNA BE MYSELF	-	8.90
9	Age Gag	Purple	8.80
10	Destiny	reality in BLACK	8.70
11	Words Don't Come Easy	Melting	8.60
12	Starry Night	Yellow Flower	8.55
13	Um Oh Ah Yeh	Pink Funky	8.50
14	Waggy	White Wind	8.45
15	Mr-Ambiguous	-	8.40
16	AHH OOP!	Pink Funky	8.25
17	1,2,3 Eoi!	-	8.20
18	4 Flowers	-	8.15
19	gogobebe	White Wind	8.10
20	NEW YORK	Memory	8.05
21	Travel	TRAVEL	8.00
22	Wind Flower	BLUE;S	7.95
23	Dingga	-	7.90
24	L.I.E.C	-	7.85
25	Da Ra Da	Purple	7.80
26	ILLELA	-	7.75
27	Baton Touch	-	7.75
28	Girl Crush	-	7.70
29	My Star	White Wind	7.70
30	Memory	Memory	7.65
31	Strange Day	-	7.60
32	Sleep in the Car	RED MOON	7.55
33	Peppermint Chocolate	-	7.50
34	Hello	BLUE;S	7.40
35	Paint Me	Yellow Flower	7.35

butter · 19 February 2024

👠 MAMAMOO DISCOGRAPHY RATE 👠
as of June 2026

Part 1: 71st - 105th
Part 2: 36th - 70th
Part 3: 1st - 35th

#	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	Purple	2017	Mini album	7.910
2	Pink Funky	2015	Mini album	6.983
3	RED MOON	2018	Mini album	6.958
4	Memory	2016	Mini album	6.879
5	White Wind	2019	Mini album	6.836
6	TRAVEL	2020	Mini album	6.730
7	BLUE;S	2018	Mini album	6.390
8	Melting	2016	Mini album	6.200
9	Yellow Flower	2018	Mini album	6.117
10	reality IN BLACK	2019	Full album	5.973

10/10 songs	0
% skips	62.86%
👠 Avg. Song Score	6.521
👠 Precision Score	6.566
👠 Butter Score	6.388
👠 Verdict	Decent

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	104	#83	6.371	Decent	N/A - first tracking data
-	-	#95 (-12)	6.371	-	2025 year-end rank and score
7 June 2026	105 (+1)	#103 (-8)	6.388 (+0.017) *PEAK*	Decent	New song "4 Flowers"

SOLO & SUBUNITS (not included in the group rate)

Artist	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
Hwasa	O	2024	Mini album	7.307
Hwasa	María	2020	Mini album	6.875
Whee In	WHEE	2022	Mini album	6.820
Solar	COLOURS	2024	Mini album	6.792
Solar	容: FACE	2022	Mini album	6.600
Whee In	IN the mood	2023	Full album	6.514
Whee In	Redd	2021	Mini album	6.200
Moonbyul	laundri	2025	Mini album	6.167
Moonbyul	6equence	2022	Mini album	6.075
MAMAMOO+	TWO RABBITS	2023	Mini album	5.988
Moonbyul	Dark Side of the Moon	2020	Mini album	5.740
Moonbyul	Starlit of Muse	2024	Full album	5.596

Hwasa	Chili
Hwasa	FOMO
Hwasa	So Cute
Hwasa	TWIT
Moonbyul	Is This Love?
Moonbyul	MOMENTUM
Solar	Spit It Out
Solar & Moonbyul w/ MISMOLLY, TURNS	Bada Boom

butter · 21 February 2024

🎟 MOMOLAND DISCOGRAPHY RATE 🎟
as of February 2026

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	Wonderful Love	-	9.80
2	Freeze	Freeze!	9.65
3	VeryVery	Fun To The World	9.50
4	Bboom Bboom	GREAT!	9.45
5	BAAM	Fun To The World	9.35
6	Jjan! Koong! Kwang!	Welcome to MOMOLAND	8.75
7	Light Up	Show Me	8.55
8	I'm So Hot	Show Me	8.50
9	Same Same	GREAT!	8.20
10	Ready or Not	-	8.10
11	Yummy Yummy Love (feat. NATTI NATASHA)	-	7.80
12	Thumbs Up	-	7.65
13	Welcome to MOMOLAND	Welcome to MOMOLAND	7.30
14	TIKI TAKA	-	7.20
15	white spring	-	7.15
16	Chiri Chiri	-	6.65
17	Orgel	Freeze!	6.45
18	Uh-gi-yeo-cha	Welcome to MOMOLAND	6.40
19	Love Sick	Welcome to MOMOLAND	6.15
20	Starry Night	-	6.05
21	Bingo Game	Fun To The World	5.65
22	RODEO	-	5.55
23	Falling U	Show Me	5.50
24	Curious	GREAT!	5.45
25	Wrap Me In Plastic (feat. CHROMANCE)	-	5.40
26	Pinky Love	-	5.35
27	What Planet Are You From?	Freeze!	5.30
28	Hug Me	-	5.25
29	Love Is Only You (feat. ERIK)	-	5.15
30	Fly	GREAT!	5.05
31	BANANA CHACHA	-	5.00
32	What You Want	Show Me	4.90
33	Merry Go Round	-	4.85
34	Only One You	Fun To The World	4.55
35	I Like It	Freeze!	4.50
36	Dream Song	-	3.80
37	Holiday	Show Me	2.60

#	Album Title	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	Fun To The World	2018	Mini album	7.263
2	Welcome to MOMOLAND	2016	Mini album	7.150
3	GREAT!	2018	Mini album	7.038
4	Freeze!	2017	Mini album	6.475
5	Show Me	2019	Mini album	6.010

10/10 songs	0
% skips	59.46%
🎟 Avg. Song Score	6.554
🎟 Precision Score	3.315
🎟 Butter Score	5.959
🎟 Verdict	Trainee

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	35	#99	5.939	Trainee	N/A - first tracking data
14 September 2025	36 (+1)	#102 (-3)	5.928 (-0.011)	Trainee	New song "RODEO" below average of the group
-	-	#112 (-10)	5.928	-	2025 year-end rank and score
2 February 2026	37 (+1)	#114 (-2)	5.959 (+0.031) *PEAK*	Trainee	New song "white spring"

butter · 25 February 2024

🏆 2019 Butter Awards 🏆

🎶 Song of the Year

🥇 🚨 NCT 127 – Superhuman
🥈 🍳 Stray Kids – Side Effects
🥉 🍭 TWICE – Feel Special
🍰 Red Velvet – Zimzalabim
🛫 WayV – Love Talk
💡 ONF – Moscow Moscow
🎸 DAY6 – Time of Our Life
🍳 Stray Kids – MIROH
🪐 EXO – Obsession
🐯 SuperM – Jopping
🛫 WayV – Moonwalk
🪐 CHEN – Shall we?
🪐 D.O. – That's okay
🔌 SULLI – Dorothy
🍳 Stray Kids – Double Knot
🍳 Stray Kids – Neverending Story
💣 BTS – Mikrokosmos
🐊 MONSTA X – Follow
🎐 Dreamcatcher – Silent Night
🏴‍☠️ ATEEZ – HALA HALA
🏙 YUKIKA – NEON
🔌 SULLI – On The Moon
💎 SEVENTEEN – Back It Up
👑 HYO – Badster
👠 MAMAMOO – HIP

💿 Album of the Year

🥇 🪐 CHEN – April and a Flower
🥈 🍳 Stray Kids – Clé 1: MIROH
🥉 🍰 Red Velvet – The ReVe Festival Day 1
🚨 NCT 127 – NCT #127 WE ARE SUPERHUMAN
🐯 SuperM – SuperM
🍭 TWICE – FANCY YOU
💣 BTS – MAP OF THE SOUL: PERSONA
🍰 Red Velvet – The ReVe Festival Finale
🍭 TWICE – Feel Special
🪐 CHEN – Dear My Dear

💿 Album of the Year - Full-length

🍰 Red Velvet – The ReVe Festival Finale

🎤 Artist of the Year

🍳 Stray Kids

Top 100 Songs Playlist:

Best of 2019 Playlist:

🍈 Top 100 entries:

TBA

butter · 26 February 2024

How it works:

I give each song by a specific group a grade from 0 to 10, and afterwards calculate the average score for each album of said group and an overall average for all the songs of that group.

Since the group final scores heavily depend on the number of songs a group has released (groups with few songs can have very volatile averages, so outliers, both extremely good and extremely bad songs, will weigh a lot in the group's overall score). To solve that issue, I will be using a statistical formula that will also take into account the reliability of a group score. Which means, a group with 100 will have a higher reliability score than a group with 20 songs. In order to also not penalize newer groups in detriment of older groups with bigger discography, I've decided to give a 90% weight to the average song rate and 10% to the reliability score. The final adjusted score, which I will call Butter score, is the ultimate stat that will be used to determine the kpop group discography ranking. Please check it below.

Each group will also have their own Verdict. This is a title I will attribute to each group, and takes into account both average rate and butter score.

	Minimum number of songs	Average rate (how good the songs are)	Precision score (how reliable the discography is)	Butter score (90% avg, 10% precision)	Brief description
*Sublime*	>100	>8.000	>6.800	>7.500	The ultimate best. Consistently superb quality.
*Extraordinary*	>50	>7.500	>6.000	>7.200	High quality discographies that, with time, could become Sublime.
*Rising Star*	<50	>7.500	3.000 - 5.500	>6.800	Groups with small discographies but with potential to grow into Extraordinary.
*Unicorn*	<35	>7.500	-	>6.200	Groups with smaller and/or less consistent discographies but very impressive. Too early to tell whether they can be Extraordinary.
*Legend*	>200	>7.000	>7.500	>7.000	Very good and extremely consistent, long and sturdy discography.
*Impressive*	>=50	>7.300	4.000 - 7.000	>6.800	High quality discographies with potential to become even better. One step below Extraordinary.
*Solid*	-	6.600 - 7.300	>5.800	>6.500	Good, reliable and consistent, but that are not (yet) my absolute favorites.
Sophomore	40 - 90	>7.000	-	>6.000	Groups with potential to grow into Impressive.
*Rookie*	<40	7.000 - 7.500	-	>6.000	Potential to become Unicorns or Strong.
*Decent*	-	>6.400	5.500 - 7.000	>6.300	Middle of the road, but consistently so.
*Mixed Bag*	>30	>6.500	<5.500	>6.000	Quite inconsistent and/or messy discographies, but not necessarily bad.
*Lackluster*	>40	>6.000	>5.000	>6.100	Not convincing, but still has a couple really good songs.
*Trainee*	<30	>6.000	<3.500	>5.300	Underdeveloped and too small. Not impressing me much so far still has a lot of room to grow.
*Weak*	>40	>5.500	>3.500	<6.100	Has had time to establish themselves but remains weak.
*Flop*	>40	<5.500	-	<5.500	Just... not good.

butter · 28 February 2024

ONEUS DISCOGRAPHY RATE - PART 1 (68 - 101st)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
68	Intro: Window (feat. Choi Ye Lim)	BLOOD MOON	6.05
69	A Thousand Stars	808	6.00
70	Intro: EDEN	MALUS	6.00
71	Life is Beautiful	BLOOD MOON	5.95
72	Level Up	FLY WITH US	5.95
73	Intro: Who Got the Joker	TRICKSTER	5.90
74	I.P.U	DEVIL	5.90
75	Intro: LIGHT US	LIGHT US	5.85
76	RELOAD	5x	5.85
77	We're in Love	BLOOD MOON	5.80
78	Youth	DEVIL	5.80
79	Epilogue	La Dolce Vita	5.75
80	IKUK	Dear.M	5.70
81	Leftover	DEVIL	5.55
82	Intro: LIVED	LIVED	5.55
83	Firebomb	TRICKSTER	5.50
84	Gravitation	MALUS	5.45
85	Red Thread	LIGHT US	5.45
86	Dead or Alive	LIVED	5.40
87	Intro: Fly me to the moon	FLY WITH US	5.35
88	HITOKOTO	-	5.35
89	We Run For Youth	FIRST LIGHT : 井	5.30
90	LOST	808	5.30
91	Who You Are	BLOOD MOON	5.30
92	TIME MACHINE	5x	5.25
93	koisii	-	5.20
94	By Chance	FIRST LIGHT : 井	5.15
95	kiseki	-	5.00
96	Never Ending Us	FIRST LIGHT : 井	4.95
97	HERO	LIGHT US	4.65
98	Plastic Flower	FLY WITH US	4.60
99	Intro: Devil is in the detail	DEVIL	4.55
100	English Girl	RAISE US	4.30
101	KATOKI	Dopamine	4.00

butter · 29 February 2024

ONEUS DISCOGRAPHY RATE - PART 2 (34 - 67th)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
34	BBUSYEO	DEVIL	7.40
35	Skydivin'	TRICKSTER	7.35
36	Stand By	FLY WITH US	7.35
37	Polarity	BINARY CODE	7.30
38	Only One	-	7.25
39	What You Doing?	DEVIL	7.20
40	Hide and Seek	-	7.00
41	CRAZY & CRAZY	LIGHT US	6.95
42	808	808	6.90
43	White Night	RAISE US	6.85
44	Runaway	FIRST LIGHT : 井	6.80
45	Happy Birthday	BINARY CODE	6.80
46	Don't know why	Dopamine	6.75
47	Dizzy	LIVED	6.70
48	W	Dear.M	6.70
49	EYE CONTACT	LIGHT US	6.65
50	We Are Young	Dear.M	6.60
51	Baila Conmigo	La Dolce Vita	6.60
52	Connect with US	BINARY CODE	6.50
53	Leader	Dopamine	6.50
54	Fragile	TRICKSTER	6.45
55	Incomplete	DEVIL	6.45
56	Fly To You	-	6.40
57	Lion Heart	DEVIL	6.40
58	FULL MOON	MALUS	6.35
59	Yes or No	BLOOD MOON	6.35
60	Same Scent	MALUS	6.30
61	In My Arms	808	6.25
62	Rewind	DEVIL	6.20
63	Intro: Beggin' you	La Dolce Vita	6.20
64	Intro: LETHE	PYGMALION	6.15
65	BAD	5x	6.15
66	Blue Sky	FLY WITH US	6.10
67	Unforgettable	PYGMALION	6.05

butter · 29 February 2024

ONEUS DISCOGRAPHY RATE - PART 3 (1 - 33rd)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	LUNA	BLOOD MOON	9.90
2	Valkyrie	LIGHT US	9.55
3	Rupert's Drop	Dear.M	9.05
4	X	5x	9.00
5	Mr. Wolf	TRICKSTER	9.00
6	LOVE ME or LOSER	5x	8.90
7	Twilight	RAISE US	8.90
8	BLACK MIRROR	BINARY CODE	8.85
9	Simulation	La Dolce Vita	8.85
10	Say Yes!	FIRST LIGHT : 井	8.80
11	TO BE OR NOT TO BE	LIVED	8.75
12	COME BACK HOME	LIVED	8.60
13	Halley's Comet	PYGMALION	8.55
14	Shut Up Batgo Crazy Hot!	BLOOD MOON	8.50
15	ECHO	PYGMALION	8.25
16	ERASE ME	PYGMALION	8.10
17	STUPID LOVE	MALUS	8.05
18	Grenade	-	8.00
19	Dopamine	Dopamine	7.95
20	A Song Written Easily	-	7.85
21	ZigZag	LIGHT US	7.80
22	No diggity	DEVIL	7.80
23	Bring It On	TRICKSTER	7.75
24	Mermaid	MALUS	7.75
25	Under	-	7.70
26	STOP & MOVE	-	7.70
27	BingBing	RAISE US	7.65
28	Airplane	LIVED	7.60
29	DEVILISH LOVE	Dear.M	7.60
30	Now	RAISE US	7.55
31	When You're Close To Me	-	7.50
32	LIT	FLY WITH US	7.50
33	Intro: Time	RAISE US	7.45

butter · 7 March 2024

🕯 ONEUS DISCOGRAPHY RATE 🕯
as of October 2026

Part 1: 101st - 68th
Part 2: 67th - 34th
Part 3: 33rd - 1st

#	Album Title	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	PYGMALION	2023	Mini album	7.420
2	BINARY CODE	2021	Mini album	7.363
3	Dear.M	2025	Full album	7.130
4	RAISE US	2019	Mini album	7.117
5	LIVED	2020	Mini album	7.100
6	5x	2025	Mini album	7.030
7	TRICKSTER	2022	Mini album	6.992
8	La Dolce Vita	2023	Mini album	6.850
9	BLOOD MOON	2021	Mini album	6.836
10	LIGHT US	2019	Mini album	6.700
11	MALUS	2022	Mini album	6.658
12	DEVIL	2021	Full album	6.325
13	Dopamine	2022	Mini album	6.300
14	FIRST LIGHT : 井	2026	Mini album	6.200
15	FLY WITH US	2019	Mini album	6.142
16	808	2019	Single album	6.113

10/10 songs	0
% skips	60.40%
🕯 Avg. Song Score	6.756
🕯 Precision Score	7.802
🕯 Butter Score	6.746
🕯 Verdict	Solid

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	90	#57	6.692	Solid	N/A - first tracking data
29 October 2025	91 (+1)	#62 (-5)	6.700 (+0.008)	Solid	Residual increase in precision score
21 December 2025	91 (=)	#63 (-1)	6.707 (+0.007)	Solid	Year-end adjustments
-	-	#64 (-1)	6.707	-	2025 year-end rank and score
14 February 2026	94 (+3)	#62 (+2)	6.755 (+0.048)	Solid	3 new songs
11 July 2026	96 (+2)	#67 (-5)	6.760 (+0.005) *PEAK*	Solid	2 new songs
10 October 2026	101 (+5)	#76 (-9)	6.746 (-0.014)	Solid	New mini "FIRST LIGHT : 井"

ONEWE and ONEUS	LAST SONG
ONEWE and ONEUS	STAY

butter · 14 March 2024

🎒 XIKERS DISCOGRAPHY RATE 🎒
as of June 2026

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	DO OR DIE	HOUSE OF TRICKY: HOW TO PLAY	9.90
2	We Don't Stop	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Trial And Error	9.80
3	SUPERPOWER (Peak)	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WRECKING THE HOUSE	9.75
4	Supercalifragilistic	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Trial And Error	9.50
5	Red Sun	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Trial And Error	9.40
6	See You Play (S'il vous plaît)	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WRECKING THE HOUSE	9.35
7	OKay	ROUTE ZERO : The ORA	9.20
8	Every Flavor Jelly	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Trial And Error	9.10
9	BACK OFF	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WATCH OUT	8.85
10	Are You Serious?	-	8.65
11	Tsuki (Lunatic)	-	8.60
12	Bittersweet	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WATCH OUT	8.55
13	WITCH	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WATCH OUT	8.45
14	Roller Coaster	HOUSE OF TRICKY: SPUR	8.30
15	BREATHE	HOUSE OF TRICKY: SPUR	8.10
16	HIGHWAY	HOUSE OF TRICKY: SPUR	8.05
17	You Hide We Seek	HOUSE OF TRICKY: SPUR	7.85
18	Blurry	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WRECKING THE HOUSE	7.75
19	100%	-	7.70
20	Sunny Side	HOUSE OF TRICKY: HOW TO PLAY	7.65
21	ICONIC	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WRECKING THE HOUSE	7.65
22	Ghost Rider	ROUTE ZERO : The ORA	7.55
23	Run	HOUSE OF TRICKY: HOW TO PLAY	7.50
24	Trophy	ROUTE ZERO : The ORA	7.45
25	Cool	-	7.45
26	ROCKSTAR	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Doorbell Ringing	7.40
27	Hang Around	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WATCH OUT	7.35
28	Rock Your Body	HOUSE OF TRICKY: SPUR	7.35
29	XIKEY	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Doorbell Ringing	7.30
30	Graffiti	ROUTE ZERO : The ORA	7.30
31	Up All Night	-	7.25
32	Break A Leg	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Trial And Error	7.20
33	TRICKY HOUSE	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Doorbell Ringing	7.15
34	Doorbell Ringing	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Doorbell Ringing	7.05
35	Koong	HOUSE OF TRICKY: HOW TO PLAY	6.80
36	Sandcastle	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WATCH OUT	6.70
37	Outsider	ROUTE ZERO : The ORA	6.40
38	Right In	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WRECKING THE HOUSE	5.90
39	Oh My Gosh	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Doorbell Ringing	5.60
40	Period	-	5.55
41	Skater	HOUSE OF TRICKY: HOW TO PLAY	3.90
42	HOMEBOY	HOUSE OF TRICKY: HOW TO PLAY	3.20

#	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Trial And Error	2024	Mini album	9.000
2	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WRECKING THE HOUSE	2025	Mini album	8.080
3	HOUSE OF TRICKY: WATCH OUT	2024	Mini album	7.980
4	HOUSE OF TRICKY: SPUR	2025	Mini album	7.930
5	ROUTE ZERO : The ORA	2026	Mini album	7.580
6	HOUSE OF TRICKY: Doorbell Ringing	2023	Mini album	6.900
7	HOUSE OF TRICKY: HOW TO PLAY	2023	Mini album	6.492

10/10 songs	0
% skips	19.05%
🎒 Avg. Song Score	7.655
🎒 Precision	4.530
🎒 Butter Score	7.144
🎒 Verdict	Rising Star

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	33	#29	6.952	Rising Star	N/A - first tracking data
10 November 2025	37 (+4)	#27 (+2)	7.007	Rising Star	Increase in precision score
23 December 2025	37 (=)	#25 (+2)	7.074 (+0.067)	Rising Star	Year-end adjustments
-	-	#26 (-1)	7.074	-	2025 year-end rank and score
11 April 2026	37 (=)	#27 (-1)	7.087 (+0.013)	Rising Star	Adjustments
24 June 2026	42 (+5)	#24 (+3) *PEAK*	7.144 (+0.057) *PEAK*	Rising Star	New mini "ROUTE ZERO : The ORA"

butter · 16 March 2024

📆 WEEEKLY DISCOGRAPHY RATE 📆
as of May 2025

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	After School	We Play	9.70
2	Tag Me (@Me)	We Are	9.65
3	Top Secret	We Can	9.40
4	Love (feat. Kim Eana)	-	9.25
5	ODYSSEY	ColoRise	8.60
6	Stranger	-	8.40
7	Good Day	-	8.30
8	Where Is My Love?	-	8.20
9	Twenties	Bliss	8.15
10	Sweet Dream	ColoRise	8.10
11	Holiday Party	Play Game: Holiday	8.00
12	Zig Zag	We Can	7.85
13	Hello	We Are	7.80
14	Backwards	ColoRise	7.75
15	BOOM CHI KI	-	7.70
16	RUBY-DUBY-DU	ColoRise	7.65
17	Happy Christmas	-	7.60
18	Weeekly	We Can	7.45
19	I Wanna Fly	-	7.40
20	Yummy!	We Play	7.35
21	VROOM VROOM	ColoRise	7.25
22	Uni	We Play	6.90
23	Airplane Mode	-	6.75
24	Classic	Bliss	6.60
25	Solar	-	6.50
26	Unnie	We Can	6.35
27	Universe	We Are	6.20
28	Check It Out	Play Game: Holiday	6.05
29	LIGHTS ON	Bliss	5.95
30	7days Tension	-	5.85
31	Wake Up	-	5.80
32	A+	ColoRise	5.70
33	Draw in to you	-	5.65
34	Ven Para	-	5.60
35	Reality	We Are	5.60
36	Page (A Story That Reached Me)	Bliss	5.55
37	Butterfly	We Play	5.50
38	Best Friend (We Can)	-	5.45
39	Weekend	Play Game: Holiday	5.40
40	Memories of Summer Rain	Play Game: Holiday	5.25
41	La Luna	Play Game: Holiday	5.10
42	My Earth	We Can	4.90
43	Dance Dance Dance!	Bliss	4.60
44	Lucky	We Play	4.30

#	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	ColoRise	2023	Mini album	7.508
2	We Are	2020	Mini album	7.313
3	We Can	2020	Mini album	7.190
4	We Play	2021	Mini album	6.750
5	Bliss	2024	Mini album	6.170
6	Play Game: Holiday	2021	Mini album	5.960

10/10 songs	0
% skips	52.27%
📆 Avg. Song Score	6.889
📆 Precision Score	4.671
📆 Butter Score	6.474
📆 Verdict	Sophomore

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	44	#73	6.474	Sophomore	N/A - first tracking data
-	-	#82 (-9)	6.474	-	2025 year-end rank and score

SOLO & SUBUNITS (not included in the group rate)

Artist	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
Lunedi	ANEW	2026	Mini album	7.280

butter · 20 March 2024

🎬 CIX DISCOGRAPHY RATE 🎬
as of December 2025

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	THUNDER	THUNDER FEVER	9.60
2	Lovers or Enemies	THUNDER FEVER	9.45
3	Cinema	HELLO Chapter Ø: Hello, Strange Dream	9.35
4	Movie Star	HELLO Chapter 1: Hello, Stranger	8.70
5	Bystander	HELLO Chapter 2: Hello, Strange Place	8.55
6	Round 2	HELLO Chapter Ø: Hello, Strange Dream	8.50
7	S.O.S	GO Chapter 1: GO Together	8.15
8	My Everlasting Sun	THUNDER FEVER	8.10
9	Future Maker	Pinky Swear	8.05
10	Imagine	HELLO Chapter 1: Hello, Stranger	8.00
11	Jungle	HELLO Chapter 3: Hello, Strange Time	7.90
12	Genie in a Bottle	OK Prologue: Be OK	7.90
13	What You Wanted	HELLO Chapter 1: Hello, Stranger	7.85
14	BAD DREAM	OK Prologue: Be OK	7.85
15	Maybe I	HELLO Chapter 2: Hello, Strange Place	7.65
16	Young	HELLO Chapter Ø: Hello, Strange Dream	7.60
17	Off My Mind	OK Prologue: Be OK	7.60
18	Change Me	HELLO Chapter 3: Hello, Strange Time	7.55
19	Save Me, Kill Me	OK Episode 2: I'm OK	7.50
20	Without You	OK Episode 1: OK Not	7.30
21	Black Out	HELLO Chapter 2: Hello, Strange Place	7.25
22	Bad Moves	THUNDER FEVER	7.15
23	My New World	-	7.10
24	Bend the Rules	OK Episode 1: OK Not	7.05
25	Rebel	HELLO Chapter 3: Hello, Strange Time	7.00
26	Move My Body	HELLO Chapter 3: Hello, Strange Time	6.95
27	UPSTANDER	GO Chapter 1: GO Together	6.85
28	458	OK Episode 1: OK Not	6.80
29	The One	HELLO Chapter 1: Hello, Stranger	6.80
30	Everything	HELLO Chapter Ø: Hello, Strange Dream	6.75
31	IN MY DREAMS	GO Chapter 1: GO Together	6.70
32	Drown in Luv	OK Episode 1: OK Not	6.65
33	WONDER YOU	GO Chapter 1: GO Together	6.55
34	Switch It Up	HELLO Chapter 3: Hello, Strange Time	6.45
35	Curtain Call	OK Episode 2: I'm OK	6.30
36	Numb	HELLO Chapter 2: Hello, Strange Place	6.10
37	All For You	Pinky Swear	6.05
38	Rewind	HELLO Chapter 2: Hello, Strange Place	6.05
39	Back to Life	OK Episode 2: I'm OK	6.00
40	Wondering	Pinky Swear	5.85
41	In & Out	OK Prologue: Be OK	5.80
42	LOST	OK Prologue: Be OK	5.65
43	Plastic Umbrella	Pinky Swear	5.65
44	My Name Is Shadow	THUNDER FEVER	5.55
45	ICE	OK Prologue: Be OK	5.50
46	Like It That Way	HELLO Chapter 1: Hello, Stranger	5.50
47	Stairway To Heaven	HELLO Chapter Ø: Hello, Strange Dream	5.45
48	Confession	OK Prologue: Be OK	5.45
49	With You	Pinky Swear	5.40
50	WAVE	OK Prologue: Be OK	5.35
51	WIN	Pinky Swear	5.25
52	Color	OK Episode 2: I'm OK	5.20
53	Here For You	OK Prologue: Be OK	5.20
54	Pinky Swear	Pinky Swear	5.15
55	TESSERACT	-	5.00
56	I'll Take You	Pinky Swear	4.90
57	20	OK Prologue: Be OK	4.80
58	Labyrinth	Pinky Swear	4.75
59	Revival	Pinky Swear	4.20

#	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	THUNDER FEVER	2025	Mini album	7.970
2	HELLO Chapter Ø: Hello, Strange Dream	2021	Mini album	7.530
3	HELLO Chapter 1: Hello, Stranger	2019	Mini album	7.370
4	HELLO Chapter 3: Hello, Strange Time	2020	Mini album	7.170
5	HELLO Chapter 2: Hello, Strange Place	2019	Mini album	7.120
6	GO Chapter 1: GO Together	2025	Mini album	7.063
7	OK Episode 1: OK Not	2022	Mini album	6.950
8	OK Episode 2: I'm OK	2023	Mini album	6.250
9	OK Prologue: Be OK	2021	Full album	6.110
10	Pinky Swear	2022	Full album	5.525

10/10 songs	0
% skips	57.63%
🎬 Avg. Song Score	6.700
🎬 Precision Score	5.930
🎬 Butter Score	6.471
🎬 Verdict	Decent

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	55	#79	6.407	Decent	N/A - first tracking data
20 September 2025	59 (+4)	#79 (=)	6.453 (+0.046)	Decent	Increase in precision score and slight increase in average song score
23 December 2025	59 (=)	#82 (-3)	6.471 (+0.018) *PEAK*	Decent	Year-end adjustments
-	-	#83 (-1)	6.471	-	2025 year-end rank and score

SOLO & SUBUNITS (not included in the group rate)

Artist	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
Bae Jin Young	STILL YOUNG	2025	Mini album	6.890

butter · 25 March 2024

🧸 STAYC DISCOGRAPHY RATE 🧸
as of June 2026

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	RUN2U	YOUNG-LUV.COM	9.75
2	Bubble	TEENFRESH	9.70
3	SO BAD	-	9.65
4	Cheeky Icy Thang	Metamorphic	9.65
5	YOUNG LUV	YOUNG-LUV.COM	9.60
6	BEBE	-	9.50
7	STEREOTYPE	STEREOTYPE	9.35
8	Fakin' (Sumin & Yoon)	Metamorphic	9.25
9	GPT	-	9.15
10	Over U, Goodbye (Seeun x J)	-	9.00
11	I WANT IT		9.00
12	1 Thing	Metamorphic	8.85
13	ASAP	-	8.80
14	SORRY	2:LOVE	8.70
15	COMPLEX	STEREOTYPE	8.70
16	Teddy Bear	-	8.60
17	Poppy	-	8.40
18	Say My Name	-	8.35
19	PIPE DOWN	-	8.30
20	LIT	-	8.10
21	2 L0VE	2:LOVE	8.00
22	BUTTERFLY	YOUNG-LUV.COM	7.85
23	Satellite	-	7.80
24	Meant to Be	-	7.75
25	LOVE FOOL	-	7.65
26	247	YOUNG-LUV.COM	7.65
27	Twenty	Metamorphic	7.60
28	SLOW DOWN	STEREOTYPE	7.55
29	MWUAH	-	7.55
30	Roses (ISA)	Metamorphic	7.45
31	Find (Sieun & Seeun & J)	Metamorphic	7.40
32	I Wanna Do	TEENFRESH	7.30
33	Flexing On My Ex	Metamorphic	7.25
34	Beauty Bomb	Metamorphic	7.20
35	WHERE YOU AT?	2:LOVE	6.75
36	Be Mine	TEENFRESH	6.60
37	BEAUTIFUL MONSTER	-	6.55
38	SAME SAME	YOUNG-LUV.COM	6.45
39	Trouble Maker	Metamorphic	6.35
40	Not Like You	TEENFRESH	6.30
41	BOY	-	6.10
42	Let Me Know	Metamorphic	6.05
43	Honestly	-	6.00
44	Stay WITH me	Metamorphic	5.95
45	I WANT U BABY	-	5.90
46	I LIKE IT	-	5.85
47	SO WHAT	-	5.60
48	BEAT MY LOVE	2:LOVE	5.60
49	LOVE	-	5.40
50	Nada	Metamorphic	5.35
51	I'LL BE THERE	YOUNG-LUV.COM	5.30
52	Tell Me Now	-	5.25
53	Give It 2 Me	Metamorphic	5.25
54	Gummy Bear	Metamorphic	4.90
55	DIAMOND	-	4.80
56	Lover, Killer	-	4.40
57	MEOW	-	4.20
58	STAR	-	4.00
59	LIKE THIS	-	3.50

#	Album Title	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	YOUNG-LUV.COM	2022	Mini album	7.867
2	STEREOTYPE	2021	Mini album	7.725
3	TEENFRESH	2023	Mini album	7.475
4	2:LOVE	2026	Mini album	7.263
5	Metamorphic	2024	Full album	7.036

10/10 songs	0
% skips	42.37%
🧸 Avg. Song Score	7.200
🧸 Precision Score	4.610
🧸 Butter Score	6.746
🧸 Verdict	Sophomore

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	52	#67	6.559	Sophomore	N/A - first tracking data
9 December 2025	52 (=)	#71 (-4)	6.632 (+0.073)	Sophomore	Year-end adjustments
-	-	#73 (-2)	6.632	-	2025 year-end rank and score
15 February 2026	55 (+3)	#69 (+4)	6.701 (+0.069)	Sophomore	3 new songs
11 April 2026	55 (=)	#71 (-2)	6.707 (+0.006)	Sophomore	Adjustments
24 June 2026	59 (+4)	#71 (=)	6.746 (+0.039) *PEAK*	Sophomore	New mini "2:LOVE"

butter · 26 March 2024

GIRLS' GENERATION DISCOGRAPHY RATE - Part 1 (77 - 115th)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
77	Stick Wit U	Oh!; Run Devil Run	6.25
78	Paper Plane	FOREVER 1	6.20
79	Sweet Talk	Holiday Night	6.15
80	Show! Show! Show!	Oh!; Run Devil Run	6.10
81	Wait a Minute	Mr. Mr.	6.05
82	My Best Friend	Hoot	5.85
83	Boyfriend	Genie	5.80
84	Destiny	Gee	5.75
85	Chain Reaction	THE BEST	5.70
86	Merry-Go-Round	Girls' Generation	5.65
87	Time Machine	THE BEST	5.60
88	Mood Lamp	FOREVER 1	5.55
89	ALL MY LOVE IS FOR YOU	THE BEST	5.50
90	Paradise	Lion Heart	5.50
91	Ooh La-La!	Girls' Generation	5.45
92	Forever	Oh!; Run Devil Run	5.40
93	Tinkerbell	Girls' Generation	5.35
94	Look at Me	I GOT A BOY	5.30
95	Complete	Girls' Generation	5.20
96	Let's Talk About Love	Gee	5.15
97	Say Yes	The Boys	5.10
98	BEEP BEEP	THE BEST	5.10
99	Mistake	Hoot	5.05
100	One Year Later	Genie	5.05
101	Only One	Holiday Night	5.00
102	Indestructible	THE BEST	4.80
103	DIVINE	THE BEST	4.75
104	Sailing (0805)	-	4.70
105	Talk Talk	Lion Heart	4.65
106	Dear. Mom	Gee	4.50
107	Promise	I GOT A BOY	4.45
108	Echo	Run Devil Run	4.40
109	Tears	Girls' Generation	4.35
110	Star Star Star (☆★☆)	Oh!; Run Devil Run	4.30
111	7989	Girls' Generation	4.20
112	Be Happy	Oh!; Run Devil Run	4.10
113	How Great Is Your Love	The Boys	4.00
114	It's You	Holiday Night	3.30
115	BAD GIRL	THE BEST	3.10

butter · 26 March 2024

GIRLS' GENERATION DISCOGRAPHY RATE - Part 2 (39 - 76th)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
39	Lazy Girl (Dolce Far Niente)	The Boys	8.10
40	One Afternoon	Lion Heart	8.05
41	Europa	I GOT A BOY	7.95
42	Kissing You	Girls' Generation	7.95
43	Green Light	Lion Heart	7.90
44	Seventeen	FOREVER 1	7.75
45	Dancing Queen	I GOT A BOY	7.70
46	Girls	-	7.70
47	LOVE&GIRLS	THE BEST	7.65
48	You Better Run	FOREVER 1	7.60
49	Back Hug	Mr. Mr.	7.55
50	Lost In Love	I GOT A BOY	7.50
51	Etude	Genie	7.45
52	Sweet Talking Baby	Oh!; Run Devil Run	7.45
53	Snowy Wish	Hoot	7.40
54	Boys & Girls	Oh!; Run Devil Run	7.35
55	Beginning	-	7.25
56	Baby Baby	Girls' Generation	7.15
57	GALAXY SUPERNOVA	THE BEST	7.10
58	Sunflower	The Boys	7.05
59	Fire Alarm	Lion Heart	7.05
			Points
60	Check	Lion Heart	6.95
61	OSCAR	The Boys	6.95
62	Light Up The Sky	Holiday Night	6.90
63	FLOWER POWER	THE BEST	6.85
64	Talk Talk	I GOT A BOY	6.80
65	FAN	Holiday Night	6.75
66	My Child	Genie	6.65
67	VITAMIN	The Boys	6.65
68	Bump It	Lion Heart	6.60
69	My J	The Boys	6.60
70	Summer Night	FOREVER 1	6.50
71	Romantic St.	I GOT A BOY	6.45
72	Goodbye	Mr. Mr.	6.40
73	Girls Are Back	Holiday Night	6.35
74	Day By Day	Oh!; Run Devil Run	6.35
75	Baby Maybe	I GOT A BOY	6.30
76	Girlfriend	Genie	6.25

butter · 3 April 2024

GIRLS' GENERATION DISCOGRAPHY RATE - Part 3 (1 - 38th)

#	Song Title	Album Name	Points
1	I GOT A BOY	I GOT A BOY	10.00
2	Catch Me If You Can	-	10.00
3	Mr. Mr.	Mr. Mr.	10.00
4	Into the New World	Girls' Generation	9.95
5	Express 999	I GOT A BOY	9.90
6	Hoot	Hoot	9.85
7	Holiday	Holiday Night	9.80
8	Lion Heart	Lion Heart	9.75
9	MR. TAXI	The Boys	9.75
10	FOREVER 1	FOREVER 1	9.70
11	Telepathy	The Boys	9.65
12	Freedom	FOREVER 1	9.65
13	You Think	Lion Heart	9.55
14	Talk to Me	Oh!; Run Devil Run	9.55
15	One Last Time	Holiday Night	9.50
16	Closer	FOREVER 1	9.45
17	Genie	Genie	9.40
18	Oh!	Oh!; Run Devil Run	9.35
19	The Boys	The Boys	9.25
20	My oh My	THE BEST	9.20
21	All Night	Holiday Night	9.15
22	Run Devil Run	Run Devil Run	9.10
23	Villain	FOREVER 1	8.95
24	Perfect for You	Girls' Generation	8.90
25	Sign	Lion Heart	8.85
26	Lucky Like That	FOREVER 1	8.85
27	Girls' Generation	Girls' Generation	8.75
28	Soul	Mr. Mr.	8.75
29	TOP SECRET	The Boys	8.65
30	TRICK	The Boys	8.55
31	Way To Go	Gee	8.50
32	XYZ	I GOT A BOY	8.50
33	Wake Up	Hoot	8.40
34	Love is Bitter	Holiday Night	8.35
35	PAPARAZZI	THE BEST	8.30
36	PARTY	Lion Heart	8.25
37	Show Girls	Lion Heart	8.20
38	Gee	Gee	8.15

butter · 3 April 2024

👑 GIRLS' GENERATION DISCOGRAPHY RATE 👑
as of June 2025

Part 1: 115th - 77th
Part 2: 76th - 39th
Part 3: 38th - 1st

#	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
1	FOREVER 1	2022	Full album	8.020
2	Mr. Mr.	2014	Mini album	7.783
3	Lion Heart	2015	Full album	7.608
4	The Boys	2011	Full album	7.525
5	Hoot	2010	Mini album	7.310
6	I GOT A BOY	2013	Full album	7.290
7	Holiday Night	2017	Full album	7.125
8	Genie	2009	Mini album	6.767
9	Run Devil Run	2010	Full album repackage	6.633
10	Girls' Generation	2007	Full album	6.627
11	Oh!	2010	Full album	6.610
12	Gee	2009	Mini album	6.410
13	THE BEST	2014	Compilation album	6.138

10/10 songs	3
% skips	48.70%
👑 Avg. Song Score	7.110
👑 Precision Score	5.973
👑 Butter Score	6.846
👑 Verdict	Solid

Rate and rank evolution report

Update time	Nr. of songs	Rank	Rate	Verdict	Reason for change
1 August 2025	115	#42	6.846	Impressive	N/A - first tracking data
28 September 2025	115 (=)	#43 (-1)	6.846 (=)	Solid	Adjustments to "Impressive" verdict criteria
-	-	#49 (-6)	6.846	-	2025 year-end rank and score

SOLO & SUBUNITS (not included in the group rate)

Artist	Album Name	Year	Type	Album Avg.
Taeyeon	INVU	2022	Full album	8.658
Hyoyeon	DEEP	2022	Mini album	8.414
Taeyeon	My Voice	2017	Full album	7.469
Taeyeon	This Christmas - Winter is Coming	2017	Mini album	7.300
Taeyeon	Why	2016	Mini album	7.214
Taeyeon	Purpose	2019	Full album	7.208
Tiffany	Edge of Calm	2026	Full album	7.165
Taeyeon	Something New	2018	Mini album	7.090
Taeyeon	VOICE	2019	Mini album	6.933
Yuri	The First Scene	2018	Mini album	6.900
Taeyeon	I	2015	Mini album	6.890
Girls' Generation-TTS	Dear Santa	2015	Mini album	6.860
Seohyun	Don't Say No	2017	Mini album	6.829
Yoona	A Walk to Remember	2019	Mini album	6.620
Tiffany	I Just Wanna Dance	2016	Mini album	6.483
Girls' Generation-TTS	Holler	2014	Mini album	6.317
Girls' Generation-TTS	Twinkle	2012	Mini album	6.314
Taeyeon	To. X	2023	Mini album	6.308
Taeyeon	Letter To Myself	2024	Mini album	6.300
Taeyeon	#GirlsSpkOut	2020	Mini album	6.280
Taeyeon	What Do I Call You?	2020	Mini album	6.130
Jessica	BEEP BEEP	2023	Mini album	6.100
Jessica	My Decade	2017	Mini album	5.925
Jessica	WONDERLAND	2016	Mini album	5.392
Jessica	With Love, J	2016	Mini album	5.290
Tiffany	Lips on Lips	2019	Mini album	5.270

Eunhyuk, HYO, Taeyong, Jaemin, Sungchan, Winter & Giselle	Jet
Girls' Generation-Oh!GG	Lil' Touch
GOT the beat	Step Back
HYO	MOVEURBODY
HYO	Retro Romance
HYO	YES
HYO, Key, Chen, Johnny, Ningning, Ginjo, Raiden, IMLAY & Mar Vista	Good To Be Alive
Kangta, BoA, U-KNOW, Leeteuk, Taeyeon, Onew, Suho, Irene, Taeyong, Mark, Kun & Karina	The Cure
Seohyun & Yuri	Secret
Taeyeon	All About You
Taeyeon	All With You
Taeyeon	Blue
Taeyeon	Four Seasons
Taeyeon	Happy
Taeyeon	Panorama
Taeyeon feat. MeloMance	Page 0
Tiffany feat. Simon Dominic	Heartbreak Hotel
Yoona	Wish to Wish

Search

Butter's kpop discography rates (3 Viewers)

butter

ani07

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

butter

Viewing thread