My problem with TXT (3 Viewers)

[perhapz]

I think, from your analysis, that you're just comparing them too much to BTS.

They are just rookies, I think they'll end up developing their style/concept with time.

Stan Huening Kai btw. 🇧🇷

 

[jasque]

stan txt kings of kpop

 

[Jichuus]

They’re still rookies and have time to grow and develop their own identity. I think the concept they went for is cute and age appropriate. Definitely a refreshing concept that stands out amongst dance heavy debuts. If anything their debut concept and styling is a reflection of Bighit’s marketing choices rather than the boys themselves.

 

[ddeonghwaaa]

they just debuted they need time to grow.......i mean, you comparing their height between bts is not necessary. Just because they are taller doesnt have anything to do with the group......just my opinion

 

[Les]

I'm not a fan but their debut wasn't too bad. Crown was a safe choice!
Right now they are kind of "generic" (when they debuted they reminded me a bit of ASTRO) but I'm sure they'll soon find their style :)
Variety shows help a lot.

My only problem was with Cat & Dog lol
The "I JUST WANT TO BE YOUR DOG" part ...
A lot of K-pop lyrics don't make any sense but this was...too much.

BH why did you even release an English version smh

 

[Poetry]

Just don't stan if you have that many problems with them. You don't need to be a company stan because you like BTS. Personally, I prefer TXT over most of this year's rookies thus far.

 

[Evergreen]

I like TxT. Their debut was one of the best for me since a long time musically-wise.

I am not bothered by the fact that they follow one of the most used Kpop concept, the flower boy one. They are pulling it very well and I think that they are doing it with their own refreshing signature.

They are adorable.

But I think that none of them is a strong vocalist, rapper or dancer. Maybe they will prove me wrong during theirs next comebacks.

 

[GoldenBunny]

Just saw this discussion, and it's interesting, I think they have an incredible amount of promise - every one is s strong singer. Quite baffled by the 'no one is a stand-out singer' part? if you look at their lives every one is good, they have fantastic harmonies.
You can tell by their breathing this is 100% live:
They're all strong and confident performers for rookies, and their music is - just opinion, of course - excellent and catchy. And their cheeks are all super squishable.

I do agree a bit that despite their age their heights and vibe doesn't 100% fit the cutesy thing, but hopefully the next concept will be something different! The new Nap of the Star video has me REALLY hopeful. So beautiful, and really unique.

Kpop goes Wes Anderson: SO here for that. And their Fictional Universe is gonna be *weird.* I demand More evil cat!

 

[JJbaker]

Just saw this discussion, and it's interesting, I think they have an incredible amount of promise - every one is s strong singer. Quite baffled by the 'no one is a stand-out singer' part? if you look at their lives every one is good, they have fantastic harmonies.
You can tell by their breathing this is 100% live:
They're all strong and confident performers for rookies, and their music is - just opinion, of course - excellent and catchy. And their cheeks are all super squishable.

I do agree a bit that despite their age their heights and vibe doesn't 100% fit the cutesy thing, but hopefully the next concept will be something different! The new Nap of the Star video has me REALLY hopeful. So beautiful, and really unique.

Kpop goes Wes Anderson: SO here for that. And their Fictional Universe is gonna be *weird.* I demand More evil cat!

I didnt mean they arent strong singers
i mean there voices arent unique in my eyes

but as i said before
i still support them
still like the group
just like every group i follow i have issues with them somewhere
as im not the manager or creator of the group so they arent 100% how i want them obviously

 

[GoldenBunny]

I didnt mean they arent strong singers
i mean there voices arent unique in my eyes

but as i said before
i still support them
still like the group
just like every group i follow i have issues with them somewhere
as im not the manager or creator of the group so they arent 100% how i want them obviously

That makes sense, thank you for the clarification! I do agree there, I hope that we see more chances for them to differentiate their voices!!!