Secret - Secret Flavor full album discussion (1 Viewer)

[centen]

I really want to talk about this, given I think it's the first time I recall ever seeing a group disband, then reboot years later with a new member. And the majority of the album is remaking their old songs. @Secret Time

YouTube playlist version that, for some reason, has the original Yoo-Hoo in it instead of the remake version. I linked the correct one below.



The Spotify version won't play for me, but maybe it will for you:

 

[centen]

It immediately stands out to me that both of the new versions of Madonna shortened the original, but the rest are pretty spot on.

From the new songs, Ice Cream sounds the most like "cute" Secret (ala Starlight Moonlight) and Get Right sounds the most like powerful secret (ala Madonna), which is kind of a nice touch to have something of both sides. I understand remaking their most popular hits if this is intended to be a full reboot, as in, this is just the first album, but RBW intends to have more. They'll need to be able to perform more than two songs.

Of the 2026 ver. songs, Starlight Moonlight sounds the most "off" to me TBH. The new version sounds pitched up or something. I listened to the original right after it, and the original has more low notes in it. I think their powerful songs sound really good in the 2026 versions (especially Madonna and Love is Move), no complaints there.

The only song I don't like at all is the shortened 2.5 minute remake version of Madonna (the last song on the album).