Shinee vs Shinee (1 Viewer)

[Ahsoka]

Between Onew and Key this year, who had the better:
Song overall?
Title track?
Bside?
Album overall?
Visuals (including MV, stage outfits ect)?
Choreography?

If you think of more categories feel free to drop them below and I'll include them

For me:
Song overall? Kay (Heartless)
Title track? Key
Bside? Key (Heartless)
Album overall? Tie. I prefer some of Keys new songs and am meh on one, Onew's top ones aren't as good imo but his are consistently good. Hard to judge fully given the number of new songs each had though.
Visuals (including MV, stage outfits ect)? Key
Choreography? Tie again. They're both really god choreos tbh. Definitely aren't very similar, but the songs aren't very similar either so that makes sense. They both match the songs they're made for very well.

 

[Willow]

what was ONEW's comeback

 

[Ahsoka]

what was ONEW's comeback

Circle

 

[Willow]

Circle

ah yes

 

[Willow]

Key's Killer is one of my favourites so far

 

[Myth]

I feel like it’s comparing apples to oranges. The vibes, goals, and messages are very different and onew and key have different tastes and strengths.

that being said, i found killer to be better than circle and I’m more drawn to the choreo’s energy, but onew’s album was stronger overall to me and offered a bit more ig variety. There was also something rlly down to earth and relatable in his work that resonated with me more.

 

[Ahsoka]

I feel like it’s comparing apples to oranges. The vibes, goals, and messages are very different and onew and key have different tastes and strengths.

that being said, i found killer to be better than circle and I’m more drawn to the choreo’s energy, but onew’s album was stronger overall to me and offered a bit more ig variety. There was also something rlly down to earth and relatable in his work that resonated with me more.

True but given that people compare apples to lawnmowers all the time apples to orange seems relatively reasonable because they're at least fruits

 

[ani07]

I liked key better overall.

 

[Violanah]

I have to go with Key overall. I did like what Onew put out though.