The hypocrisy (1 Viewer)

[athenaaa]

SOME kpop fans inadvertently asked for minors to debut. Okay hear me out. Many complain that minors, especially those under 16, shouldn’t debut. Understandably so. But then some of these same people will go around calling anyone 21+ a hag. Companies see that shit! These people are continuing to “make it clear” to kpop companies that debuting literal children is okay. IT IS NOT OKAY!​

 

[Day]

The industry is fucked up 100%

 

[athenaaa]

The industry is fucked up 100%

Facts

 

[Day]

Facts

It definitely has been one of the reasons I have such a hard time stanning new groups. Even older groups I enjoy I cannot help but steer FAAAAR AWAY from the youngest members I still have a hard time with Jihan and Zoa let alone anyone younger.... it's too much for me

 

[dark_tranquility]

That's gross.

I cannot believe it is supported.
how annoying and improper.

 

[Selfmate]

I've said it previously but personally I have nothing against minors debuting since it's their choice

especially for GG and female idols for the most part Korean female idols have an "expiry period"

there are just not that many idols performing and releasing new music post (30???)
and of those not many that release music as a group and of those not many that actually succeed
and of those not many that are still successful

thus being a female idol one needs to make the most of the limited time period in order to earn $$$

like I said if wonyoung (or any 13 and some 14 year old idols) debuted in a regular GG from the beginning they'd be younger than say Jisoo/Irene/Nayeon when they debuted - that's the equivalent of an entire 7 year contract periods worth of potential earnings.

I'm not saying whether it's right or wrong - it is what it is

 

[won_young]

The industry is messed up but it is the idols choice, they could easily walk out of quit. It's still wrong and should not be supported but we should also think about the idol who wanted this dream

 

[athenaaa]

I've said it previously but personally I have nothing against minors debuting since it's their choice

especially for GG and female idols for the most part Korean female idols have an "expiry period"

there are just not that many idols performing and releasing new music post (30???)
and of those not many that release music as a group and of those not many that actually succeed
and of those not many that are still successful

thus being a female idol one needs to make the most of the limited time period in order to earn $$$

like I said if wonyoung (or any 13 and some 14 year old idols) debuted in a regular GG from the beginning they'd be younger than say Jisoo/Irene/Nayeon when they debuted - that's the equivalent of an entire 7 year contract periods worth of potential earnings.

I'm not saying whether it's right or wrong - it is what it is

The industry is messed up but it is the idols choice, they could easily walk out of quit. It's still wrong and should not be supported but we should also think about the idol who wanted this dream

This wasn’t meant to be a discussion about whether minors should debut or not. I do agree that it is thier choice. The point I was trying to make is that I have noticed there are some fans who say minors shouldn’t debut but when things like survival shows happen and theres a trainee who is like 21 they wont vote for them cause they’re too old.

 

[Selfmate]

This wasn’t meant to be a discussion about whether minors should debut or not. I do agree that it is thier choice. The point I was trying to make is that I have noticed there are some fans who say minors shouldn’t debut but when things like survival shows happen and theres a trainee who is like 21 they wont vote for them cause they’re too old.

makes sense - everyone's a hypocritic lol