Which would you rather have? (1 Viewer)

[Yili]

A group whose idols are extremely talented in one aspect and just average in the others ( ex: an amazing singer with okay dance and rap or variety).

OR

A group whose idols have above average talent in everything but are not amazing at anything in particular

 

[Ahsoka]

Amazing at something.

 

[shika]

The latter since it would be more interesting to see them perfect those skills & all have cohesively flowing talents in all fields aha

 

[Jewel]

The first option XD

 

[AmysTeri]

The second option because I feel like it creates a more cohesive presentation overall.

I almost said the first option because it's the reality of "a lot of groups," then I thought about the groups I've listened to and, quite frankly, the majority of them fit in the second option rather than the first.

 

[Abeamus]

I can actually give a correct answer to this based on the fact that I have seen both of these play out with my biases and one definitely has better results than the other and that is being amazing at something over being just good at everything. The reason being is that EXID when they were active at least were known for being quite funny at variety and having LE, Gfriend were known for being quite good at dancing and Mamamoo were known for being quite good singers however Oh My Girl were never as prominent as a pick for these kinds of lists.

To me that does show that it's more valuable for idols to have a reputation of being the top of a category rather than be like Oh My Girl who are about as complete of a package as you could get in terms of being high in all the categories without being the focus of any of them despite arguably being more talented than groups who have a weak spot.

 

[The_LastRomeo]

The latter!

 

[Misakii]

Amazing at something

 

[Day]

2nd is the best option for a group to do well as a group

 

[lexus]

The first one