Official Who would you like to collect cards from? (common cards) (1 Viewer)

[Ahsoka]

before submitting later today, let me just make sure I´ve got it right. soloists - what does it mean? I get that Yongguk would classify and Agust D (Suga) as well, but what about like solo cards for concrete biases? Choi Minho has one solo song :D. is that ok? Can I also include S. Coups?

Minho wouldn’t count because it was an SM Station song, which we aren’t counting for this.

 

[blueberries]

Korean
2PM (especially since they are having summer cb!)
Lim Kim
Epik High
Jyj.. or just Junsu and Jaejoong

Non-korean
Daoko
Gackt

Thesr two would have prettiest cards!

 

[Abeamus]

If the artist in question has only one song but it was promoted (like they went on a chart show/s), I think you should definitely include their name when submitting your choices.

I even put down Jennie's name lol.

Where would Yuju fit with this exactly? I've at least seen Love Rain called her official debut but it only got a lyric video and a Dingo live with Suran so I took her out of my list since she wasn't ever on a music show with it to my knowledge

 

[OnlyCalB]

Where would Yuju fit with this exactly? I've at least seen Love Rain called her official debut but it only got a lyric video and a Dingo live with Suran so I took her out of my list since she wasn't ever on a music show with it to my knowledge

That's a good question.

Even though it may officially be called her "solo debut", we'd only consider a solo artist from a group if they had full promotions for it (chart shows) and an actual Music Video.

 

[Abeamus]

That's a good question.

Even though it may officially be called her "solo debut", we'd only consider a solo artist from a group if they had full promotions for it (chart shows) and an actual Music Video.

Figured that'd be the answer so my list has everything that could count for what I'd be interested in outside of another debut

 

[Villains]

Enhypen, Treasure, P1harmony, Kard, and Boy Story

 

[brekker]

That's a good question.

Even though it may officially be called her "solo debut", we'd only consider a solo artist from a group if they had full promotions for it (chart shows) and an actual Music Video.

which Minho had but apparently it doesn´t count ... okayyyy ... rules bending here slightly and not for everyone? :)

 

[OnlyCalB]

which Minho had but apparently it doesn´t count ... okayyyy ... rules bending here slightly and not for everyone? :)

Please refer to this answer:

Minho wouldn’t count because it was an SM Station song, which we aren’t counting for this.

 

[brekker]

Please refer to this answer:

still according to your answer it had a full promotion and had a music video released. but sure, great that we might be getting duo lipa on a kpop forum, but not one of the best rappers in the kpop industry.

 

[Panda]

The Rose, DPR Live, AOMG, Highlight, Fanxychild

I FORGOT EPIK HIGH

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

So I want to add some.
Stellar, Highlight, SS501 and History

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Also I'd collect Woohyun or Sunggyu solo cards but I know that would not happen

Same with Minah ones.

 

[Willow]

MANACLE, Sumire Uesaka and Wonho

 

[Magician]

Kpop groups:
Weeekly
StayC
Lovelyz

 

[Ahsoka]

Wonho
3ye
NFlying

 

[Panda]

still according to your answer it had a full promotion and had a music video released. but sure, great that we might be getting duo lipa on a kpop forum, but not one of the best rappers in the kpop industry.

You do realize that SM station songs don't actually count as solo debuts tho, right? Like Baekhyun released a bunch of SM station songs but he was not considered to have had his formal solo debut until un village. The SM station rule makes perfect sense in what is counted as a debut and what is not. Rather than instantly arguing about "bending the rules," why don't you look at it from their perspective? And why would Vikki as a Shawol herself be against adding Minho as a potential new set? That makes no sense. She, as a good cards team member, is setting specific guidelines as to what can be counted and what can't. Let's be a bit nicer to our cards team members and respect their decisions on these matters.

 

[lexus]

WJSN
NFlying

 

[Areum]

Japanese groups:
Manacle
NiziU

Kpop groups:
Busters
Drippin
Weeekly
K.A.R.D.
Momoland

Kpop soloist:
Wendy
Rose
Jennie
Somi
PSY

Other:
Ariana Grande
Dua Lipa

Thank you!!

 

[lexus]

Adding Lewis Capaldi hoping that he at least gets some love in here

 

[Tickita]

Korean
TVXQ!
OnlyOneOf
Zion.T

Japanese
Utada Hikaru
Perfume

Western
Boys World
Rina Sawayama