Would you support By9.. [produce x 101] (1 Viewer)

[JJbaker]

For me probally not

even though jungmo tony wonjin would be in the line up they wernt top on my wants to debut

if they changed the name so they could add Lee jinwoo i would fully support it

@Reo @JJbaker @Peach @colorfulteardrop @Riasama @Queen @JakeyWantsCakey @Darkyoda47 @wayvoutsold @baekk @Yolks @AlmostThere @Dopamine @Jichuus @planetarium @Wingfrost @Tomochin @SaviorTXT @blueberries @Darjeeling​

 

[QueenB]

My 2nd perfect group (cause this debut line up has had the most in my top 11-15 before) would be Jinhyuk, Wonjin, Donghyun, Yunseong, and Jinwoo

Wouldn't mind Jungmo or Yuvin in it.

Also, Suhwan, Hyunsu, and Minseo (the early eliminated one) would be cool to see a comeback with

 

[Wingfrost]

If this group does happen I'd support it if I like their music but I personally would rather all of them do something within their own companies and go back to their groups. If Yuvin is put into By9 then it would just be a longer wait until a full group comeback for Myteen and I'd rather see them all comeback together. Same for Jinhyuk it's already going to be weird to see Up10tion without Wooseok and if he's not there as well I don't think Up10tion would do very well.

 

[JJbaker]

If this group does happen I'd support it if I like their music but I personally would rather all of them do something within their own companies and go back to their groups. If Yuvin is put into By9 then it would just be a longer wait until a full group comeback for Myteen and I'd rather see them all comeback together. Same for Jinhyuk it's already going to be weird to see Up10tion without Wooseok and if he's not there as well I don't think Up10tion would do very well.

tbh it 5 year group x1 you might as well class them out of the group if i was you tbh as for example wooseok will be 27 when he leaves x1 he prob will just go to military and than have a solo career etc
its only the baby line who can really do much after
i.e donpyo is 16 and will be 21 after so he can be in a group etc

 

[JJbaker]

My 2nd perfect group (cause this debut line up has had the most in my top 11-15 before) would be Jinhyuk, Wonjin, Donghyun, Yunseong, and Jinwoo

Wouldn't mind Jungmo or Yuvin in it.

Also, Suhwan, Hyunsu, and Minseo (the early eliminated one) would be cool to see a comeback with

jinwoo needs to be in it though :(

 

[Wingfrost]

tbh it 5 year group x1 you might as well class them out of the group if i was you tbh as for example wooseok will be 27 when he leaves x1 he prob will just go to military and than have a solo career etc
its only the baby line who can really do much after
i.e donpyo is 16 and will be 21 after so he can be in a group etc

True I get your point, I think I'm just mainly wanting their groups to get some recognition and I just fear if Jinhyuk isn't there then they may never get more recognized. I also hate falling in love with temporary groups because it's so sad when they disband. I'm already way too obsessed with X1 right now and they haven't even debuted yet lol.

 

[JJbaker]

True I get your point, I think I'm just mainly wanting their groups to get some recognition and I just fear if Jinhyuk isn't there then they may never get more recognized. I also hate falling in love with temporary groups because it's so sad when they disband. I'm already way too obsessed with X1 right now and they haven't even debuted yet lol.

5 years is honnestly pretty decent and due to how long it is if they all become good friends they could decide to stay a group as contracts can only last 5-7 years so if there contracts run out with there company's they can choose not to resign remembering most of them are trainees

 

[QueenB]

jinwoo needs to be in it though :(

He is! Lol

 

[Jichuus]

I would and believe it’s a really good opportunity based on how past produce groups have been treated. Very few companies have been able to fully integrate and utilize the success of their produce trainees (ex: WJSN), so the project group would be a better bet.

Hotshot unfortunately is no where to be seen despite having an ex-Wannaone member and ex-JBJ member. One of the JBJ members also left his old group to start fresh in a JBJ subunit and has since found success there. I’d rather the debuted members find successs than hoping they’d pull off a Nuest one day.

 

[JJbaker]

He is! Lol

is he....
BY9 includes: Lee Jinhyuk, Lee Sejin, Song Yuvin, Koo Jungmo, Hwang Yunseong, Kim Minkyu, Ham Wonjin, Tony and Keum Donghyun.

 

[QueenB]

is he....
BY9 includes: Lee Jinhyuk, Lee Sejin, Song Yuvin, Koo Jungmo, Hwang Yunseong, Kim Minkyu, Ham Wonjin, Tony and Keum Donghyun.

I thought you were talking about the list I made lmao

 

[JJbaker]

I thought you were talking about the list I made lmao

ah
im happy he on your list