Official AOA Card Voting: Mina and Jimin (1 Viewer)

[litc]

No idea how that conversation went honestly as well no one ever really cared to ask about them and while I'd only want OT5 EXID myself I also don't see BESTie getting cards so making members like that optional could've been a compromise in case anyone does like BESTie without making people have to get members they wouldn't want.

Maybe they didn’t know abt the bestie members originally being in exid and only know the current lineup tbh

 

[Abeamus]

I get it and I agree with you 100%. Lucas' case is not even officially proved and he has no card. Mina is on another level, it's better not to state my opinion about her.

True, there are groups where removing former members would feel bad. Like, in EXO removing Luhan or Tao would make me bitter, not gonna lie. However, removing Kris is an other case. Every group's case is different and ofc, people see things differently, too.

One thing is sure, I agree with you on Mina.

Speaking of Kris I saw some news stuff about him potentially being innocent so might be mess coming there

 

[Abeamus]

Thank you exi. I like some aoa songs a lot and would want their set in the future but I wouldn’t want to have aoa Mina’s card at all

Stopped listening to anything from AOA the day Jimins scandal happened and then with Minas stuff I just checked out entirely and haven't gone back

Maybe they didn’t know abt the bestie members originally being in exid and only know the current lineup tbh

Well they even had another member of Nu'est for a short while that was quite obscure and even I didn't know about so I doubt that

 

[Boyo]

Speaking of Kris I saw some news stuff about him potentially being innocent so might be mess coming there

Plot twist of the year. Let's see.

 

[litc]

Well they even had another member of Nu'est for a short while that was quite obscure and even I didn't know about so I doubt that

Wait really? Didn't they debut as five? Was it S.Coups (Seventeen leader)?

 

[Abeamus]

Wait really? Didn't they debut as five? Was it S.Coups (Seventeen leader)?

They had an additional member in a sub-unit called Nu'est M being called Jason but there was no official work for the sub-unit and he was taken out for that reason

 

[Ahsoka]

Well that's not entirely true as EXID doesn't have their former members that went on to be BESTie but that's the only one that I can recall although that's another topic as I do feel an argument could be made for keeping the iconic lineup of groups what is needed for the main set barring major scandals of course

No idea how that conversation went honestly as well no one ever really cared to ask about them and while I'd only want OT5 EXID myself I also don't see BESTie getting cards so making members like that optional could've been a compromise in case anyone does like BESTie without making people have to get members they wouldn't want.

Maybe they didn’t know abt the bestie members originally being in exid and only know the current lineup tbh

I didn’t know that Exid had former members tbh, I’m guessing whoever made their cards didn’t know either, which is why they weren’t included. We might make cards for them now that we know

 

[litc]

They had an additional member in a sub-unit called Nu'est M being called Jason but there was no official work for the sub-unit and he was taken out for that reason

Oh right

I guess that would make sense for like AOA Black Youkyung didn't have a card ig since she wasn't in full group AOA, and if Suju had a set, since there are Suju-M members not officially in full group suju

 

[litc]

I didn’t know that Exid had former members tbh, I’m guessing whoever made their cards didn’t know either, which is why they weren’t included. We might make cards for them now that we know

I feel like a lot of people didn't know tbh

I knew bc I had gotten interested in BESTie at one point

 

[Abeamus]

I didn’t know that Exid had former members tbh, I’m guessing whoever made their cards didn’t know either, which is why they weren’t included. We might make cards for them now that we know

This is what I get for never doing EXIDs tournament

 

[Abeamus]

Oh right

I guess that would make sense for like AOA Black Youkyung didn't have a card ig since she wasn't in full group AOA, and if Suju had a set, since there are Suju-M members not officially in full group suju

Youkyung isn't the same as AOA Black has an official release for one but on top of that Youkyung is actually in AOAs debut MV Elvis however soon stopped as she had no interest in anything but the band which AOA left behind

 

[litc]

Youkyung isn't the same as AOA Black has an official release for one but on top of that Youkyung is actually in AOAs debut MV Elvis however soon stopped as she had no interest in anything but the band which AOA left behind

Oh no, I meant her not having a card in AOA's set

Edit: Since we're talking abt AOA cards @Vikki can we add her until aoa black gets a set in a subunit voting

 

[Ahsoka]

Oh no, I meant her not having a card in AOA's set

Edit: Since we're talking abt AOA cards @Vikki can we add her until aoa black gets a set in a subunit voting

I’m pretty sure she is in the AOA set

 

[litc]

I’m pretty sure she is in the AOA set

OMG IM STUPID

 

[litc]

OMG IM STUPID

ignore me @Abeamus

 

[athenaaa]

Minkie's and my point was about that it would be better to put those idols' cards as last in the sets, not about questioning it what they did is serious or not. Like, I think Woojin is not in Stray Kids anymore for reasons and you think he is okay, we probably will never agree on this. I just say if something similar happens with an idol group member in the future, maybe it would be better not to put her/his card as like #1, etc. in a set, but last.

Having former members last is an interesting idea from you though.

Yes, this was what I meant, if they were to get added, this is a good solution. I was only just comparing to the precedent of cards, not the specific accusations. Not at all saying I agree with Mina's actions at all either. As someone who has struggled myself, doing it for attention is a huge no.

 

[Exi]

I didn’t know that Exid had former members tbh, I’m guessing whoever made their cards didn’t know either, which is why they weren’t included. We might make cards for them now that we know

Ngl they left pretty early into exid’s career life so I don’t blame you 😂
High key still want a 8 member exid stage one day tho 😂
Exi delulu wbk


we could have bestie cards instead since all the members that left exid joined bestie

 

[litc]

Ngl they left pretty early into exid’s career life so I don’t blame you 😂
High key still want a 8 member exid stage one day tho 😂
Exi delulu wbk


we could have bestie cards instead since all the members that left exid joined bestie

Tbh I don't think bestie would get enough votes. I'd only see at some point (maybe) you, cami, cal, and me voting for them, I'm not sure abt anyone else, and not right away

 

[Abeamus]

Ngl they left pretty early into exid’s career life so I don’t blame you 😂
High key still want a 8 member exid stage one day tho 😂
Exi delulu wbk


we could have bestie cards instead since all the members that left exid joined bestie

Well Hyuna had a solo set and still got a Wonder Girls card anyway so idk if that's an argument

 

[litc]

Well Hyuna had a solo set and still got a Wonder Girls card anyway so idk if that's an argument

true if hyuna is known for another group and her solos, I don't see why any scandal-free former members wouldn't get unless they didn't know about them