If the leader of your bias group(s) wasn't the leader, who would it be? (1 Viewer)

[NogaNono]

SNSD: In my opinion, if Taeyeon wasn't the leader, it would be Jessica. She's definitely mature enough, she trained for a long time, and she's definitely got the leadership qualities in her, I feel.

CLC: The obvious choice is Seunghee, since she was the former leader and she still has a bunch of great qualities that would make her a good leader. She's really mature and all of the members really love her and get along with her well. If we're excluding her (since she was already leader) then I'd pick Yeeun. She's really good at speaking (she introduced the song most of the time during NO era) and I think she's rather mature, so she could do a good job as well.

Twice: Nayeon. While I think Jihyo is the best choice for leader, Nayeon wouldn't be a bad one either. She's got good character and despite being a goofball, I think when it comes down to it, Nayeon could definitely step up and unite the girls under her leadership.

BTS: It's really difficult, because I truly think that RM is the only one who could ever be the leader of BTS. He's perfect for it. However, if I had to choose, I'd say Jin or J-hope. Jin is a bit of a goofball but I think he can be the mature hyung when he needs to be. J-hope isn't the oldest, but I get a leader vibe from him. I just feel like he'd be good at it.

Red Velvet: Wendy. I think she could do a really good job. She's mature enough and I get the feeling that she likes speaking, which is good for a leader who would do most of the talking for the group.

 

[mirella]

Block B

If Zico weren't the leader, I would say B-Bomb. He is one of the oldest members and is responsible, slightly more reserved and less... um, wild compared to the others. I think he would be a great leader tbh.

If not him, then Park Kyung maybe?

 

[Day]

In NCT, it'd be Johnny or Doyoung, no doubt. They're both good at speaking as well as act like parents to the group.

In VIXX, I'd say it's kind of hard to choose a member other than Hakyeon... maybe either Ravi or Hyuk? Fellow starlights feel free to share ideas

 

[kuro]

I agree with noga for BTS and Red Velvet
for mamamoo (because they just popped in my head), if Solar wasn't the leader, Moonbyul would be amazing. she's charismatic, funny, charming, sweet, a visual, talented...she's perfect

for twice, I feel like Sana would actually make a good leader as well. Nayeon and Sana both are funny and goofballs, but Sixteen Sana was quirky and fun but she got what she wanted and disciplined Dahyun and Min-young or whatever, when they didn't show up for practice with her and Tzuyu. Sana can be serious, not just a naive fun girl, which I love.

 

[Jimimis]

Make Jimin leader BigHit you cowards

 

[RandAlThor]

SNSD - i agree Jess was the leader before as senior trainee. Its totally apparent in GGTS. Actually this is always one of the things that annoyed me about how snsd played out they really marginalized Jessica, from the start to give space to the other kids. And a good chunk of the fans buy into the lazy meme. Yet who did SM send to RM alone in ep 3 and 4?

Red Velvet - Wendy is super caring, but Yeri is the one most willing to talk :)

Honestly the next 4 would be such a stretch just because seeing anyone other than the og leader would be i think the wrong choice.

Apink maybe Bomi

Gfriend - Yerin

F(x) - Luna

Lovelyz - Sujeong

 

[Darkyoda47]

SNSD - Jessica or Hyoyeon
GFriend - Tbh I really can't imagine anyone but Sowon. For example, even though Taeyeon was the leader, she wasn't really much of a leader lol. SNSD all had strong, individualistic personalities that you'd find it hard to pin point who was the leader when looked from afar. However, with GFriend, it's very apparent that Sowon's the leader. She takes care of the group like they are her own kids, as cliché as that sounds. It's noticeable, even to non fans how the girls all look to her in any time of crisis. They have so much faith in her. Not to mention, she literally scolds them (like a mom) on live interviews if they misbehave. Lol I can't imagine how many times she's given Yerin and SinB the eye in a professional interview, when they're mucking about xD.

 

[NogaNono]

SNSD - Jessica or Hyoyeon
GFriend - Tbh I really can't imagine anyone but Sowon. For example, even though Taeyeon was the leader, she wasn't really much of a leader lol. SNSD all had strong, individualistic personalities that you'd find it hard to pin point who was the leader when looked from afar. However, with GFriend, it's very apparent that Sowon's the leader. She takes care of the group like they are her own kids, as cliché as that sounds. It's noticeable, even to non fans how the girls all look to her in any time of crisis. They have so much faith in her. Not to mention, she literally scolds them (like a mom) on live interviews if they misbehave. Lol I can't imagine how many times she's given Yerin and SinB the eye in a professional interview, when they're mucking about xD.

Honestly true tbh. Even though I think Taeyeon does have the makings of a good leader, I feel like since all of the girls have such strong personalities, they didn't really need a leader tbh. I think all of them at one point became a leader in SNSD's career, because that's just how SNSD is.

Interesting about Sowon. XD I've been wanting to stan Gfriend for a while now, but I guess I just haven't gotten to it, lol. They have good music though.

 

[RandAlThor]

SNSD - Jessica or Hyoyeon
GFriend - Tbh I really can't imagine anyone but Sowon. For example, even though Taeyeon was the leader, she wasn't really much of a leader lol. SNSD all had strong, individualistic personalities that you'd find it hard to pin point who was the leader when looked from afar. However, with GFriend, it's very apparent that Sowon's the leader. She takes care of the group like they are her own kids, as cliché as that sounds. It's noticeable, even to non fans how the girls all look to her in any time of crisis. They have so much faith in her. Not to mention, she literally scolds them (like a mom) on live interviews if they misbehave. Lol I can't imagine how many times she's given Yerin and SinB the eye in a professional interview, when they're mucking about xD.

I think
Sowon
Victoria
Kahi
Chorong
Especially are integral to the success and longevity of each group.

 

[Darkyoda47]

Honestly true tbh. Even though I think Taeyeon does have the makings of a good leader, I feel like since all of the girls have such strong personalities, they didn't really need a leader tbh. I think all of them at one point became a leader in SNSD's career, because that's just how SNSD is.

Interesting about Sowon. XD I've been wanting to stan Gfriend for a while now, but I guess I just haven't gotten to it, lol. They have good music though.

Yeah and I feel like, Taeyeon never wanted the role of leader either but she tried her best with the task she was given. I mean I remember Yoona saying that she use to introduce herself as SNSD's leader when sleep talking LOL. So yeah, she did it to the best of her ability. Managing people like Hyoyeon or Sooyoung or Jessica or Tiffany is extremely challenging. They're all BIG personalities. Kids like Yoona and Seohyun were fine listening to the older ones and even Sunny and Yuri just seemed to do whatever the majority went with but the other 4 oof lol. I do think, at one point, maybe after Hoot, she was just done with the whole leader thing anyway.

Haha yeah GFriend are a very interesting group. Though they have this bright, fairy, girly image in their music, their off screen personalities are what you'd expect from group's like 2NE1, BlackPink and 4minute lol.

 

[Darkyoda47]

I think
Sowon
Victoria
Kahi
Chorong
Especially are integral to the success and longevity of each group.

Very true. Any long-term group needs good leadership to bring the members together.

 

[Walnutt]

Blackpink don't have a leader but it would 100% be Jisoo if they did

 

[RandAlThor]

Very true. Any long-term group needs good leadership to bring the members together.

I have always felt that Guyri and Soyeon were just not up to the job.
Soyeon would have been ate alive by soshi .

 

[Darkyoda47]

I have always felt that Guyri and Soyeon were just not up to the job.
Soyeon would have been ate alive by soshi .

Soyeon was an absolutely terrible leader. I'm glad they switched to Qri after the scandal, who seemingly did a way better job. The fact that Soyeon was on twitter contributing to the start of the mess proves that she wasn't meant to be leader. That rotational system was a mess anyway.

 

[NogaNono]

Yeah and I feel like, Taeyeon never wanted the role of leader either but she tried her best with the task she was given. I mean I remember Yoona saying that she use to introduce herself as SNSD's leader when sleep talking LOL. So yeah, she did it to the best of her ability. Managing people like Hyoyeon or Sooyoung or Jessica or Tiffany is extremely challenging. They're all BIG personalities. Kids like Yoona and Seohyun were fine listening to the older ones and even Sunny and Yuri just seemed to do whatever the majority went with but the other 4 oof lol. I do think, at one point, maybe after Hoot, she was just done with the whole leader thing anyway.

Haha yeah GFriend are a very interesting group. Though they have this bright, fairy, girly image in their music, their off screen personalities are what you'd expect from group's like 2NE1, BlackPink and 4minute lol.

Yeah, she didn’t especially want to do to it but she stepped it up to the job really well. I think she probably stressed a lot about it though, about being a good leader and all. There was that one Strong Heart Episode where she talked about wanting to quit being leader, which really broke my heart because she seemed to really take to heart everything they say and try her best to be the leader the group needed her to be.

 

[Darkyoda47]

Yeah, she didn’t especially want to do to it but she stepped it up to the job really well. I think she probably stressed a lot about it though, about being a good leader and all. There was that one Strong Heart Episode where she talked about wanting to quit being leader, which really broke my heart because she seemed to really take to heart everything they say and try her best to be the leader the group needed her to be.

Yeah I mean I could never dream about being the leader in a group like SNSD. It's too stressful lol.

 

[NogaNono]

Yeah I mean I could never dream about being the leader in a group like SNSD. It's too stressful lol.

Yes lol, they are all such fiery personalities which is both a good thing and a bad thing. On one hand, I feel like if you took any one of the members they could probably be the leader of a group, because even though they have different ways of thinking (ie Yoona would be a more quiet leader, while Hyoyeon would be a more extroverted one) each of them could do a really great job. That’s probably why as a group they’d be so hard to handle by just one person. Lol poor Taeyeon.

 

[RandAlThor]

Also Eunbi is perfect for IZ One.
Chaeyeon would be good but she would need to Dial back a bit which would likely hide her more than help.

Plus I can see from repeated rewatches of pd 48 it seemed like every girl loved her and she loved em back.
She is always walking around touching and comforting the kids.

 

[RandAlThor]

Yeah I mean I could never dream about being the leader in a group like SNSD. It's too stressful lol.

i pity Victoria.
Luna would be chill but wow.....STRONG personalities.

 

[Darkyoda47]

Also Eunbi is perfect for IZ One.
Chaeyeon would be good but she would need to Dial back a bit which would likely hide her more than help.

Plus I can see from repeated rewatches of pd 48 it seemed like every girl loved her and she loved em back.
She is always walking around touching and comforting the kids.

Yeah I was actually about to add, Eunbi's a great leader. Even in Japan, when Japanese is just not it for her, she tries her best to make sure the kids do well in their segments.