Which Group Is Better? (1 Viewer)

[VillageIdiot]

Group A:
Main Dancer: extremely talented dancer but average/below average vocal

Main Vocal/rapper: is a talented vocal/rapper but average dancer

Two filler members

Group B:
Main vocal/rap: Good Dancer, Great vocal/rap but pales in comparison to Main Vocal A.

Main Dancer: Good Vocal/Rap. A talented dancer but falls a little bit short compared to Main Dancer A.

Lead: Like the other groupmates, good at dancing and singing but does not excel to the extent other members in their group or the mains of group A. However, is better than the fillers of Group A

One Filler member


Or in other words: a group with a few highly skilled members that carry the group or a group that's very well-rounded but not the best in any particular thing
There's not wrong answer, just a matter of preference

 

[kuro]

well-rounded groups are great, but I prefer having groups with a few very skilled members. this calls for some stanning problems, but that's my choice.

 

[Abeamus]

Group A cause people only notice the really talented members of a group anyway

 

[Walnutt]

Well rounded. Having only one or two highly skilled members makes the weaknesses of the others that much more noticable

 

[Riasama]

Well rounded. Having only one or two highly skilled members makes the weaknesses of the others that much more noticable

r ur jisoos ok

 

[Walnutt]

r ur jisoos ok

What are you implying...

 

[VillageIdiot]

Why did this thread flop

 

[maruberry]

I like Group A more.

They are more versatile imo. Also lowkey reminds me of EXO... Kai can dance but his singing/rap.... Then we have Chen who can sing but his Dancing...

The 2 fillers can shine in othe areas. 1 can be a variety god and the other one can be a top visual! Having really strong members in the group is always better imo.

 

[lexus]

Group B for me.

 

[Jimimis]

Ok but tell me about their faces

 

[feepit]

Group A for me. It's a balance of really skilled members from the start and members that you can see grow from being a "filler" member to a skilled one (if they ever improve).

 

[amourpinks]

group A, isnt this what a lot of kpop groups are like now. when you have a lot of members who are amazing at something, it kinda masks the filler members.