K-media calling Boys Planet Group 5th Generation? (1 Viewer)

[Abeamus]

I don't know about that

​

 

[Yili]

They're really jumping the gun when the 4th just started

Edit: I have no concept of time and forgot it's already been like 5 years so

 

[Moguri]

So it began

 

[RandAlThor]

They're really jumping the gun when the 4th just started

not really they have been counting 4th gen since what 17-18 thats 5 years +

heck i would put the girls at 5th gen starting with IVE since they came from a 4th gen group.
ive, seera and nj are nothing like the other 4 gen acts.

 

[Yili]

not really they have been counting 4th gen since what 17-18 thats 5 years +

heck i would put the girls at 5th gen starting with IVE since they came from a 4th gen group.

No man don't say that it's been that long it feels like a drop in the ocean I've already lived through two generations of kpop then

 

[RandAlThor]

Maybe that is goo

No man don't say that it's been that long it feels like a drop in the ocean I've already lived through two generations of kpop then

and the 'end ' of the pandemic is also a natural break point. every thing changed.

 

[Abeamus]

not really they have been counting 4th gen since what 17-18 thats 5 years +

heck i would put the girls at 5th gen starting with IVE since they came from a 4th gen group.

I wouldn't say Ive are 5th generation for that reason since then you'd also have to do the same to the post I.O.I groups which would be a mess and the only way I see Ive and Iz*One being separate generations is if you start 4th generation at 2019 then that'd put Iz*One at the tail end of 3rd generation but other than that they'd be the same generation really

 

[RandAlThor]

I wouldn't say Ive are 5th generation for that reason since then you'd also have to do the same to the post I.O.I groups which would be a mess and the only way I see Ive and Iz*One being separate generations is if you start 4th generation at 2019 then that'd put Iz*One at the tail end of 3rd generation but other than that they'd be the same generation really

Well if exo and bts are 3rd gen and they tend to split 2nd gen into 2 and 2.5 which i think is silly if it change it change make it a new gen :) i think 2018 is a good split.

and IOI had nowhere near the spill over effect of pd 48. actual successful groups came out of pd 48. IOI really only has gidle 2-3 years after it aired.

 

[Abeamus]

Well if exo and bts are 3rd gen and they tend to split 2nd gen into 2 and 2.5 which i think is silly if it change it change make it a new gen :) i think 2018 is a good split.

and IOI had nowhere near the spill over effect of pd 48. actual successful groups came out of pd 48. IOI really only has gidle 2-3 years after it aired.

The 2.5 Generation split is just very questionable since people tend to focus on the shift from sexy girl groups being popular like Sistar and AOA going into Red Velvet and Gfriend while ignoring the existence of Apink also being popular with a cute concept.

I don't think success of groups really matters in generations though as BTS is still the dominating boy group and probably still willl be by the time this group debuts which the reason I'd pinpoint around 2018 for 4th generation is due to downloads peaked in 2018 with Love Scenario selling 3M by the time Gaon came around and 2019 they fell completely off a cliff.

 

[Ahsoka]

They're really jumping the gun when the 4th just started

Depending on when you consider 4th gen as starting, 4th gen may have lasted longer than 3rd gen already Like if you count 2017 as the end of 3rd gen like some do then 3rd gen lasted about 5 years and 4th gen so far about 6. No matter when you count 4th gen as beginning though most people probably put it somewhere in the 2017-2019 range. So 4th gen is, for most people, at least 4 years old approximately, which isn't that short.

 

[Yili]

Depending on when you consider 4th gen as starting, 4th gen may have lasted longer than 3rd gen already Like if you count 2017 as the end of 3rd gen like some do then 3rd gen lasted about 5 years and 4th gen so far about 6. No matter when you count 4th gen as beginning though most people probably put it somewhere in the 2017-2019 range. So 4th gen is, for most people, at least 4 years old approximately, which isn't that short.

Yeah I forgot what year it is imma edit my post

 

[ani07]

I`m still getting confused when asked about kpop gens

 

[cocomelon]

NO.

 

[Selfmate]

interesting