Ep 1 & 2 Queendom Puzzle: MY RANKING (1 Viewer)

[Lovely_Cornchips]

So to give some background.
I wanted to create a little form that has categories
for each performance.
I will use that form to rank performances from the shows more fairly
over just rooting for my biases because I have so many biases in this damn show.

So to put it simply this ranking may seem weird but a large portion of it
is based on professionalism, if they lip sang, if they made any major mistakes.
Also just in general how much of their talents they really truly showed off and if what we saw was good.

So without further ado here are the rankings after the original performances.
Total points that can be earned was 60 points.

RANKINGS FOR INITIAL PERFORMANCES:
1. Bora (46)
2. Hwiseo (45.5)
3. Yeonhee (44)
4. Suyun (43.5)
5. Soeun (43.5)
6. Riina (43.5)
7. Yeeun (42)
---------------------
8. Nana (42)
9. Kei (41)
10. Yuki (41)
11. Chaeyeon (39)
12. Elly (38.5)
13. Yeoreum (38)
14. Jihan (38)
15. Juri (38)
16. Sangah (37.5)
17. Soojin (37)
18. Jiwoo (36.5)
19. Miru (36)
20. Haein (36)
21. Wooyeon (35)
22. Dohwa (35)
23. FYE (35)
24. Jiwon (34)
25. Chaerin (33)
26. JooE (32)
27. Zoa (28)
28. Seoyeon (21)

Let me know if you are curious about anything or what your ranking would be!
Please not hate to these gorlies or meself.
THANK YOU!

@nymphology
​

 

[athenaaa]

Riina and Suyun getting the love they deserve. And Bora a shoe-in for top rank

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Riina and Suyun getting the love they deserve. And Bora a shoe-in for top rank

The crap those 2 girls got along with Elly for small mistakes (Suyun didn't even mess up) that they recovered from was fucking stupid.

 

[athenaaa]

The crap those 2 girls got along with Elly for small mistakes (Suyun didn't even mess up) that they recovered from was fucking stupid.

THEY ARE HUMAN IT DOESNT HAVE TO BE PERFECT

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

THEY ARE HUMAN IT DOESNT HAVE TO BE PERFECT

And *cough* they sang live *cough*

 

[athenaaa]

And *cough* they sang live *cough*

Some people can’t relate

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Some people can’t relate

I love how i made a rule and then immediately broke it

 

[Wingfrost]

I now wanna do this I still have to watch the most recent episode but so far Bora’s performance is my favorite as well (along with Riina)

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

I now wanna do this I still have to watch the most recent episode but so far Bora’s performance is my favorite as well (along with Riina)

Oh Suyun's was my personal fave but I tried to make this objective LOL

 

[Wingfrost]

Oh Suyun's was my personal fave but I tried to make this objective LOL

Ah I see

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Ah I see

Yeah hence I have a whole ass google sheet form for it

 

[Wingfrost]

Yeah hence I have a whole ass google sheet form for it

My brain is already asleep it didn’t click

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

My brain is already asleep it didn’t click

YOU'RE ALL GOOD- I do have an ideal line up though already and so far the objective scores are not lining up lol

 

[Wingfrost]

YOU'RE ALL GOOD- I do have an ideal line up though already and so far the objective scores are not lining up lol

Oooh who’s in your ideal lineup?

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Oooh who’s in your ideal lineup?

1. Bora
2. Yeeun
3. Nana
4.Yuki
5. Suyun
6. Soeun
7. Hwiseo

I REALLY WANT ELLY THOUGH

 

[Wingfrost]

1. Bora
2. Yeeun
3. Nana
4.Yuki
5. Suyun
6. Soeun
7. Hwiseo

I REALLY WANT ELLY THOUGH

We have a few of the same choices
I really just wanna know more details on the contract though, like how long they’ll be promoting and whatnot, everything is so vague it makes me nervous.

 

[RandAlThor]

THEY ARE HUMAN IT DOESNT HAVE TO BE PERFECT

lol, the standard is perfection have you watched kpop. well pre 4th gen. even then the dance has to be perfect .
The girls judging have lived that life. They know the cost of live f ups.

 

[RandAlThor]

I did it by tiers.

in someone else thread lets see if i can find it.

this is it.

pretty much all of the legacy/disbanded artists did poorly except Kei.

Haeun needed to sing for the 2nd song or just do all of the first.
Dowah was too much 3 songs is too many, and have some energy please.
Jooe WTH was that song choice. If Soyhe can do full moon pull it together.
Yeeun heck i cant even remember it that is not good. I do not see her getting the bounce Yujin did (Yujin crushed bubble pop a song i really do not like lol yet i watch hers.)

Miru was not going to cut it with that song she is super amazing as cute or sexy / both but that was not a good song choice.

Kei needed another song Doing destiny only was too easy i expected more. she did well but hell she has sung that 1000's of times.

Fye was good at hypeboy but her song again was a bad call.

hmm i am a lot less forgiving of the poor singing and i feel many of these girls are nowhere near ready for solo work.
So the many lipsync are not even going to get ranked.
Failure to try also not good.
failure to hit the note is better.

Also i am not to be swayed by cool.. ( why ill never be a bp fan for example) if they can deliver cool and sing while dance then better.

ill tier em.

Bora first she crushed it. Stands alone performance and singing just wow.

Jiwon Yeorum, Nana,

Yeonhee( again took i song i dislike and made me want to rewatch her ) Jihan Hwiseo Zoa(not fantastic but bonus points for fx) Kei

Juri Suyun Chaeyeon(who really under preformed about as half assed as i have ever seen her.)

Riina Soeun Miru Elly Sangha

the rest