Appreciation Queendom Puzzle Ranking Changes: Round 2 (1 Viewer)

[Lovely_Cornchips]

So like in my thread from yesterday (here).
I will be using a google sheet I created to automatically rank and place
girls in these groups into a ranking based on mostly objective scoring.

BUT
given that this time around it was in fact a group challenge
and the performance videos have been dropped I decided to watch those and just begin my scoring.
I want to first state that this would be my ideal line-up:

IDEAL:
1. Bora
2. Yeeun
3. Nana
4. Yuki or Elly
5. Suyun
6. Soeun
7. Hwiseo

NOW with the groups that were created, I did a before ranking and an after ranking by tiers.

BEFORE ROUND 2 GROUP RANKING:
Tier 1: PICK CAT-Snap (40.1)
Tier 2: Athena-Snap (38.4)
Tier 3: PICK on the Top- Charismatic (38.2)
Tier 4: DROP the Beat-Charismatic (34.2)

END OF ROUND 2 GROUP RANKING:
Tier 1: Athena-Snap (46)

Note: This group absolutely destroyed vocally. Like they cannot be compared to the other groups. So many powerhouse vocalists and it showed.
Not to mention a lot of these girls clearly had fire in their eyes and the intensity they gave throughout was perfect. Their rap was probably the only downfall.
But they made it their own and actually carried pretty damn well.

Tier 2: PICK-CAT-Snap (43)

Note: Yes, they were good vocally but not at the same level as Athena. They obviously killed stage presence-wise as well.
Also, this group's strong suit was rap.
But then Sangah isn't a good OR great rapper. So she kind of brought the group down in that department, unfortunately. She is stronger
as a dancer so it bothers me they are forcing the whole "Little Soyeon" thing. Compared to the others in the group she was lacking.
But they carried pretty well and her vocals didn't disappoint.

Tier 3: DROP The Beat-Charismatic (40.5)

Note: So to put it simply this group knew the assignment. They all seemed to work cohesively to give off the same vibe
and the same concept, and as a result, they felt more like a group than some of the others. They all shined
stage presence-wise. Vocally they were pretty stable and strong too with vocals that matched the song. The weak link for me was JooE though.
Even with the rap not being super great this was pretty damn good and felt like a legit group.

Tier 4: PICK on the Top-Charismatic (39)

Note: So for this group, I am not going to lie. It felt like they all had a different idea of what the concept was.
Some members were trying to be somewhat sensual it felt like while others were being pure and happy and bubbly.
It threw the whole group off for me. Not to mention Nana was really the only one who stood out. The other girls weren't bad.
But some vocals were too soft. Some were great. The rap was bad just like with the other group.
Just overall I think this group did not feel like a group and it threw the whole thing off.

So with all of that out of the way, the next section will be the individual ranking after these scores
have been added to the girls' individual performances from Round 1.

Tier 1:
1. Hwiseo (91.5)
2. Bora (89)
3. Kei (87)
4. Riina (86.5)
5. Yeeun (85)
6. Yeonhee (84.5)
7. Elly (84.5)

Tier 2:
8. Suyun (84)
9. Yuki (84)
10. Juri (84)
11. Soeun (82.5)
11. Miru (82)
12. Nana (81)
13. Yeoreum (81)

Tier 3:
14. Dohwa (81)
15. FYE (81)
16. Sangah (80.5)
17. Soojin (77.5)
18. Jihan (77)
19. Chaerin (76)

Tier 4:
20. Jiwoo (75.5)
21. Wooyeon (74)
23. Jiwon 73)
24. JooE (72.5)
25. Zoa (68.5
26.Seoyeon (61.5)

So I'm going to tag @nymphology & @Wingfrost

But what was your guys ranking?
How do you feel about mine?

Please no hate.
But opinions are allowed.

​

 

[Wingfrost]

I is extremely biased and Pick Cat is still my favorite (it may have to do with the fact that 5 of them are my picks ) but I also think all of them fit the concept/sound, they felt like a group and while Athena did do better in the vocal department, Pick Cat just felt more… cohesive if that makes sense??
Tbh I don’t have much an opinion on the other two performances because I felt like none of the girls really stood out to me, it might just be the song though because I really felt the song was lacking.

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

I is extremely biased and Pick Cat is still my favorite (it may have to do with the fact that 5 of them are my picks ) but I also think all of them fit the concept/sound, they felt like a group and while Athena did do better in the vocal department, Pick Cat just felt more… cohesive if that makes sense??
Tbh I don’t have much an opinion on the other two performances because I felt like none of the girls really stood out to me, it might just be the song though because I really felt the song was lacking.

Nana was the only one who stood out in the other group which pains me to say because I love a lot of the members there but yeah. PICK CAT honestly...I obviously thought they did good but overall the concept was too easy for them because of the way Bora made things (good strategy on her part) but as a result, I think it made Athena work harder to shine and go out of their comfort zones.

 

[RandAlThor]

lol i hate snap over all so i really didn't even care that many of my picks and most interested in were in it.
i can barely finish watching either its just not fun.

Charismatic i find my self singing all the time.
Both teams were far far far more watchable than snap teams.

pick cat had 3 weeekly members and 2 rcp ie they were already a team.
I have no idea why jiwon took wooyoung.
The rain did not help i think it confused the girls even more ... sexy in the rain or cute having fun, so mostly they went to type.

pretty much i really hated the way both girls picked the teams.
i know both are pissed cuz they got burned by gp999 but damn.
Bora had to take Chaerin and all 3 rappers is over kill. Rapping isnt that hard as she herself proved in gp999.
take one prob yeeun and pick some more solid vetrans, i would have for sure taken Miru she is just crazy on stage.

if i had a phone i would be voting

Bora
Kei
Yeonhee
Nana
Jiwon
Suyun
Juri
atm
lol pretty much blow up 3 real groups ...