Would you still Stan Your Bias Group (1 Viewer)

[VillageIdiot]

Stayed with their intended/original lineup

Imagine Twice without Momo, Blackpink with Miyeon , SVT With 17 members, SNSD with Soyeon, and so on...
Would you still Stan?
Would you even like their music anymore?

SNSD(+Soyeon):

Spoiler

Yes. (Soyeon+Taeyeon+Jessica+Seohyun )

T-ara (-Soyeon, Qri and Boram):

Spoiler

Impossible.

The first time I'd ever heard of T-ara was because of Soyeon's connection to Soshi. Not only that but she is the voice of the group and the other distinctive vocalists (KyulRam) would be gone. As much as I love Jiyeon, Hyomin and Eunjung, they can be hard to differentiate. And T-ara without Qri...
Me staying in kpop without Qri...

Girl's Day

Spoiler

Meh
Jiin's voice isn't as pulling as Sojin and Minah but I could deal with.
I'd still be a fan of their music but I couldn't Stan
The strength that they have as a unit does stem from everything they went through those first few years.

Random Tags

Spoiler

@StarWarsBitch @StarlightGalaxy @Reo @Lovely_Cornchips @Ireneisbaee @Minuteman @lexusuwu @Angelyna_Frost @NogaNono @RandAlThor @BritishLuvie @SaviorTXT @arieam @Jimimis @ParkJimin @Jimin @bulletproof @ChaseMeJiYoo

 

[Jimimis]

man even number groups are the worst but Jimin's still there and i follow my husband since imma good wife

 

[kuro]

man even number groups are the worst but Jimin's still there and i follow my husband since imma good wife

I follow taehyung xD

 

[Panda]

I'm trying to remember who was supposed to be in VIXX cause I'm pretty sure there were supposed to be more members?

But, the answer would be yes anyways lmao

 

[Neckologist]

If they still have the same songs then I would still stan

 

[kuro]

If they still have the same songs then I would still stan

but a member would be missing, so the lines would change, and the distribution xD

 

[Neckologist]

but a member would be missing, so the lines would change, and the distribution xD

I don't really care about lines and distribution and stuff like that
I just want my music

 

[kuro]

I don't really care about lines and distribution and stuff like that
I just want my music

fair enough xD

 

[NogaNono]

SNSD: Yes. I don't really follow T-ara so I don't know much about Soyeon, but she seems nice enough and I would still love all of the other members and their music.

CLC: Yes, probably. There would be that one other girl who went on to become and actress and left cube, bur she seems nice enough. And I like OT5 a lot so I would still like them. Would miss Elkie and Eunbin though.

Twice: Although Momo was the reason I got into Twice, she's not my favorite member anymore and I think that I'd still stan them, even though it would be different.

 

[LoveYooShaSha]

Stayed with their intended/original lineup

Imagine Twice without Momo, Blackpink with Miyeon , SVT With 17 members, SNSD with Soyeon, and so on...
Would you still Stan?
Would you even like their music anymore?

SNSD(+Soyeon):

Spoiler

Yes. (Soyeon+Taeyeon+Jessica+Seohyun )

T-ara (-Soyeon, Qri and Boram):

Spoiler

Impossible.

The first time I'd ever heard of T-ara was because of Soyeon's connection to Soshi. Not only that but she is the voice of the group and the other distinctive vocalists (KyulRam) would be gone. As much as I love Jiyeon, Hyomin and Eunjung, they can be hard to differentiate. And T-ara without Qri...
Me staying in kpop without Qri...

Girl's Day

Spoiler

Meh
Jiin's voice isn't as pulling as Sojin and Minah but I could deal with.
I'd still be a fan of their music but I couldn't Stan
The strength that they have as a unit does stem from everything they went through those first few years.

Random Tags

Spoiler

@StarWarsBitch @StarlightGalaxy @Reo @Lovely_Cornchips @Ireneisbaee @Minuteman @lexusuwu @Angelyna_Frost @NogaNono @RandAlThor @BritishLuvie @SaviorTXT @arieam @Jimimis @ParkJimin @Jimin @bulletproof @ChaseMeJiYoo

but a member would be missing, so the lines would change, and the distribution xD

If Soyeon remained in SNSD, would Taeyeon hv disappeared longer than one day, as she came bk after running away for one day.

Then I think wow, maybe I wouldn't stan SNSD if TaengSic wasn't in it as strongly.

I don't really care about lines and distribution and stuff like that
I just want my music

Without same members same songs might not be chosen or might be written differently to highlight different members.

But dammit I would still bias Jessica bcos.

 

[Neckologist]

If Soyeon remained in SNSD, would Taeyeon hv disappeared longer than one day, as she came bk after running away for one day.

Then I think wow, maybe I wouldn't stan SNSD if TaengSic wasn't in it as strongly.


Without same members same songs might not be chosen or might be written differently to highlight different members

If they were never in the group I would never know those songs or members
As long as they keep their general sound then that's all I want

 

[lexus]

Well, J-hope almost dropped out of BTS until RM convinced him to stay and I think Jimin was almost dropped from the group's original lineup. There's actually other artists who could've been in the group such as Loco, Supreme Boi (still produces songs under Bighit), and even Iron who thankfully did not debut with them.
Honestly without J-hope and Jimin the group wouldn't be the same for me. I could still be a fan because I do like their music, but the music wouldn't sound the same without the other two. Hopefully that makes sense.

 

[LoveYooShaSha]

If they were never in the group I would never know those songs or members
As long as they keep their general sound then that's all I want

An example for @kuroyuri hyuna was in wonder girls but left. Would wonder girls w/hyuna have same sound n would hyuna hv evolved the same to be sexy, edawn loving woman we all know n love now? Makes u think, huh?

 

[RandAlThor]

I like Soyeon in Tara not sure she would have been right in SNSD.
At the end of the day Tara needs her much much more.

 

[RandAlThor]

How about if that JYP group with Hani, Jieun, Uji, Hyorin debuted and gutted 4 groups

 

[VillageIdiot]

If Soyeon remained in SNSD, would Taeyeon hv disappeared longer than one day, as she came bk after running away for one day.

Then I think wow, maybe I wouldn't stan SNSD if TaengSic wasn't in it as strongly.


Without same members same songs might not be chosen or might be written differently to highlight different members.

But dammit I would still bias Jessica bcos.

I think, instead of TaengsicSeo, it would have been TaengsicSo since Soyeon has an advantage over Seohyun on the tone front. I think SM would have pushed Soyeon right along with Taeyeon for having a soulful voice but that doesn't change the fact that Jessica was more capable of the high notes
Imagine Jessica juggling main dancer and lead vocal tho

 

[RavenHikari]

Rip Kyu and Wookie


I would stan the group that Junsu, Sungmin, and Eunhyuk were going to be in together tho
​

 

[VillageIdiot]

How about if that JYP group with Hani, Jieun, Uji, Hyorin debuted and gutted 4 groups

 

[SeulPika]

Jessica was one of my favourite Soshi girls and I still stan SNSD even after 9/30.....

 

[LoveYooShaSha]

I think, instead of TaengsicSeo, it would have been TaengsicSo since Soyeon has an advantage over Seohyun on the tone front. I think SM would have pushed Soyeon right along with Taeyeon for having a soulful voice but that doesn't change the fact that Jessica was more capable of the high notes
Imagine Jessica juggling main dancer and lead vocal tho

With TaengsicSo, we would avoid Jess exhaustion after performing in Girls go to school since soyeon is singer n visual, dunno wat to think-since I think this led to Jess getting more prominent vocal parts n downplaying her lead dance role due to her focusing on one instead of two roles. Still sth to think abt.
MonCherry why ur mind went there. In all the years since this (2010 smh)

The Making of So Nyuh Shi Dae

So I watched Ellie’s vlog about how ‘SNSD should be 4 not 9’. I love Ellie and her K-pop vlog, as Cindy said, she always has interesting take on K-pop — this one is no excep…

snsdkorean.com

I don't know why I never read what if soyeon actually was in SNSD from the start.

Not sure if bottom left is soyeon, think it's not.

There's a video made based on this too.