Reality Official Produce_X101 Thread (The Finale Is Subbed NOW!!!) (8 Viewers)

Peach

Always there for Daniel
.
Joined
13 November 2018
Messages
1,356
Reactions Received
5,025
Location
Estonia
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
I see it as
1-5 months - under the age of 17 should be bit easy on....

everyone else the same

as if you only been training months it not like you could of learnt much in that time unless you been training yourself and if your are a kid and trained for years it not same as a 17 plus year old who has trained with a striker trainer etc
I don't think it matters, though. You should be ranked by your performance. Training longer doesn't necessarily mean you'll be better or worse if you train less. Some people are just more talented than the rest. I also don't think being under a great company gives any privileges, you can still do well without proper training facilities and training in a basement (such as in Daniel's case who was A ranked) if you practise hard enough in such environment.

Anyways, let's look at some of yesterday's performers, their training length and their age (I'll put international), bolded the examples!

MBK Entertainment

Kim Yeong Sang - D, training period: 4 years, 22
Nam Do Hyon - A, training period: 5 months, 15
Lee Han Gyul - C, training period: 4 years and 2 months, 20

Brand New Music

Kim Sihun - B, training period: 2 years and 2 months, 20
Yun Junghwan - A, training period: 2 years and 6 months, 18
Lee Eunsang - A, training period: 1 year and 2 months, 17
Hong Seongjun - B, training period: 1 year and 4 months, 20

here the youngest and least trained trainee did the best as well even though their training periods are more similar to each other ^

Starship Entertainment

Moon Hyunbin - D, training period: 2 years and 7 months, 19
Ham Wonjin - D, training period: 2 years and 6 months, 18
Song Hyungjun - X, training period: 1 year and 3 months, 17
Kang Minhee - X, training period: 1 year and 9 months, 17
Koo Jungmo - X, training period: 1 year and 2 months, 19

here is an example of how training period correlates with the rank ^

DSP Media

Son Dongpyo
- B, training period: 1 year and 5 months, 17
Lee Junhyuk - C, training period: 2 years and 3 months, 19
Lee Hwan - B, training period: 2 years and 9 months, 20

here the youngest and least trained did the best once again, his B has more value to it than the other guy's

Source Music

Kim Hyeonbin - D, training period: 1 year and 7 months, 17
Yoon Mingook - D, training period: 2 years and 1 month, 17
Tsai Chia Hao - D, training period: 1 year and 3 months, 21

Oui Entertainment

Kim Yohan
- A, training period: 3 months, 20

same age and training amount as Kwon Taeeun, look at the difference in skill levels!

Maroo Entertainment

Lee Jinwoo - X, training period: 5 months, 15
Lee Woojin - X, training period: 9 months, 16
Lee Taeseung - X, training period: 3 months, 16

Now some of the guys who I believe deserved their X rank

A CONIC Entertainment

Kwon Taeeun
- X, training period: 3 months, 20

Cre.ker Entertainment


Gwon Huijun - X, training period: 3 months, 18

Plasma Entertainment

Park Sion - X, training period: 5 months, 17

as we can now see, it absolutely doesn't matter, you can train for a long time and get an X and you can train for 3 months and get A, you can also debut with F rank and improve a lot and A doesn't guarantee debut, of course, as well for all the group battles, most of the points go to the most popular person, especially for first group battle, because they're more known and no one cares if they're A or F, it's something people will nitpick on later though >:
 

Peach

Always there for Daniel
.
Joined
13 November 2018
Messages
1,356
Reactions Received
5,025
Location
Estonia
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
my totally unbiased top picks as of now
I still have hope for the starship boys OK

link to make one yourself
I need to watch more because I can't pick more than top 3 now for now, lmao. And I wonder what's up with Im Siu? I'm pretty sure he left the show. He never was in any of these events they had unless he had a reason.
 
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
5,686
Reactions Received
16,237
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
I need to watch more because I can't pick more than top 3 now for now, lmao. And I wonder what's up with Im Siu? I'm pretty sure he left the show. He never was in any of these events they had unless he had a reason.
I remember him from the introduction video and the snack one. I honestly don't remember seeing him in the other stuff so he could have left the show.

Tbh the only reason I picked him is he reminds me of NCT's Jungwoo lmao
 

Peach

Always there for Daniel
.
Joined
13 November 2018
Messages
1,356
Reactions Received
5,025
Location
Estonia
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
I remember him from the introduction video and the snack one. I honestly don't remember seeing him in the other stuff so he could have left the show.

Tbh the only reason I picked him is he reminds me of NCT's Jungwoo lmao
Everyone are saying he left. I don't know why MNET hasn't said anything about him though and you can see him in first episode a bit when it shows individual trainees coming in but that's all. Strange.

And he's really cute, haha. I first thought he wasn't even Korean because they romanized Siwoo into Siu.
 
Joined
12 November 2018
Messages
551
Reactions Received
1,842
Location
Finally free
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
After a long hiatus I’m back and I did watch the first episode of PDX 101 last friday. I’m ready to discuss with you guys!

First of all: I’m new to the hole PD101 world, but I knew overall how the procedere of this show is. Neverless I was excited for the first episode. I’m all little bit overwhelmed at how many face and names I need to learn lol but I did saw some interesting boys.

First: Midam is looking much better and healthier than in YGTB and I was happy that he was holding the first seat for a long time. Probably I’m little biased lol

The trainers: Man, that is some good line up. And the vocal trainer Seokhoon is really good looking (he also reminds me of someone, hm…)

Even tho the the episode was so long it didn’t really felt like that. I think now I need to watch all the videos about the trainees which were released beforehand. Otherwise I don’t get to know all of them (but…I’m also really lazy, so…).

The JYP guy is probably really good and we will see that the next episode. I hope Mahiro and Jyunhao from YG are also doing a good job.
 

JakeyWantsCakey

Stan Treasure!
.
.
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
9,507
Reactions Received
26,077
Location
UK
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Male
On the otherside I did read something about the JYP trainee and his bad behaviour in school? This could teint his reputation

Yeah, here's the article... I know you should take everything you read on allkpop with a grain of salt but there seem to be plenty of pictures and screenshots to back up the allegations. Just to be clear if any of you don't want to read the article, he's being accused of underage drinking and smoking as well as bullying and school violence.
 
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
5,686
Reactions Received
16,237
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
Everyone are saying he left. I don't know why MNET hasn't said anything about him though and you can see him in first episode a bit when it shows individual trainees coming in but that's all. Strange.

And he's really cute, haha. I first thought he wasn't even Korean because they romanized Siwoo into Siu.
Yeah its pretty weird but its also mnet so not everything is logical

Same! I thought he was foreign as well from the name
 

JakeyWantsCakey

Stan Treasure!
.
.
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
9,507
Reactions Received
26,077
Location
UK
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Male
TOP 10 + X

1
Wang Jyunhao
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]YG
[/COLOR]


2
Son Dongpyo
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]DSP

3
Lee Sejin
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]IME[/COLOR]
[/COLOR]


4
Peak
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]CHANDELIER

5
Jeong Jaehun
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]AROUND US[/COLOR]

6
Lee Jinwoo
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]MAROO[/COLOR]
[/COLOR]


7
Lee Hangyul
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]MBK

8
Song Yuvin
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]MUSIC WORKS[/COLOR]

9
Lee Midam
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]AAPY[/COLOR]

10
Steven Kim
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]DS[/COLOR]

11
Yun Junghwan
[COLOR=var(--ranking-affil-gray)]BRAND NEW MUSIC[/COLOR]
[/COLOR]
 
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
5,686
Reactions Received
16,237
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female

Yeah, here's the article... I know you should take everything you read on allkpop with a grain of salt but there seem to be plenty of pictures and screenshots to back up the allegations. Just to be clear if any of you don't want to read the article, he's being accused of underage drinking and smoking as well as bullying and school violence.
Pretty strange for a jyp trainee. They seem anal about having idols with good behavior.

If I'm honest I don't care about the underage drinking and smoking lol. I mean I did one of those things myself so it'd be a hypocrite lol

The only problem would be the bullying stuff.
 

Peach

Always there for Daniel
.
Joined
13 November 2018
Messages
1,356
Reactions Received
5,025
Location
Estonia
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
On the otherside I did read something about the JYP trainee and his bad behaviour in school? This could teint his reputation

Yeah, here's the article... I know you should take everything you read on allkpop with a grain of salt but there seem to be plenty of pictures and screenshots to back up the allegations. Just to be clear if any of you don't want to read the article, he's being accused of underage drinking and smoking as well as bullying and school violence.
Pretty strange for a jyp trainee. They seem anal about having idols with good behavior.

If I'm honest I don't care about the underage drinking and smoking lol. I mean I did one of those things myself so it'd be a hypocrite lol

The only problem would be the bullying stuff.
It was already debunked by someone!



Sadly dcgall (worst site ever for such things) already picked it up, he’s not even one of my picks but there have been too many of these bullying accusations that lead to nowhere so I take them with a grain of salt.
 
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
5,686
Reactions Received
16,237
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
It was already debunked by someone!



Sadly dcgall (worst site ever for such things) already picked it up, he’s not even one of my picks but there have been too many of these bullying accusations that lead to nowhere so I take them with a grain of salt.
Makes sense. Some of those pictures were blurry or zoomed out where you couldn't identity the face that well.

I don't get what people gain from making up this stuff though
 

Peach

Always there for Daniel
.
Joined
13 November 2018
Messages
1,356
Reactions Received
5,025
Location
Estonia
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
Makes sense. Some of those pictures were blurry or zoomed out where you couldn't identity the face that well.

I don't get what people gain from making up this stuff though
They probably feel threatened or jealous, I assume the latter though. This is most likely done by someone who knew them in the school.

There was this Maroo trainee in the second season named Han Jongyeon, who was A ranked, and he was accused of sexual assault and also of being a bully and iljin. There was a lot of evidence towards him mainly because the posts weren't made anonymously but instead his former classmates called him out under their real names. So he left the show before it aired and the only part you see him in is where the trainees go against each other in dance battles. He debuted last year in a group named LUCENTE under the stage name Parkha. It's such a pity because the guy is actually very talented but he only got to debut because everyone forgot about him the moment he left. This is the case where there is somewhat evidence to it.

But when they accused Baekho of the same thing, I didn't fall for it. It was obvious at that point that it was done due to his success because the lack of evidence towards him was the biggest proof of it all and the female accusing him had so many inconsistencies to her claims. They could have brought up something that old (supposedly happened in 2008-2009) when he debuted and not right after PD101 ended. I even got hate on one of my anonymous forms for using his gif because some people didn't even bother checking whether it's true or not. So now I'm just wary of these things in general. There are terrible idols as we know about but a lot of male idols get accused without any proof or truth to it and I am happy that they quickly disapproved it in Seobin's case. There's a lot of misandry towards male idols as well and no one wants to admit to it, it's sad.
 
Last edited:

JakeyWantsCakey

Stan Treasure!
.
.
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
9,507
Reactions Received
26,077
Location
UK
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Male
In the last 3 seasons, whoever sat on the no1 throne in the 1st episode got eliminated. It would be awkward if JYP's boy do not make it.
I have a feeling he'll be ok Mnet and JYP have a pretty good relationship if anything it'll be the YG boys that are made to look bad. Did anyone else realise that Midam got more screen time than any of the actual YG trainees and they kept referring to him as a YG trainee even though he's under a new label now...
 
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
5,686
Reactions Received
16,237
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
I have a feeling he'll be ok Mnet and JYP have a pretty good relationship if anything it'll be the YG boys that are made to look bad. Did anyone else realise that Midam got more screen time than any of the actual YG trainees and they kept referring to him as a YG trainee even though he's under a new label now...
Yeah they seem to want to build tension with the whole big 3 thing. They were even including the esteem trainees in mentions of the big3 in the competition
 

Peach

Always there for Daniel
.
Joined
13 November 2018
Messages
1,356
Reactions Received
5,025
Location
Estonia
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Female
I have a feeling he'll be ok Mnet and JYP have a pretty good relationship if anything it'll be the YG boys that are made to look bad. Did anyone else realise that Midam got more screen time than any of the actual YG trainees and they kept referring to him as a YG trainee even though he's under a new label now...
But they completely neglected his performance. We don't even know what rank he got or the rest of the boys from both AAPY and Yuehua, they also showcased self-produced songs just like BNM boys who got plenty of screentime (which honestly was expected). I don't think he's getting that great screentime. But it's ridiculous to refer to him as YG trainee.. they take away from his individuality, which is annoying. They keep referring to Han Gichan as a Ong look-like as well and he himself keeps saying things about Ong so they keep pushing him as next Ong which I also find annoying. I also don't understand why Seobin got PR to himself while none of the other trainees got it. And for the last, I saw people saying they're starting to dislike Dongpyo, for the way MNET constantly gives him screentime. MNET hurts a lot of trainees just by doing this, since it's a survival show, it's easy to feel dislike towards someone over something that they've no control of. :l
 
Joined
23 November 2018
Messages
592
Reactions Received
2,029
Location
Buddy Hole
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Pronouns
she/her
I haven't finished watching the episode yet, but I honestly like the 10+X rule already. Now shit like Jonghyun or Kaeun doesn't happen, where a trainee is in top11 constantly but doesn't make it in just because the people at Mnet are total asshats when it comes to final episodes.
 

JakeyWantsCakey

Stan Treasure!
.
.
Joined
22 February 2019
Messages
9,507
Reactions Received
26,077
Location
UK
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
0
Gender
Male

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Viewing thread