Na Haeun Solo or Girl Group (1 Viewer)

[JJbaker]

Na Haeun is 11
so this / next year we will see signs what path she is planning to take...

but what do you think she should take
solo or group
plus what company as she currently in a kid company

Her most recent mv:



I think she should join a 7 member group
as
sub vocalist
visual
Main dancer

and i think she suits jyp tbh
or
sm​

 

[bulletproof]

wait wait wait is she gonna debut in a regular idol group? or something for kids? I don't know her

 

[JJbaker]

wait wait wait is she gonna debut in a regular idol group? or something for kids? I don't know her

ATM she is in a company what helps kids get to being idols
[same as super kids]

she is most known for her dance covers
and dancing at the award shows...
also being back up dancer for red velvet [zimzalabim]


but as she is 11 now she is coming up to the age range that her current known company stops at

also the legal age to go on shows properly is 13 so we will see signs of her chosing what her future is as a idol soon
[plus with the company now pushing a boy group it shows there ready for na haeun to be too old for the cutesy stuff]

Spoiler: Her more known stuff videos

 

[bulletproof]

ATM she is in a company what helps kids get to being idols
[same as super kids]

she is most known for her dance covers
and dancing at the award shows...
also being back up dancer for red velvet [zimzalabim]


but as she is 11 now she is coming up to the age range that her current known company stops at

also the legal age to go on shows properly is 13 so we will see signs of her chosing what her future is as a idol soon
[plus with the company now pushing a boy group it shows there ready for na haeun to be too old for the cutesy stuff]

Spoiler: Her more known stuff videos

I think she will go big then, she definitely has potential

 

[JJbaker]

I think she will go big then, she definitely has potential

I hope a big company takes her cause i dont think a small company will be able to do her right
as even though her fan base is decent
she has fan base from all the groups she has helped or met through out the years
from itzy/exo/twice/jay park -- to -- momoland oneus enoi

 

[bulletproof]

I hope a big company takes her cause i dont think a small company will be able to do her right
as even though her fan base is decent
she has fan base from all the groups she has helped or met through out the years
from itzy/exo/twice/jay park -- to -- momoland oneus enoi

definitely, after so many years of hard work she deserves a good company

 

[RandAlThor]

She isn't the girl who did the choro for Psycho right? I thought she was 15.

This girl has a ton of covers up.
She would need someone ready to debut her or the group ...
ITZY is still new.
Sm is never going to act.
and YG is full of s.
Soo
maybe with some of the Izone kids if it falls apart.

 

[JJbaker]

She isn't the girl who did the choro for Psycho right? I thought she was 15.

This girl has a ton of covers up.
She would need someone ready to debut her or the group ...
ITZY is still new.
Sm is never going to act.
and YG is full of s.
Soo
maybe with some of the Izone kids if it falls apart.

Well my thoughts is...
with jyp
as she is only 11 now [January 16th, 2009 ]
jyp would wait until atleast 14/15 < for debut stuff
so thats 3/4 years down the line
so itzy will be a old group by then

sm new gg would be 3/4 years old by time she reaches the rule on debut age as well

even though sm likes to wait 7 years between groups...
this could change with girl groups becoming more popular then boys

 

[RandAlThor]

Well my thoughts is...
with jyp
as she is only 11 now [January 16th, 2009 ]
jyp would wait until atleast 14/15 < for debut stuff
so thats 3/4 years down the line
so itzy will be a old group by then

sm new gg would be 3/4 years old by time she reaches the rule on debut age as well

even though sm likes to wait 7 years between groups...
this could change with girl groups becoming more popular then boys

Is she going to have that kind of patience?
She is marketable now.
4 years is forever to an 11 year old. Especially with her fame.
Somi did not make it even with work to keep her busy.

 

[yeji]

she really is talented

 

[JJbaker]

Is she going to have that kind of patience?
She is marketable now.
4 years is forever to an 11 year old. Especially with her fame.
Somi did not make it even with work to keep her busy.

Theory:
[I think cause her mum is very much in control of her career [by what i see on her vlogs]
and has been keeping her sister back a bit
and she does a little less tv work then she used to
i think the aim is to wait until she is a little older
as it seems to be once she has done the "job" they leave
i.e mma 2017 she stayed around and watch the show
2019 she prerecorded 1 part and left right after the live of the second]

But if she wanted to rush it
1. she wouldn't be able to perform on any stages atm as the legal age is 13
2. she would lose all her collabs and mma work if she debuts as the second she debuts she will lose all the business she has now
so timing would be key
[she also does modeling atm]

 

[JJbaker]

she really is talented

agreed

 

[RandAlThor]

Theory:
[I think cause her mum is very much in control of her career [by what i see on her vlogs]
and has been keeping her sister back a bit
and she does a little less tv work then she used to
i think the aim is to wait until she is a little older
as it seems to be once she has done the "job" they leave
i.e mma 2017 she stayed around and watch the show
2019 she prerecorded 1 part and left right after the live of the second]

But if she wanted to rush it
1. she wouldn't be able to perform on any stages atm as the legal age is 13
2. she would lose all her collabs and mma work if she debuts as the second she debuts she will lose all the business she has now
so timing would be key
[she also does modeling atm]

Wouldn't joining an agency kill the collabs too except for maybe in house?
She will have so much popularity it is a really really fine line between joining to train up more and folks forgetting about you.
I think either option would let her keep the modeling gigs ... Maybe a big agency gets her more of those.

Also leaving major agency's has a super negative cost for the kids (just because i think folks blame the kids for not making it into the big agency's group) except for the Idle girl and Somi kinda. Chaeyeon clearly got dropped because JYP did not think she was pretty enough folks will not hold that against her. Unlike say Natty.

 

[JJbaker]

Wouldn't joining an agency kill the collabs too except for maybe in house?
She will have so much popularity it is a really really fine line between joining to train up more and folks forgetting about you.
I think either option would let her keep the modeling gigs ... Maybe a big agency gets her more of those.

Also leaving major agency's has a super negative cost for the kids (just because i think folks blame the kids for not making it into the big agency's group) except for the Idle girl and Somi kinda. Chaeyeon clearly got dropped because JYP did not think she was pretty enough folks will not hold that against her. Unlike say Natty.

I think she should wait until maybe 12 and go for a bigger company what has more focus on tv shows etc
like jyp he loves making his idols tv hosts
and hopefully he will keep her on tv side of things until she ready to debut

 

[RandAlThor]

I think she should wait until maybe 12 and go for a bigger company what has more focus on tv shows etc
like jyp he loves making his idols tv hosts
and hopefully he will keep her on tv side of things until she ready to debut

True SM also has its girls especially on music bank or MBC too. Yeri Krystal Tiffany Yuri Taeyeon Seohyun at least on music core.
Amber was on show champ for years.
Music show gig would be interesting as a trainee....That would also leave collabs open at least on that station.

 

[JJbaker]

True SM also has its girls especially on music bank or MBC too. Yeri Krystal Tiffany Yuri Taeyeon Seohyun at least on music core.
Amber was on show champ for years.
Music show gig would be interesting as a trainee....That would also leave collabs open at least on that station.

i think w.e she does will have to be specialised to her

the only similar situation to this is g dragon
and that was ages ago
and i pray she doesnt enter no comeback yg