If another group had released Twice's 'I Can't Stop Me' do you think it would have been a hit? (2 Viewers)

[Suzy]

I know it sounds crazy, I mean, if Twice can't make it a hit who can? But I really think 'I Can't Stop Me' is a hit level song. The only issue is, the general public don't want mature Twice, they want cute Twice and considering they didn't even peak in the top 10, it's obvious that the general public didn't even bother to listen to the song. I mean, their UL count was less than 250k which was even less that RV SeulRene who debuted as a UNIT (they had 400k+ day 1).

So my theory is, if a group that already has a mature image that the public has accepted, idk maybe like Mamamoo or RV (Velvet side), I think the song would have been HUGE. I honestly don't care for Twice at all but the song is so good. Honestly, it's one of the best releases of the year and I even like it better than all the songs my faves released this year minus Psycho if that counts as a 2020 release. I have literally had it on repeat since release. And it seems most others who listened to it also loved it. So I really can't believe that people think it's a bad song, it's just that the public does not want mature Twice so they're not even bothering to listen to their songs. I guess that's the downside of having a clear cut image and sound and blowing up with it. Same happened to GFriend of the new gen top girl groups and SNSD of old gen.

What do you guys think?



@Once @Girl Group​

 

[Suzy]

Also I'm not saying that I Can't Stop Me is a song that would suit MMM or RV. I think it suits Twice perfectly. It's just that they marketed it as a more mature concept which the girls dressed in suits and serious looks rather than their usual cute outfits and smiles. If they had debuted with that more serious concept rather than their refreshing/cute concept and hit big, then I think this song would have been accepted by the public. But because it's the opposite of what the general public fell for, they're not accepting it. So I'm wondering if a group with a more mature concept had done it, would have have been a hit.

Like it's still a catchy pop song that Twice usually releases but THE CONCEPT is different. And that's what's inhibiting the success of the song in my opinion.

 

[Darkseid]

Yeah the song would really do well if some other group released it imo. It’s not a question of the song but the public’s expectations from the group and it seems the gp at large still isn’t ready to move on from cute Twice.

It’s why songs like DTNA have had such insane longevity despite being a vastly inferior song to ICSM imo. The way this underperformed on charts really surprised me, even the worst charting Itzy title outcharted this which I didn’t expect.

Regardless Twice is at a point where they really don’t need to worry anymore about stats and achievements since they’ve done it all and wil likely never be surpassed in many years so hopefully they stick to this direction and keep putting out music they identify with more. If it’s anything like ICSM I’ll love it.

 

[Abeamus]

Potentially yes but also potentially no as we're in a digital decline and interest in groups as a whole is different and lower than it was before and Twices charting hasn't been their best for a while.

Mamamoo or Red Velvet have had shaky charting in the past too however their last comebacks did relatively well so the interest might've carried them into people checking it out.

Digitally speaking Kpop is in a bad position with public interest in groups as apart from BTS then only really Blackpink and Oh My Girl have done really well this year and we really need new groups rising to the occasion this late into a generation and we don't really have that.

 

[eclipsoul]

most likely yes but let's just say that twice did it for the arts not the charts

 

[Evergreen]

Probably. I saw a lot of Knetzs saying that the song is good but that it’s not the Twice that they want.

 

[JakeyWantsCakey]

Unpopular Opinion: I Can't Stop Me is just a poor man's La Di Da...

 

[Suzy]

Unpopular Opinion: I Can't Stop Me is just a poor man's La Di Da...

Whaaaaat? How? They sound nothing alike to me.
Both are my top girl group songs of the year though so maybe they do sound alike and I just haven't realised

 

[JakeyWantsCakey]

Whaaaaat? How? They sound nothing alike to me.
Both are my top girl group songs of the year though so maybe they do sound alike and I just haven't realised

The genre is exactly the same and I think Everglow's song is just a lot more impactful.

 

[QueenB]

I'm surprised that it didn't do that well on charts. I could see it doing well internationally though because it has a Dua Lipa sound to it

 

[yeji]

honestly the gp will never be ready to move on from cute twice. this just proves it again and again

 

[SHlNEE]

how is this not a success? they got almost 80m views within 1 week
a lot of western artists can't do that

i really like the song too and the mv is GORG art wise
but i don't understand why there is a subway scene in it when the rest is so much more artistic
feels out of place
also, in the last outfits, momo is rocking it

 

[Suzy]

how is this not a success? they got almost 80m views within 1 week
a lot of western artists can't do that

i really like the song too and the mv is GORG art wise
but i don't understand why there is a subway scene in it when the rest is so much more artistic
feels out of place
also, in the last outfits, momo is rocking it

I wasn't talking about Youtube views, I was talking about the song's actual success on charts. They didn't peak in the top 20 on Melon which is a first for Twice and their unique listeners was less than 250k which is a lot less than the 600k+ they would usually get. It's clear that the public simply has not even bothered to listen to the song and I would say it's because of their concept change. They have a clear image about Twice they like and mature isn't it unfortunately. If they had given the song a chance though, it would have undoubtedly been a hit. It's one of their best songs.

 

[SHlNEE]

I wasn't talking about Youtube views, I was talking about the song's actual success on charts. They didn't peak in the top 20 on Melon which is a first for Twice and their unique listeners was less than 250k which is a lot less than the 600k+ they would usually get. It's clear that the public simply has not even bothered to listen to the song and I would say it's because of their concept change. They have a clear image about Twice they like and mature isn't it unfortunately. If they had given the song a chance though, it would have undoubtedly been a hit. It's one of their best songs.

so if i understand you correctly
this mv shows them in a mature way and not a cute way?
that is what other folks think?


i clearly see cute faces and cute outfits and cute dancing
so

 

[Darkseid]

Seems they might start doing better slowly.

The song has climbed up to 18 on Melon Daily now, hope it continues to rise