Soshi vs Red Velvet vs Aespa (1 Viewer)

[VillageIdiot]

Who had the best remake?

SNSD

Spoiler

Red Velvet

Spoiler

Aespa

Spoiler

 

[VillageIdiot]

@Sone @Reveluv @My

 

[RandAlThor]

I vote for eman here GG was more fun.

I think be natural was better for RV long term as it locked in the R and b style they wanted for the velvet.

 

[Darkseid]

Pulling system up up, TY track

Ok but fr, Girls' Generation ofc

 

[mysteric]

the f(x) erasure with hot summer

 

[dnb]

Musically, I think all 3 remakes are equally good.

As for the nonmusical aspects of the MVs? I think Red Velvet in suits is their all-time iconic look, and their dancing on chairs is yet another factor that sets their MV apart.

 

[Abeamus]

Girls' Generation stands up the best I feel

 

[VillageIdiot]

the f(x) erasure with hot summer

I meant of their seniors
And it deserves erasure

 

[mysteric]

I meant of their seniors
And it deserves erasure

indeed it does

 

[emptycup]

Girls generation, i'm not even being biased Everything from the song (the prechorus +the taengsic bridge hello) to the mv are iconic.

 

[naturalqueen]

red velvet ofc, i dont like snsd music that much while aespa only has two songs

 

[Minju]

SNSD

 

[yeji]

RV

 

[eclipsoul]

today i learned one of my favourite snsd songs was a remake

 

[LoveYooShaSha]

SNSD, its their call sign(directly influencing them being named Girls'Generation)

 

[Evergreen]

I prefer Forever