Would NCT be better of? (1 Viewer)

[JJbaker]

If nct debuted like seventeen
but with 15 members...

this what i think the line up would be
[yes taeil can hold a note but he isnt the best singer overall and i dont think he would be picked over other members]
@NCTzen

@Jimimis do you agree with the line up??

 

[maruberry]

Considering my favourite members aren't in this lineup, nope I disagree

 

[JJbaker]

Considering my favourite members aren't in this lineup, nope I disagree

who are your favourite?

 

[daesuki]

Considering my favourite members aren't in this lineup, nope I disagree

ten is weeping rn

 

[maruberry]

who are your favourite?

Kun is one of my ults
and Chenle is my no.2 in NCT and my bias in Dream

 

[maruberry]

ten is weeping rn

He is my no.3 lmao

 

[JJbaker]

Kun is one of my ults
and Chenle is my no.2 in NCT and my bias in Dream

I love chenle and kun
but there vocal skills arent strong enough to put them over others
i cant see who i would swap a member for from the vocal line

maybe haechan for chenle but haechan is purely there cause of his unique sound

 

[maruberry]

I love chenle and kun
but there vocal skills arent strong enough to put them over others
i cant see who i would swap a member for from the vocal line

maybe haechan for chenle but haechan is purely there cause of his unique sound

But I'd argue the way you made the lineup isn't the way Seventeen has it.

I'd argue that when debuting all of Seventeen's members weren't all kill amazing at what they did.
Jeonghan even didn't have any lines in Adore U lmao and instead lipsynced to Seungkwan singing

 

[JJbaker]

But I'd argue the way you made the lineup isn't the way Seventeen has it.

I'd argue that when debuting all of Seventeen's members weren't all kill amazing at what they did.
Jeonghan even didn't have any lines in Adore U lmao and instead lipsynced to Seungkwan singing

they are
vocal unit
performance unit [aka dance unit]
hip hop unit [aka all rappers]

and you would obv debut the better person
as all of nct bring personality to the table
so i dunno why you would put kun or chenle over other vocalist
make a argument for them please :]

 

[Jimimis]

If nct debuted like seventeen
but with 15 members...

this what i think the line up would be
[yes taeil can hold a note but he isnt the best singer overall and i dont think he would be picked over other members]
@NCTzen

@Jimimis do you agree with the line up??

Remove 13 of them

 

[maruberry]

they are
vocal unit
performance unit [aka dance unit]
hip hop unit [aka all rappers]

and you would obv debut the better person
as all of nct bring personality to the table
so i dunno why you would put kun or chenle over other vocalist
make a argument for them please :]

There is more to being an idol than just the base level skills. Sure those are DEFINITELY important as well, but those aren't the only factors.

Kun is a leader + he produces music! (And it looks like SM is allowing him to do that) He is the one all of the Chinese members rely heavily on.
Chenle is the social butterfly, he would do wonders in keeping the group together and communicating. He is the most extroverted of extroverts in NCT.

Honestly I just love NCT the way they are right now too much to like any other alternative

 

[JJbaker]

There is more to being an idol than just the base level skills. Sure those are DEFINITELY important as well, but those aren't the only factors.

Kun is a leader + he produces music! (And it looks like SM is allowing him to do that) He is the one all of the Chinese members rely heavily on.
Chenle is the social butterfly, he would do wonders in keeping the group together and communicating. He is the most extroverted of extroverts in NCT.

Honestly I just love NCT the way they are right now too much to like any other alternative

I honestly feel if kun wasn't in nct very early on and wasn't debuted
and fans weren't pissed about this...
and being the oldest
and ten being Thai not Chinese
Ten would of been the leader

alot of the members produce music though and sm wont ever use there music they create
as sm has said multiple times they dont think idols need to do this anymore
but i really really hope we get to see all there work
as i would love nct 2022 be a fully member produced album [music dance etc]

being social butterfly outside of your own group isnt good
chenle ledgit forgot korean between boom and ridin...
when 5 out of 7 dream members are korean..
it says alot
it just says chenle will jump ship second he gets a chance

 

[maruberry]

I honestly feel if kun wasn't in nct very early on and wasn't debuted
and fans weren't pissed about this...
and being the oldest
and ten being Thai not Chinese
Ten would of been the leader

alot of the members produce music though and sm wont ever use there music they create
as sm has said multiple times they dont think idols need to do this anymore
but i really really hope we get to see all there work
as i would love nct 2022 be a fully member produced album [music dance etc]

being social butterfly outside of your own group isnt good
chenle ledgit forgot korean between boom and ridin...
when 5 out of 7 dream members are korean..
it says alot
it just says chenle will jump ship second he gets a chance

I dunno how sure I would be about Kun not being allowed to produce part, considering there is a very high chance WayV's next mini contains a Kun produced track. + SM has allowed him to talk about it a lot openly, has shown him learning to produce on the official YT channel etc. TWO seperate producers have tagged him alongside other producers when posting about the WayV mini.

Also in what world would Ten be leader over Kun???? You could not make it any more clear that you don't follow WayV, considering how much EVERYBODY in WayV (including Ten) appreciate him being the leader.

There is 0 reason for Ten to be a leader over Kun. ZERO! His personality doesn't fit being a leader nowhere NEAR as well as Kun's does! ANY of the WayV members will tell you that whenever they have any kind of problem they go to Kun for help. Ten himself has said and I quote "Everybody in WayV is immature, except for Kun". Ten doesn't WANT to be a leader!

Kun is a god damn perfect candidate for leader! I would even go as far as to say that imo he is one of the best idols leaders period! He puts everything he has into the group!

Chenle lives on his own... that's it. Between boom and ridin' I'm pretty sure his aunt/mom was also still living with him. 3 guesses as to what language he would be using day to day when not promoting! Atm the members are coming over constantly, to the point Chenle has even complained that they are treating his house like their own home at times! Haechan would just come over when Chenle is out without telling him even! Chenle has a picture of Mark hanging in his own home!

 

[JJbaker]

I dunno how sure I would be about Kun not being allowed to produce part, considering there is a very high chance WayV's next mini contains a Kun produced track. + SM has allowed him to talk about it a lot openly, has shown him learning to produce on the official YT channel etc. TWO seperate producers have tagged him alongside other producers when posting about the WayV mini.

Also in what world would Ten be leader over Kun???? You could not make it any more clear that you don't follow WayV, considering how much EVERYBODY in WayV (including Ten) appreciate him being the leader.

There is 0 reason for Ten to be a leader over Kun. ZERO! His personality doesn't fit being a leader nowhere NEAR as well as Kun's does! ANY of the WayV members will tell you that whenever they have any kind of problem they go to Kun for help. Ten himself has said and I quote "Everybody in WayV is immature, except for Kun". Ten doesn't WANT to be a leader!

Kun is a god damn perfect candidate for leader! I would even go as far as to say that imo he is one of the best idols leaders period! He puts everything he has into the group!

Chenle lives on his own... that's it. Between boom and ridin' I'm pretty sure his aunt/mom was also still living with him. 3 guesses as to what language he would be using day to day when not promoting! Atm the members are coming over constantly, to the point Chenle has even complained that they are treating his house like their own home at times! Haechan would just come over when Chenle is out without telling him even! Chenle has a picture of Mark hanging in his own home!

Sm loves Ten thats what im going off
plus if i had choose in 127 who was the leader it wouldnt be taeyong

i wasnt dissing his abilities to be a leader im just saying i dont think sm would of picked him if somethings were different

Kun is never put at equal level to taeyong as a leader within nct so i dont think leader ablitie is always key as i know kun would prob be better being the main leader within nct
in all seriousness sm needs to consider pushing this as taeyong bulling scandals may get pulled into the bullying scandal hype train..

yeh also saying chenle being social isnt a reason to have him in a group at all
alot of the other members are social just follow korean age rules due to that how they were brought up

 

[maruberry]

Sm loves Ten thats what im going off
plus if i had choose in 127 who was the leader it wouldnt be taeyong

i wasnt dissing his abilities to be a leader im just saying i dont think sm would of picked him if somethings were different

Kun is never put at equal level to taeyong as a leader within nct so i dont think leader ablitie is always key as i know kun would prob be better being the main leader within nct
in all seriousness sm needs to consider pushing this as taeyong bulling scandals may get pulled into the bullying scandal hype train..

yeh also saying chenle being social isnt a reason to have him in a group at all
alot of the other members are social just follow korean age rules due to that how they were brought up

SM doesn't really pick leader based on popularity or who they want to push though?
I mean.... Suho? Onew?

I do agree Kun's personality is better fitted to being a leader than Taeyong, but in 127 I can't really imagine who would be a leader instead of him. I think Taeyong is... He does a REALLY good job as a leader, but it doesn't come as easily to him as it does with some others. It takes more of a toll out of him, but I think nobody else in 127 could do as good of a job as him as the leader.

I don't necessarily think Kun is doing a better job as a leader, just that being a leader is taking more out of TY than it takes out of Kun.

Seeing Taeyong help Sungchan with rap and recording definitely made me see more how good TY is at being a leader. A lot of the job is behind the scenes so we don't really notice it THAT often.

 

[karinaknows]

NCT would be better off if it was just NCT 127.

They have the best lineup and discography, imo.

 

[maruberry]

NCT would be better off if it was just NCT 127.

They have the best lineup and discography, imo.

The WayV discography slander!
WayV's Awaken the world album is just IMPECCABLE

 

[karinaknows]

The WayV discography slander!
WayV's Awaken the world album is just IMPECCABLE

I haven't heard it

 

[maruberry]

I haven't heard it

Ok that is criminal considering it's legit one of the best albums of the year!
Not a single skip, not a single song not worth listening to!

The whole album just VIBES together so well, I never skip a song bcs it doesn't fit my current mood. If I am in the mood to listen to the album, I am in the mood to listen to the entire thing!

At one point the entire album was my most listened to tracks, bcs I just listened to the album on loop!

It is SO GOOD, my favourites are After Midnight and Electric Hearts, but all the other tracks are SO AMAZING as well!

 

[Mayday]

I haven't heard it

but NCT U-