Has a member leaving the group ever led you to liking a group less? (1 Viewer)

[Myco]

Not that I can remember

 

[SnowWhite]

My ultimate bias group Hello Venus at the time (2013-2015)
I tried to resist when Ara and Yoonjo left in summer 2014 but welp, everything changed including their whole image. I tried to resist still but no, I guess the new Hello Venus was just not for me.

 

[Ahsoka]

I don’t think it’s ever happened to me but it could have happened I think if the circumstances were right

 

[lexus]

I lost interest in AOA after Choa and Mina left. Lost interest even more after the bullying controversy and unstanned completely

 

[chiefchilly1]

PIXY

 

[PloryWinxyMYBlnk]

Unfortunately, this shockingly happened to two of my favorite 4th generation rookie groups recently with Purple Kiss and PIXY.
PK has one less member and PIXY has two less members, but they [ PIXY ] already has a new member join the group because she went on tour with the rest of them for the past some months.

Did that change my stance in loving them less?
No. I can understand why some members decide to leave the industry because of the strenuous physical and psychological demand they were put through and ultimately they realize it is not right for them.

As for Girls' Generation's situation, that was surprising as well when SM and Jessica decided to part ways.
I still supported her solo music career by purchasing her albums and I did not love any of the members less regardless of how her departure occurred.

 

[PWSwan]

iKON wasn't my style any more after BI left/got kicked out.

It also happened with one of my favorite Western acts; I gave up on the group entirely and stanned the member who left.

 

[ChiaraStar169]

iKON wasn't my style any more after BI left/got kicked out.

It also happened with one of my favorite Western acts; I gave up on the group entirely and stanned the member who left.

same - when 1D broke up, I gave up and just started solo stanning Harry (well, OT5, but Harry's been most successful)

 

[Jewel]

For example, in case the title is confusing:
Do you like Monsta X less after Wonho left?

but for other groups such as SNSD, VIXX, EXO, Momoland, etc

Omg, the Monsta X case is literally me. I wasn't into it as much after he left.

 

[Jewel]

It's never affected me, but even as somebody who isn't much into iKon, I was gutted when B.I left.



I don't think we'll ever know what happened, but I remember when Baekhyun released his clothing line Prive, the other EXO members were supporting him and even promoting/wearing his stuff on Instagram. That made me wonder more about SNSD and what went down with Jessica.

The B.I. situation is literally how I feel. I barely listened to iKon when he left.

 

[Selfmate]

nope it was sad for a while after soojin left but life goes on