News Hybe/MHJ Civil War Megathread (4 Viewers)

Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
7. Following Hive's rebuttal regarding other follow-up reports related to shareholder contracts,

speculations and distortions related to shareholder contracts are rife in various follow-up reports confirmed by Hive through the media. We would like to inform you to correct any further misunderstandings.

Hive is misleading the public by saying that CEO Min Hee-jin insisted on a multiple of 30 in relation to put options, as if the current conflict was motivated by financial motives. However, the 30 multiple reflected the future production value of the boy group, and was only one of the proposals in the process of changing the contract between shareholders, which had various unreasonable elements, and was not a priority item for negotiation.

In addition, Hive promised an additional 10% of Adore's shares as a stock option to CEO Min Hee-jin when signing the stock purchase agreement and shareholder agreement in March last year. However, as a result of legal advice, we learned that stock options cannot be granted to CEO Min Hee-jin, a major shareholder, under commercial law. These stock options were not requested by CEO Min Hee-jin, but were suggested by Hive. CEO Min Hee-jin could not help but think that Hive had deceived him. It was a matter of ‘trust’.

Hive offered to lift the non-competition obligation, and CEO Min Hee-jin said he refused, but this is also not true. Hive proposed that employees be required to serve for 8 years and be subject to a non-competition obligation for 1 year after retirement, and that put options be exercised in stages according to that period. However, while the shareholder contract negotiations were in progress, a controversy related to eyelets arose and continues to this day. Regarding Hive's proposal, CEO Min Hee-jin has not communicated any relevant position. It is not true that CEO Min Hee-jin expressed her intention to refuse.

8. Regarding the fact that shamans are mere acquaintances,

the success of Newgenes and the amazing performance that Adore achieved in a short period of time are based on rational management decisions. These claims appear to be framed by Hive to denigrate and deny Adore's success.

The reason for Adore's sales and operating profit is that it has increased its value by preventing unnecessary spending, managing its budget efficiently, and working to improve its brand image. If it is possible as they claim, why are CEO Min Hee-jin and Adore members working hard day and night?

It is pathetic that Hive, which is supposed to lead K-POP, attempted to frame it as a personal slander that was unrelated to the issue and not worth responding to, and that it was announced right before CEO Min Hee-jin's press conference.

9. Regarding the fact that Hive does not spare New Genes,

it was Hive that announced the sudden audit on April 22nd and announced it to the media without the results of the audit being released. They made claims of impossible 'usurpation of management rights' without any specific evidence, and did not even attempt to hear Adore's position internally, and raised this issue ahead of New Jeans' comeback.

Hive claims to have suggested ‘not mentioning the artist’. If they judged that attacking CEO Min Hee-jin and Adore by bringing out a problem that could be resolved quietly internally would not affect the brand value of New Jeans, this was an idea that did not understand the label's management at all and was a result of their management problems. This is a sophistry meant to cover up faulty judgment.

I hope the above information will help resolve any further speculations and misunderstandings.

On April 16, CEO Min Hee-jin filed an internal complaint, pointing out several issues, saying, “Hive lacks preparation, understanding, and attitude toward the multi-label system.” It was a direct statement made in reliance on the guidelines proposed by Chairman Bang Si-hyuk, which said, “Speak out your differences and opinions even if it is difficult to speak when faced with the absurdity and irrationality of the business,” but it returned to the current extreme situation with the claim of “breach of trust.”

Now and in the future, Adore will do its best to support New Genes’ activities. If Hive wants to protect its IP, as it claims, and truly cares about the interests of its shareholders, I hope it will stop its unconvincing black propaganda and show common sense in supporting Adore so that it can fully focus on creation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RandAlThor
Joined
29 December 2022
Messages
1,037
Reactions Received
1,466
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
7,083
Ador's statement is pretty weak tbh. Seems to be that MHJ's contract is the only substantive thing they have?

Both sides keeping going on about really irrelevant stuff like which group was supposed to debut first.

I want to hear about the curse the shaman placed on BTS.
 
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
Ador's statement is pretty weak tbh. Seems to be that MHJ's contract is the only substantive thing they have?

Both sides keeping going on about really irrelevant stuff like which group was supposed to debut first.

I want to hear about the curse the shaman placed on BTS.
it's because all the juicy and important stuff they save for court whilst throwing bones at us peasant folk
 
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
59,430
Reactions Received
93,258
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
183,519
Fandom
WizSoneLuv
Clearly she was supposed to debut a group with Sseras concept with Sakura from source.

She didnt want to,
she .. to put a positive spin on it ... fought to get the girls she wanted from source and create her own company.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Selfmate
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
Heejin Min, Adore board meeting to be held on the 10th
Seoul = Newsis] Reporter Lee Jae-hoon = ADOR, the agency of the group 'New Jeans', is expected to hold a board of directors meeting.

According to the industry on the 7th, Adore's board of directors, including CEO Min Hee-jin, notified Adore's parent company, HYBE, that they will hold a board meeting in Seoul on the morning of the 10th.

Currently, Adore's board of directors consists of Min Hee-jin, including CEO Min, Vice President (VP) Shin, and Senior Creative Director Kim.

The item on the agenda for this board meeting is the convening of an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders. If you decide to hold a general meeting on the same day, the general meeting date will be scheduled 15 days later. Since the 25th and 26th are weekends, the earliest the meeting can be held is the 27th.

Previously, on the 30th of last month, Adore's law firm Sejong responded, "We will hold a board meeting" at the hearing of Hive's application for permission to convene a general meeting filed with the court on the 30th of last month. It was also announced that the general meeting of shareholders would be held by the end of this month.

If Adore's board of directors refuses to convene a general meeting of shareholders on the day of the board of directors, the court will decide whether to convene a general meeting of shareholders on the 13th.

Since Hive owns 80% of Adore's shares, CEO Min's dismissal is certain when the hiring meeting is held. However, the legal battle is expected to become more intense following his dismissal.

This is because it is expected that Representative Min's side will consider whether the dismissal of Representative Min was justified. Hive is claiming that CEO Min conspired to usurp Adore management rights and committed breach of trust. Representative Min is protesting against this

Source: https://m.entertain.naver.com/article/003/0012530997
 
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
Min Hee-jin, “Application for provisional injunction prohibiting exercise of voting rights” in response to request for Hive’s extraordinary general meeting [Official]

[Reporter Lee Min-ji on the news] Min Hee-jin, CEO of Adore, filed a provisional injunction against Hive to ban the exercise of voting rights.

Representative Min Hee-jin said on May 7, "Representative Min Hee-jin filed a provisional injunction against Hive today to the Seoul Central District Court to ban the exercise of voting rights."

Earlier, Hive requested an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders for the dismissal of CEO and in-house director Min Hee-jin.

CEO Min Hee-jin said, "This violates the shareholder contract signed with CEO Min Hee-jin," adding, "CEO Min Hee-jin applied for a provisional injunction to ban the exercise of voting rights against Hive, with the right to claim the performance of the contract between shareholders as the right to be preserved."

CEO Min Hee-jin also said, "Hive's claim of breach of trust is absurd, and we have applied for a provisional injunction to ban the exercise of voting rights to protect the corporate value of Adore's artists and Adore's."

Source: https://m.entertain.naver.com/article/609/0000850811
 
  • Haha
Reactions: RandAlThor
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
59,430
Reactions Received
93,258
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
183,519
Fandom
WizSoneLuv
Min Hee-jin, “Application for provisional injunction prohibiting exercise of voting rights” in response to request for Hive’s extraordinary general meeting [Official]

[Reporter Lee Min-ji on the news] Min Hee-jin, CEO of Adore, filed a provisional injunction against Hive to ban the exercise of voting rights.

Representative Min Hee-jin said on May 7, "Representative Min Hee-jin filed a provisional injunction against Hive today to the Seoul Central District Court to ban the exercise of voting rights."

Earlier, Hive requested an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders for the dismissal of CEO and in-house director Min Hee-jin.

CEO Min Hee-jin said, "This violates the shareholder contract signed with CEO Min Hee-jin," adding, "CEO Min Hee-jin applied for a provisional injunction to ban the exercise of voting rights against Hive, with the right to claim the performance of the contract between shareholders as the right to be preserved."

CEO Min Hee-jin also said, "Hive's claim of breach of trust is absurd, and we have applied for a provisional injunction to ban the exercise of voting rights to protect the corporate value of Adore's artists and Adore's."

Source: https://m.entertain.naver.com/article/609/0000850811
Sweetheart...

At this level when your Company and the boss want you fired. Your toast.
Trust is gone. best ya can do is get some cash out of em.
But ill bet his lawyers are better than hers and that will not even happen.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Selfmate
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
Sweetheart...

At this level when your Company and the boss want you fired. Your toast.
Trust is gone. best ya can do is get some cash out of em.
But ill bet his lawyers are better than hers and that will not even happen.
with all due respect to NJ and their artistry, if I was sitting on the cash cow that is NJ I would fight tooth and nail to try to win that prize
 
  • Like
Reactions: RandAlThor
Joined
21 February 2019
Messages
59,430
Reactions Received
93,258
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
183,519
Fandom
WizSoneLuv
with all due respect to NJ and their artistry, if I was sitting on the cash cow that is NJ I would fight tooth and nail to try to win that prize
That's what makes it crazy.
you know Hybe had to be just over the top pissed off to do this. So early in the NJ run.
She pushed em too far and they said.

FINE! its on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Selfmate
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
That's what makes it crazy.
you know Hybe had to be just over the top pissed off to do this. So early in the NJ run.
She pushed em too far and they said.

FINE! its on.
absolutely the entire thing is a shit show from the very beginning
not to mention the damage to NJ brand where ever they end up
 
  • Like
Reactions: RandAlThor

mysteric

hysteric
.
Joined
26 February 2019
Messages
14,361
Reactions Received
27,573
Location
the moon
Website
newjeans.carrd.com
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
8,963
Fandom
MeU & MY
Gender
Female
Pronouns
she ✧ her
Ship
not just nj, lsfm is getting hit hard too by the news

it's honestly just sad for them, from the start they seemed to have been planned as the cash cow with no real long term plans but to peter out in such a manner is just pitiable and though no fault of their own

gp is siding more with mhj rn so at least it won't seem as bad as 50/50 case where they get labelled as ungrateful and such, especially not what you consider (if you are to believe mhj's words) the complete lack of communication between hybe/source and the nj members and their parents about their debut prospects after getting sakura on board into source

financially and legally though, I don't think mhj has anything to truly stand on, it may be a tactic to appear dumb but it's remarkable how naive she seems to have acted regarding business in general: not everyone is like lsm, a tax evader who will let you run free for years
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Selfmate
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
not just nj, lsfm is getting hit hard too by the news

it's honestly just sad for them, from the start they seemed to have been planned as the cash cow with no real long term plans but to peter out in such a manner is just pitiable and though no fault of their own

gp is siding more with mhj rn so at least it won't seem as bad as 50/50 case where they get labelled as ungrateful and such, especially not what you consider (if you are to believe mhj's words) the complete lack of communication between hybe/source and the nj members and their parents about their debut prospects after getting sakura on board into source

financially and legally though, I don't think mhj has anything to truly stand on, it may be a tactic to appear dumb but it's remarkable how naive she seems to have acted regarding business in general: not everyone is like lsm, a tax evader who will let you run free for years
LSFM was just coming off those week 1 coachella "can't sing live" accusations as well lol

for NJ this quote comes to mind (it's from a C-drama) "a man of character must be loyal to the king and love this nation - it is better to be a foolish subject than to partake in meaningless fights"

especially the second part - NJ and every Hybe GG should just shut up and continue to be idols and just do their job
also if they haven't already lawyer up individually!!!
 
Joined
29 December 2022
Messages
1,037
Reactions Received
1,466
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
7,083
I don't see any damage to NewJeans' brand tbh. Their stats are strong as ever.

There'll be extra scrutiny on them on their first few post-MHJ comebacks, I suppose, because people will be looking to project narratives about her creative direction being essential/inessential. At that point, it's just a question on whether or not HYBE can do a good job.

There's been a hate train against Le Sserafim since before this whole thing kicked off. But for as noisy as people are, again, their stats are very good. They'll also be fine. Worst case, they dip in Korea, but it looks like they're making up for it internationally ala Twice after their "scandal"-filled 2019-2020.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Selfmate

mysteric

hysteric
.
Joined
26 February 2019
Messages
14,361
Reactions Received
27,573
Location
the moon
Website
newjeans.carrd.com
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
8,963
Fandom
MeU & MY
Gender
Female
Pronouns
she ✧ her
Ship
LSFM was just coming off those week 1 coachella "can't sing live" accusations as well lol

for NJ this quote comes to mind (it's from a C-drama) "a man of character must be loyal to the king and love this nation - it is better to be a foolish subject than to partake in meaningless fights"

especially the second part - NJ and every Hybe GG should just shut up and continue to be idols and just do their job
also if they haven't already lawyer up individually!!!
it's an interesting case for sure on how disastrously everything fell out
 
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
I don't see any damage to NewJeans' brand tbh. Their stats are strong as ever.

There'll be extra scrutiny on them on their first few post-MHJ comebacks, I suppose, because people will be looking to project narratives about her creative direction being essential/inessential. At that point, it's just a question on whether or not HYBE can do a good job.

There's been a hate train against Le Sserafim since before this whole thing kicked off. But for as noisy as people are, again, their stats are very good. They'll also be fine. Worst case, they dip in Korea, but it looks like they're making up for it internationally ala Twice after their "scandal"-filled 2019-2020.
not right now since they haven't said anything yet but it will happen

can you imagine what will happen once this fully goes into court court and NJ and/or their parents get involved...I mean one of the allegations from MHJ was that NJ parents first raised the issue of Illit and plagiarism - obviously we as a GP don't know if that's true or not but that's going to matter in court

also I've said it before but do you not think Hybe has reached out to NJ/parents to clarify their views on things...I mean they would be foolish not to...and when it eventually comes out it's going to be interesting either way

also think about the journalists - someone is going to be asking the hard questions when NJ comeback fully - do you not think a journalist would ask them their thoughts on the hybe/mhj situation? I mean if I was a journalist I would lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: RandAlThor
Joined
29 December 2022
Messages
1,037
Reactions Received
1,466
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
7,083
not right now since they haven't said anything yet but it will happen

can you imagine what will happen once this fully goes into court court and NJ and/or their parents get involved...I mean one of the allegations from MHJ was that NJ parents first raised the issue of Illit and plagiarism - obviously we as a GP don't know if that's true or not but that's going to matter in court

also I've said it before but do you not think Hybe has reached out to NJ/parents to clarify their views on things...I mean they would be foolish not to...and when it eventually comes out it's going to be interesting either way

also think about the journalists - someone is going to be asking the hard questions when NJ comeback fully - do you not think a journalist would ask them their thoughts on the hybe/mhj situation? I mean if I was a journalist I would lol
The thing is, the parents aren't really a party to the dispute between HYBE and MHJ. That doesn't preclude them from getting involved, but it's not a given that they will. I think it's telling so far that they haven't. I mean, to your last paragraph - do you think journalists haven't been trying to contact them this entire time?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Selfmate
Joined
13 January 2023
Messages
50,070
Reactions Received
54,729
Cards
View Profile
KS Coins
282,340
The thing is, the parents aren't really a party to the dispute between HYBE and MHJ. That doesn't preclude them from getting involved, but it's not a given that they will. I think it's telling so far that they haven't. I mean, to your last paragraph - do you think journalists haven't been trying to contact them this entire time?
you're saying dispatch is in hybe's back pocket? hmmm....lol

well I meant based on this since they were children at the beginning

1715088777056.png


1715088718033.png


none of the members of NJ could have signed their initial contracts by themselves and 2 of them are still children by SK standards no? and the other reason I mentioned their parents is that MHJ referred to their parents in her allegations (again not sure whether it's true or not)
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Viewing thread