My problem with TXT (1 Viewer)

[JJbaker]

There is nothing special about them...

No unique concept - they been compared to nct dream ALOT
No member stands out - there all same height and all attractive
There no unique voice - all groups for most part have a member with a unique voice i.e nct haechan BTS jimin/v etc
They have no history - BTS members come from the underground scene etc...
[and being mixed and from another country is not a story cause alot of idols have similar or the same story
vernon, kim samuel, Lucas, etc]
The group is awkardly small... The vibe of the group feels like there missing members...
dunno why just feels like there not complete..

And sorry i love cute concept...
but ur tooo talll to do it
there taller then majority of bts members:
Soobin is 6FT
RM is 5ft11
Yeonjun 5ft11
Huenningkai 5ft10
Beomgyo 5ft10
Taehyun 5ft10
Jhope 5ft10
V 5ft10
Jungkook 5ft10
Suga 5ft8.5
Jimin 5ft8.3
​

 

[hearteyes]

I think you're being unnecessarily harsh, give them time to grow and find their medium. They only just debuted.

 

[maruberry]

I think the only part I agree with is the concept part.

The members not standing out, it can depend on the perspective, so I am not going there. I also don't know them well enough to judge dynamics etc...

They are going for the wrong concept, the members just don't fit the cute one! They are too tall and they frankly suck at acting cute and bubbly on stage.

 

[JJbaker]

I think you're being unnecessarily harsh, give them time to grow and find their medium. They only just debuted.

Harsh? i think ur looking to deep tbh
as i still like them and there still on my very short like list but my issues with them are mostly things what cant be changed..

There very tall >> never been a fan for tall groups
There a small group >> My smallest group was bts before them... i support seventeen and nct..
Plus they cant change there history..

 

[JJbaker]

I like to think no opinions are wrong, but reading this... honestly

you will get over it xD I still support them just im having a issue with them at the moment tbh

 

[maruberry]

1 more thing though... I have noticed they don't really seem to have any member that stand out with talent... I mean they have no standout talented vocalist, rapper or dancer.

 

[JJbaker]

I think the only part I agree with is the concept part.

The members not standing out, it can depend on the perspective, so I am not going there. I also don't know them well enough to judge dynamics etc...

They are going for the wrong concept, the members just don't fit the cute one! They are too tall and they frankly suck at acting cute and bubbly on stage.

well they do hiphop or a mature concept
and start actuall showing real personality
apart from the members feeling uncomfortable
my problems will be solved
but showing there 100% real personality is normally a debut thing before the company can change there personalitys
and i just see uncomfortable kids being pushed in bts shadow

 

[maruberry]

well they do hiphop or a mature concept
and start actuall showing real personality
apart from the members feeling uncomfortable
my problems will be solved
but showing there 100% real personality is normally a debut thing before the company can change there personalitys
and i just see uncomfortable kids being pushed in bts shadow

The BTS shadow IS strong on them. Frankly I feel like 90% of their fans are ARMY and they have barely any fans purely of their own!

 

[Siros]

you will get over it xD I still support them just im having a issue with them at the moment tbh

U can have all the issues you want with them, but there was no need to word it so rude and harshly. Chill girl

 

[hearteyes]

Harsh? i think ur looking to deep tbh
as i still like them and there still on my very short like list but my issues with them are mostly things what cant be changed..

There very tall >> never been a fan for tall groups
There a small group >> My smallest group was bts before them... i support seventeen and nct..
Plus they cant change there history..

That's your personal preference and you should stan who you want to stan, there are dozens of shorter groups with more members out there so take your pick. I personally like prefer to stan smaller groups with fewer members, BTS is the largest group I stan.

 

[GloriousHavoc]

They are too tall and they frankly suck at acting cute and bubbly on stage.

Spoiler

But... how does Mingyu do it?
This got me thinking... he really is the most naturally cute SVT member despite towering them all

 

[maruberry]

Spoiler

But... how does Mingyu do it?
This got me thinking... he really is the most naturally cute SVT member despite towering them all

He is naturally cute, but I don't think he could pull of NCT Dream's chewing gum!

It is natural cuteness vs doing aegyo!
One is purely instinct, while the other demands practice and specific looks!

 

[GloriousHavoc]

He is naturally cute, but I don't think he could pull of NCT Dream's chewing gum!

It is natural cuteness vs doing aegyo!
One is purely instinct, while the other demands practice and specific looks!

Spoiler

I honestly think Adore U era Mingyu would nail it

 

[maruberry]

Spoiler

I honestly think Adore U era Mingyu would nail it

Adore U era Seventeen was full of Aegyo... I adore that era...

 

[Foxia]

I'm not a stan but so far..
I think the songs are ok for now.
Yeonjun is the only one that stands out IMO, because of these small rap parts. Would love to see them trying another concept.

Their height really doesn't bother me lol, don't know why that would be a problem

 

[kookheon]

some of these things like the members’ history, their height, and the number of members can’t even be helped nor did i even realize they could even be reasons to be disappointed in them

 

[amourpinks]

Txt literally just debuted not even a three months ago, and honestly the songs are good. At least they didn’t debut with some wacky ass song and try to claim that they were experimenting and doing something different.
Give them time to grow, I’m sure they’ll try some new stuff out.

 

[Bopper]

TXT aren’t my cup of tea, but your reasons are a bit harsh. If Bighit had gone down the hip hop route with them they would’ve been almost instantly been shot down as a BTS tribute act. They’ll find their own sound eventually, but for now going the opposite way to BTS was a good move.

 

[marlax]

to me, they're a group that doesn't stand out or seem special. it's true that they're rookies but i feel like i can usually see if a group has that flare that makes them outstanding right from the get-go. i don't think they would be this popular if it wasn't for their seniors.

despite this, i think you're being unnecessarily harsh. some of your reasoning (specially about things like physical characteristics) is nonsensical. they do feel a little awkward now but they've got time to grow.

 

[Jimimis]

I’m sorry have you SEEN Beomgyu WHEW