Post a song/MV and I'll give it a brutally honest review (1 Viewer)

[maruberry]

Nothing held back.
Also plz keep it to like one or two songs per post....

DISCLAIMER!!! ALL THESE ARE MY OWN OPINION AND SAY NOTHING ABOUT THE OVERALL QUALITY OF THE PRODUCT

 

[Magician]

 

[eclipsoul]

i heavily dislike the term brutally honest... so i'll send a song that i also heavily dislike

 

[Chaeee]

 

[maruberry]

7.5/10

This is actually weirdly close to being a 10 in my books, which is shocking considering I gave it a 7.5.... BUT.... It has the exact type of a sound I ADORE (Reminds me of smth WJSN might have released and I-Yah is one of my fave songs of all time) The verses are great, but I think the chorus falls short of my expectations.

The tune is great even, but the instrumental doesn't dazzle and take me away enough. It also has a TAD bit too much autotune.

That being said despite it being a 7.5 in my books, I am DEFINITELY gonna listen to it again (It already joined my magical fairy princess playlist)

 

[maruberry]

i heavily dislike the term brutally honest... so i'll send a song that i also heavily dislike

Good Thinking
I also happen to not like the song

5/10

Unoriginal and the tempo is far too slow for the vibe they were going for + SuJu cannot rap
HOWEVER I can see what they were going for ig... and I can KINDA understand somebody liking it

 

[maruberry]

One of Loona's weakest titles
I don't like the mixing much, the vocals are overpowering the instrumental too much (Which is gold of me to say, being a jpop fan.... and loving some hilariously badly mixed songs)

That being said though... the instrumental is lacking.
The whole song feels very formulaic and unoriginal. Somebody told the producer to write a girlcrush kpop song and that is exactly what they got. (how many na na's and latatatata's can we HAVE in one damn song)

The idea/concept is good, but other than that has nothing to go for it tbh

6/10

 

[Nezumi]

 

[maruberry]

Always love me some B.I
This doesn't sound like a kpop song at all, but it's so GOOD

Absolutely adore it
I love how empty and far off it feels. It's a song that feels like... wandering around a big city alone in the nighttime.

The one criticism I would have for it, is that I wish it was a smoother transition between the different parts of the song (verse to chorus etc) I think it would REALLY benefit from like an instrumental part after the chorus or maybe a two part chorus.

9/10

 

[Soogi]

 

[Nezumi]

Always love me some B.I
This doesn't sound like a kpop song at all, but it's so GOOD

Absolutely adore it
I love how empty and far off it feels. It's a song that feels like... wandering around a big city alone in the nighttime.

The one criticism I would have for it, is that I wish it was a smoother transition between the different parts of the song (verse to chorus etc) I think it would REALLY benefit from like an instrumental part after the chorus or maybe a two part chorus.

9/10

That's exactly how I would describe the song. Glad you like it
I can see what you mean with that one criticism ^^
@Nina @Hakunama_Tata How can you not love this song, right?

 

[Misakii]

 

[maruberry]

Hate to do this to my boys but....
Weakest Title track by SVT.... period....

7.5/10

the pre-chorus and Minghao's mullet save it.
The oh-oh-oh part of the chorus is.... boring?

It has a similar sound and concept to Clap, but isn't really as catchy or well... cool or iconic.
I think that's the best way to describe this song... if Clap was more repetitive and boring

 

[maruberry]

10/10

I actually gagged when Taeyeon dropped this.
Its perfection. She really feels like a goddess who is showing me her world
Love it, love it, love it.

Taeyeon is just... always sosososo on point

 

[Soogi]

Hate to do this to my boys but....
Weakest Title track by SVT.... period....

7.5/10

the pre-chorus and Minghao's mullet save it.
The oh-oh-oh part of the chorus is.... boring?

It has a similar sound and concept to Clap, but isn't really as catchy or well... cool or iconic.
I think that's the best way to describe this song... if Clap was more repetitive and boring

thats valid! i do enjoy call*3 myself, and i really wish they had fleshed out the greasers vs socs/biker gang concept but i wouldnt say its one of my favorites either~ i actually wanted to pick very nice but this was in my recs when i opened youtube so i just went w it

 

[maruberry]

thats valid! i do enjoy call*3 myself, and i really wish they had fleshed out the greasers vs socs/biker gang concept but i wouldnt say its one of my favorites either~ i actually wanted to pick very nice but this was in my recs when i opened youtube so i just went w it

I mea Aju Nice is a 10/10 no brainer
It's just THAT song

 

[RandAlThor]

covers from Jessica / Kelly and Atou :)

you said 2 or i would have done the fire song.

 

[Boyo]

That's exactly how I would describe the song. Glad you like it
I can see what you mean with that one criticism ^^
@Nina @Hakunama_Tata How can you not love this song, right?

I don’t trust people who doesn’t like that song @Nezumi @Nina

 

[Nina]

That's exactly how I would describe the song. Glad you like it
I can see what you mean with that one criticism ^^
@Nina @Hakunama_Tata How can you not love this song, right?

I don’t trust people who doesn’t like that song @Nezumi @Nina

btw have you guys seen the cosmos mv?
If not go watch it

 

[Boyo]

btw have you guys seen the cosmos mv?
If not go watch it

Yess