Queendom Puzzle Ranking Changes: Round 3 (1 Viewer)

[Lovely_Cornchips]

In past threads, I've stated it but I will reiterate this:
This ranking is based on an algorithm I've made for the rounds the occur.
The girls individually along with the groups they are in get a certain amount of points
based on their performance each round.

*This time around I gave bonus points to girls who really stood out in Round 3.*
That way they didn't get points based solely on the group's overall score.


Now here is my Ideal Top 7:
1.Bora
2. Yeeun
3. Nana
4. Yuki or Elly
5. Suyun
6. Soeun
7. Hwiseo

Now just like last time before I watched the performances I did some math and ordered the groups
but the highest overall average score to demonstrate which groups should perform the best.

GROUP RANKINGS BEFORE PERFORMANCES:
1st: Shut Down
2nd: Only One
3rd: Nxde
4th: Don't Call Me
5th: Fighting
6th: DTNA

END OF ROUND 3 GROUP RANKING:
1st Place-Shut Down

Note: This was the most well-rounded performance. The vocals, dance, stage presence, and raps demonstrated
really showed that this group was super well-rounded in general. Sangah in particular really stood out here.
She got a couple of bonus points simply for how much she owned this performance. But FYE's high note and Hwiseo coming out with the tricks.
Just wow.

2nd Place-Fighting

Note: Again-this was such a well-rounded group. The stage presence and fun they were having the whole time.
It just translated so well and wow oh wow did Elly blow this out of the fucking water alongside Juri.
The vocals shown were top tier and the fun was just contagious. I adored this-the talent was unreal.

3rd Place-Only One

Note: Soeun really was the only one standing out here. She's a good dancer, she can move her face
and as a result, she had the presence that Kei lacked but Kei more than made up for it with her vocals.
They both were fantastic vocally.

4th Place-Don't Call Me

Note: Guys-the stage presence for this was atrocious. Yeeun and Yereom
were the only ones who really shined during this performance.
The vocals weren't bad though sometimes they
were off-time and didn't match the overall concept either.
I don't know this was just mediocre.

5th Place-Nxde

Note: They screwed up so badly with the concept of this performance.
Overall it was just so messy, the strings and props ruined the entire thing for me.
The girls sang well and danced ok. But the only ones really pushing presence-wise were Suyun & Dohwa.

6th Place-DTNA

Note: I was just kind of...confused by this performance.
it was completely centered on Bora for the most part and I just didn't get it.
This is a challenging song but Bora didn't need to have the center for the dance break.
So I just didn't fully get that and just overall none of the members stood out.
It felt like a very bland performance and that sucked.

So with all of that here is the final Tier ranking after group performances and bonus points.

Tier 1:
1. Hwiseo (136.5)
2. Elly (130.5)
3. Riina (130.5)
4. Juri (129)
5. Sangah (128.5)
6. Yuki (128)
7. FYE (126)

Tier 2:
8. Kei (125)
9. Soeun (122.5)
10. Yeeun (122)
11. Soojin (120.5)
12. Suyun (119)
13. Jiwoo (118.5)
14. Yeoreum (118)

Tier 3:
15. Miru (116)
16. JooE (115.5)
17. Dohwa (115)
18. Yeonhee (114.5)
19. Bora (114)
20. Nana (113)
21. Jihan (110)

Tier 4:
22. Wooyeon (108)
23. Zoa (102.5)
24. Chaerin (101)
25. Jiwon (98)
26. Seoyeon (87.5)

I did not expect the points the boost so many gorlies.
But dang FYE and Sangah shot up.
Their entire team is of course in Tier 1 now.

Nana & Bora aren't doing as well as I was anticipating either.
But anyway....

What were your guys' thoughts on all of these performances?
Who do you think stood out?

Also tagging @mahiya & @Wingfrost and @RandAlThor

ENJOY~!

Prior Ranking​

 

[RandAlThor]

Nice.

i am streaming these in realtime live(well as they are aired lol so not live)

I ranked the performances differently. And since the only song i have ever seen preformed by the og artist was only one i am kinda a blank canvas.

over all except for fighting more was not better it just cluttered up the stage. and were far too busy.
its not like they will be preforming like this as a group more than a few times a year(year end maybe).


Fighting was my fav. Juri hard carried teh whole idea thing.
only one was pretty and hey they didnt fall dancing on the sheet....
DTNA it was fun presented as a street fair/ carnival song or some such but as you said not really a way to stand out.
dont call me was fine the green and black day glow was odd. its odd Miru is so great on stage yet none of these setups are showing that. pd 48 miru v this is night and day.
nude was ok but cluttered kinda as you said.
shut down i was very unfond of. the girls were fine .. hard not to be its not challenging at all.

all and all i would only watch the top 4 again. but in the 2 weeks i have only watched fighting. So i was not in love with any of them.

as to the rest of ep 3 i thought the putting members into 2 teams drama was next level cruel and evil.

 

[Wingfrost]

I still have yet to watch any of these