Take your ult group... (2 Viewers)

[Skorge]

Twice remains with Nayeon, Jeongyeon, Sana, Dahyun, Tzuyu

(I really had to look up who main rapper is between Dahyun and Chaeyoung )

I'd still stan ofc, but it would not be the same with so many members I love gone

Hell yes! I'd stan this version of Twice as well. Still have 3 out of my 4 fav ladies here.

 

[velvet]

Minus Serim, Woobin, Allen and Hyeongjun

That leaves Jungmo, Wonjin, Minhee, Taeyoung and Seongmin

It'd probably depend if they're still doing the same music but yeah I'd still stan!!!

 

[Dreamer_of_Songs]

WJSN (including C-Line), it would be

Seola
Bona
Luda
Xuan Yi
Eunseo
Dayoung

The group loses 3 main vocalists (Soobin, Dawon, and Yeonjung), 3 main dancers (Cheng Xiao, Mei Qi, and Yeoreum), and their main rapper/leader (Exy)

I would still stan since Eunseo and Luda are there

 

[StrayMixx]

TXT doesn't have any official positions, so I'll just do Seventeen and The Boyz.

SVT would be: S. Coups, Jeonghan, Joshua, Jun, Wonwoo, Woozi, Mingyu, The8, & Vernon
Would I still stan?: Yes! I'd be sad for Seungkwan bc he's in my bias line, but I'd still stan.

TBZ would be: Jacob, Younghoon, Hyunjae, Ju Haknyeon, & Eric
Would I still stan?: Most likely, although I'd be really upset about the drastic drop in number of members and the elimination of the leader. lol

 

[Day]

TXT doesn't have any official positions, so I'll just do Seventeen and The Boyz.

SVT would be: S. Coups, Jeonghan, Joshua, Jun, Wonwoo, Woozi, Mingyu, The8, & Vernon
Would I still stan?: Yes! I'd be sad for Seungkwan bc he's in my bias line, but I'd still stan.

TBZ would be: Jacob, Younghoon, Hyunjae, Ju Haknyeon, & Eric
Would I still stan?: Most likely, although I'd be really upset about the drastic drop in number of members and the elimination of the leader. lol

S.Coups isn't the main rapper?

 

[StrayMixx]

S.Coups isn't the main rapper?

wait, lemme check. I used KProfiles to look it up.

 

[StrayMixx]

wait, lemme check. I used KProfiles to look it up.

@Day no, it just lists him as a rapper... no main, lead, or sub

 

[litc]

SuperM don’t have official positions I’m pretty sure. If you eliminate those who aren’t on hiatus and have a main position in their og groups that removes literally everyone so

There’d only be mr Lucas if he’s still considered part of the group so I guess you wouldn’t

but for superm itself I’d say
Main vocal: baekhyun, taemin
Lead: ten
Sub: kai and Taeyong and mark too tho they won’t always sing
Main rapper: mark, taeyong
Lead: Lucas?
Sub: ten and kai ig maybe they’re lead idk
Main dancer: taemin, kai, ten
Lead: taeyong and possibly mark
(Dance lines generally have more mains/leads than vocal and rap lines anyway, ig like shinee is an exception with their vocal line being almost full group and dance line only taekey but I feel like they could have had one or two other lead dancers)
No sub dancers ofc lol

 

[Ahsoka]

There’d only be mr Lucas if he’s still considered part of the group so I guess you wouldn’t

but for superm itself I’d say
Main vocal: baekhyun, taemin
Lead: ten
Sub: kai and Taeyong and mark too tho they won’t always sing
Main rapper: mark, taeyong
Lead: Lucas?
Sub: ten and kai ig maybe they’re lead idk
Main dancer: taemin, kai, ten
Lead: taeyong and possibly mark
(Dance lines generally have more mains/leads than vocal and rap lines anyway, ig like shinee is an exception with their vocal line being almost full group and dance line only taekey but I feel like they could have had one or two other lead dancers)
No sub dancers ofc lol

Yeah that’s basically how I’d distribute it too, either way it ends up being no one since I’m not including Lucas. And I think technically given everything Shinee doesn’t actually have many vocalists since Taemin, Key, and Minho have been considered sub vocals since the start, though they are undoubtedly actually more talented than that, especially as they’ve improved.

 

[litc]

Yeah that’s basically how I’d distribute it too, either way it ends up being no one since I’m not including Lucas. And I think technically given everything Shinee doesn’t actually have many vocalists since Taemin, Key, and Minho have been considered sub vocals since the start, though they are undoubtedly actually more talented than that, especially as they’ve improved.

I thought taemin got upgraded to lead
So I thought it was 3/5

another shawol told me key started as a lead vocal at debut so then I thought if he still is one and taemin became one it would be 4/5 everyone but minho

 

[tricky]

nine.i has no main/lead positions.... they're safe

 

[Ahsoka]

I thought taemin got upgraded to lead
So I thought it was 3/5

another shawol told me key started as a lead vocal at debut so then I thought if he still is one and taemin became one it would be 4/5 everyone but minho

Idk, I just go by what kprofiles says tbh since I don’t actually closely follow who’s main, lead, sub, visual, ect. They say that everyone except Onew and Jonghyun are subs, though I have noticed they changed Onew to main not lead so idk. Key is also listed as a lead rapper, maybe they meant that? Not sure on that either.

 

[litc]

Idk, I just go by what kprofiles says tbh since I don’t actually closely follow who’s main, lead, sub, visual, ect. They say that everyone except Onew and Jonghyun are subs, though I have noticed they changed Onew to main not lead so idk. Key is also listed as a lead rapper, maybe they meant that? Not sure on that either.

Oh I thought key was lead for all I did know he was lead rapper

i don’t think kprofiles is always accurate like for weeekly zoa is put as main rapper tho they didn’t say it anywhere and in variety shows Monday is always captioned as the main rapper

 

[tricky]

nine.i has no main/lead positions.... they're safe

for ptg it would be hongseok, shinwon, yeoone, yanan and yuto lmao

hui, jinho, kino and wooseok are taken out (its weird how its just the first two and the last two tgt)

 

[Ahsoka]

Oh I thought key was lead for all I did know he was lead rapper

i don’t think kprofiles is always accurate like for weeekly zoa is put as main rapper tho they didn’t say it anywhere and in variety shows Monday is always captioned as the main rapper

I don’t think it’s always accurate either, but I think the majority of sources are going to be just as inaccurate between translation errors, changes over time, and so on and I know where to find kprofiles so I just go with that and hope it is accurate then. I don’t often need to use it anyways.

 

[Day]

Idk, I just go by what kprofiles says tbh since I don’t actually closely follow who’s main, lead, sub, visual, ect. They say that everyone except Onew and Jonghyun are subs, though I have noticed they changed Onew to main not lead so idk. Key is also listed as a lead rapper, maybe they meant that? Not sure on that either.

Oh I thought key was lead for all I did know he was lead rapper

i don’t think kprofiles is always accurate like for weeekly zoa is put as main rapper tho they didn’t say it anywhere and in variety shows Monday is always captioned as the main rapper

I'm glad I unwatched this thread 10 replies ago bc what are you two talking about

 

[Ahsoka]

I'm glad I unwatched this thread 10 replies ago bc what are you two talking about

Hey kprofiles is related given that it provides information about who’s what position in the group

 

[Day]

Hey kprofiles is related given that it provides information about who’s what position in the group

I know but every time I glance at my thread in the trending the reply count keeps increasing but it's just you two

 

[litc]

I'm glad I unwatched this thread 10 replies ago bc what are you two talking about

@Vikki and I got on an unrelated tangent about how many lead vocals are in shinee and who they are and if kprofiles information on that very specific topic is accurate

 

[ichigohon]

Let's see.... who's left in T-Ara

Qri.



Well considering we've been married since 2013 I think still stan