Sensitive This is for Orbits. (1 Viewer)

[Strawberry_Poppy]

Loona is a 12 member girl group and someone is going to get the least lines. You would be mad if Heejin got the least lines. And vivi is just some how the member who gets the least lines along sidr Yeonjin. Its not exactly mistreatment--- Just like BLACKPINK. Jisoo is the member who seems to get the least lines.
We all have our opinions so feel free to put yours here.

 

[ADORA]

I feel like Heejin needs more lines because she has a beautiful voice

 

[nyaajooe]

i agree

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

This is the case with every group and the members have positions for a reason. The main dancer who is a sub-vocal shouldn't be getting the most lines. Just like a Main Vocal shouldn't get all the rap parts. It's fairer than people want to admit. But because they are biased they get their pants in a twist.

There are VERY few times where I think fans are actually justified with their annoyance with line distributions.


Like this one for example.

 

[NogaNono]

I mean, I agree and disagree. I think it's inevitable that some members get more lines than others because they all have different talents and are suitable for different parts and songs. But giving a main vocalist like Haseul only one second in Hi High when she literally sang the whole demo? That seems a little strange. As for Vivi and Yeojin's situation, they're definitely not the best vocalists in the group, so I wouldn't expect them to get the most, but I do think they get too little of an amount. IZONE is also a group with twelve members, and even though some members get more lines than others, I'd say for the most part each member gets at least one line to shine in each song, so it's not like it can't be done. I definitely wouldn't say it's mistreatment, especially since they all have solo songs, and it's not something I'm that mad about, but I do think it can be improved. Just my thoughts though, and I respect your opinion.

 

[yeji]

I honestly never felt like one member was over pushed with Loona tbh

 

[Mayday]

I think more people are upset about unfair line distribution rather than unequal line distribution.

 

[Chaeee]

I agree. It is inevitable that some members are going to get the least amount of lines. That’s not mistreatment.

But fans need to look at the bigger picture, and understand why their faves don’t get a lot of line. Companies have their reasons as to why they give members little lines; they’re not always anti-X idol or have favourites. The idol in question might be a weak vocalist, and may not be able to sing parts they’re originally given well enough, like Onda in the Adios demo.
Or they could be a decent vocalist but their vocal colour might not blend well with the song.
The solution companies (like BBC) resolve to with both these scenarios is to make do with shorter simpler lines for the member/s.

But I think it does get to a certain point where the company is just being “unfair” with the distribution of songs with no justified reason E.g, NO LIE, Hi High, etc. and when the member is constantly shunned out of the spotlight then fans can actually complain with reason

 

[eclipsoul]

this is a year old thread but i see orbits so i reply lol. honestly i disagree, you can't compare jisoo to vivi or gowon because even last in the ranks jisoo still gets 15-20 seconds per song, vivi and gowon get this much in a whole album. it's not even about who's the first or last but more about the amount - i know bbc has improved a bit in certain songs like star where they get actual lines or even why not but there is no excuse for main vocalist haseul to sing 2 seconds in their debut song. i'm not blaming that on heejin by any means ofc even my ultimate bias kim lip gets a lot of lines but loona aren't mamamoo where all their songs are extremely challenging vocally - some lines sung by members in the top 3 in the distribution can be easily given to those who have less than 5 seconds each song. for example this is the line distribution to unnatural by wjsn, a group which is nearly as big as loona member-wise. it's possible