News Upcoming “Dehumanizing” Survival Show For Girl Groups Hit With Major Backlash (3 Viewers)

[anyu]

https://www.koreaboo.com/news/new-dehumanizing-survival-show-girl-groups-hit-major-backlash/

@Maeum @willing (ichillin's fandom) @dreamnote (??) @Plory @Sumit @WOW
I had no clue my girls were going on another show. They deserve another domestic comeback before they go to another survival show. It looks like this one won't be as smooth sailing as Chuang Asia was, though... :(

 

[eclipsoul]

i need AI to go the fuck away from creative industries asap. using it to judge real human beings who spent a good part of their lives training to be performers is absolutely vile and so is claiming they "lost their shine" like it's better to say that whoever came up with this shit lost their mind if they ever had one to begin with. i'm so sorry to all the girls taking part in this...

 

[centen]

As it should be. I'm not saying AI has no uses, but for determining the artistic value of something, it is absolute garbage at that task.

Also, "lost their shine"??? WTF, WOOAH had their best year yet last year, their sales are steady, Blush and Pom Pom Pom were their highest charting songs to date. Lightsum's Pose was well received. Purple Kiss's sales are also steady, and BBB and On My Bike charted decently and they've been on a tour that's doing well from what I can tell. I don't know that much about the other artists, but it seems like their issues have more to do with their companies not giving them consistent releases than them actually doing poorly when they do release music (which is also Lightsum's issue, Cube is so hit or miss).

I kind of hate this attitude that some people have that either you are slaying the charts, doing IU level of charts and sales, or you're flopping. There's a LOT of room in the middle there, especially with how international groups are these days.

 

[Selfmate]

interesting

 

[RandAlThor]

As it should be. I'm not saying AI has no uses, but for determining the artistic value of something, it is absolute garbage at that task.

Also, "lost their shine"??? WTF, WOOAH had their best year yet last year, their sales are steady, Blush and Pom Pom Pom were their highest charting songs to date. Lightsum's Pose was well received. Purple Kiss's sales are also steady, and BBB and On My Bike charted decently and they've been on a tour that's doing well from what I can tell. I don't know that much about the other artists, but it seems like their issues have more to do with their companies not giving them consistent releases than them actually doing poorly when they do release music (which is also Lightsum's issue, Cube is so hit or miss).

I kind of hate this attitude that some people have that either you are slaying the charts, doing IU level of charts and sales, or you're flopping. There's a LOT of room in the middle there, especially with how international groups are these days.

I think ppl(by ppl i mean semi-fans and agencies) want at least StayC numbers. so solid B+ area. This was the death of Weeekly
With such a top heavy industry They have to find a niche.
Dreamnote has been surviving in sea which is crazy, and as you say their numbers are not even a blip in Korea.
Its hard for us to know the revenue model for c and d tier groups.

 

[athenaaa]

For groups who lost thier shine is a comment that bothers me. Also, why is it judged by an AI producer?!

 

[anyu]

im biased bc im such a huge csr fan but saying they lost their shine is moronic they're literally shining bright... LITERALLY.

all jokes aside, they are seriously an amazing group and claiming them to have lost their shine is just plain wrong. they get more popular with every comeback and they clearly are all working hard and care a lot about their work. these shitty producers need to get a soul already (no pun intended w the ai producer)
a2z entertainment fuck u !!! csr fighting!!

 

[StirFriedPanda]

I kept reading stuff about this and wanted to post about it but couldn't think of a way that wouldn't get me more warnings. Having real talented being judged by any kind of AI is absolute bull shit.

 

[magali]

i actually considered unstanning lightsum because of this lol fuck cube

 

[Moguri]

after thinking about this for a while I'm not actually sure, at first I felt the same as most other users here... but then I remembered how biased and unfair human judges often are

 

[StirFriedPanda]

after thinking about this for a while I'm not actually sure, at first I felt the same as most other users here... but then I remembered how biased and unfair human judges often are

True, but is a nameless, blameless, emotionless computer better?

 

[Moguri]

True, but is a nameless, blameless, emotionless computer better?

I don't know, but if it was not manipulated by the producers and tried to objectivly rate the performances, it could be possible. I don't think AI is at that level yet, so probably not. But we will see how it goes by watching this show

 

[StirFriedPanda]

I don't know, but if it was not manipulated by the producers and tried to objectivly rate the performances, it could be possible. I don't think AI is at that level yet, so probably not. But we will see how it goes by watching this show

I tried watching My Teenage Girl and couldn't get into it. I think its better to not even give the AI a chance. Only humans should judge humans. As flawed as we are we are at least capable of judging with heart and emotion. You can't boil talent down to an algorithm.

 

[Moguri]

I tried watching My Teenage Girl and couldn't get into it. I think its better to not even give the AI a chance. Only humans should judge humans. As flawed as we are we are at least capable of judging with heart and emotion. You can't boil talent down to an algorithm.

I don't know what that is, but its okay, if everyone thinks like you, no one will watch it and those shows will go away, but I think people will be too curious

 

[StirFriedPanda]

I don't know what that is, but its okay, if everyone thinks like you, no one will watch it and those shows will go away, but I think people will be too curious

Algorithm is simply a math problem that consistently creates a certain result. I guess you won't do my Calculus home work.

 

[Moguri]

Algorithm is simply a math problem that consistently creates a certain result. I guess you won't do my Calculus home work.

I meant my teenage girl

 

[StirFriedPanda]

I meant my teenage girl

Sorry, it was the show that created Classy.

 

[Moguri]

Sorry, it was the show that created Classy.

and that was run by AI..? Isn't that quite some time ago?

 

[StirFriedPanda]

and that was run by AI..? Isn't that quite some time ago?

No it wasn't run by AI. It was the only group creation show I tried to watch. Until VCHA.

 

[Moguri]

No it wasn't run by AI. It was the only group creation show I tried to watch. Until VCHA.

oh... I don't watch them either Apart from VCHA