What would the Kep1er lineup look like if it was 3-3-3? (1 Viewer)

[athenaaa]

Many people were led to think the final lineup of Girls Planet 999 early on would have three Korean, three Japanese, and three Chinese members. We learned through the voting system and the interim results that this would not be the case. So I got thinking, what if this model was actually real?

Current lineup:
Kim Chaehyun (1)
Huening Bahiyyih (2)
Choi Yujin (3)
Kim Dayeon (4)
Seo Youngeun (5)
Kang Yeseo (6)
Ezaki Hikaru (7)
Sakamoto Mashiro (8)
Shen Xiaoting (9)

Hypothetical model:
K01 Kim Chaehyun
K02 Huening Bahiyyih
K03 Choi Yujin
J01Ezaki Hikaru
J02 Sakamoto Mashiro
J03 Kawaguchi Yurina
C01 Shen Xiaoting
C02 Fu Yaning
C03 Su Riqui

 

[RandAlThor]

Many people were led to think the final lineup of Girls Planet 999 early on would have three Korean, three Japanese, and three Chinese members. We learned through the voting system and the interim results that this would not be the case. So I got thinking, what if this model was actually real?

Current lineup:
Kim Chaehyun (1)
Huening Bahiyyih (2)
Choi Yujin (3)
Kim Dayeon (4)
Seo Youngeun (5)
Kang Yeseo (6)
Ezaki Hikaru (7)
Sakamoto Mashiro (8)
Shen Xiaoting (9)

Hypothetical model:
K01 Kim Chaehyun
K02 Huening Bahiyyih
K03 Choi Yujin
J01Ezaki Hikaru
J02 Sakamoto Mashiro
J03 Kawaguchi Yurina
C01 Shen Xiaoting
C02 Fu Yaning
C03 Su Riqui

Aside from the fact that forcing ppl to pick girls they do not want purely based on group is bad.

Sadly this group would crash and burn in Korea purely because of the 2 C group girls.
geopolitically they would be getting hate non stop.
Network TV stations might not even let em work.

The problem even if ya went total raw vote its 4k 3c 2j.
But given the pandemic and the CF that is China and music now. they are going to have to work in Korea/virtually for most of the run.

over all people just did not care enough to vote.
from my other thread these are the raw vote numbers out there atm.

Total
C group
J group
K group +HB(who was number 1 raw vote getter)

about 620 k votes per day
Voters was far far less if you consider multiple accounts and the sim card switching that was going on.
A small number of actual people controlled this.

Yurina in particular got very few votes like 13th over all.

 

[athenaaa]

Aside from the fact that forcing ppl to pick girls they do not want purely based on group is bad.

Sadly this group would crash and burn in Korea purely because of the 2 C group girls.
geopolitically they would be getting hate non stop.
Network TV stations might not even let em work.

The problem even if ya went total raw vote its 4k 3c 2j.
But given the pandemic and the CF that is China and music now. they are going to have to work in Korea/virtually for most of the run.

over all people just did not care enough to vote.
from my other thread these are the raw vote numbers out there atm.

Total
C group
J group
K group +HB(who was number 1 raw vote getter)

about 620 k votes per day
Voters was far far less if you consider multiple accounts and the sim card switching that was going on.
A small number of actual people controlled this.

Yurina in particular got very few votes like 13th over all.

It was more of a random thought that I had instead of going into the math. But I do what you're saying about the controversy - however the group will have controversy no matter what.

 

[RandAlThor]

It was more of a random thought that I had instead of going into the math. But I do what you're saying about the controversy - however the group will have controversy no matter what.

There is controversy and controversy.
there is a reason Victoria , Lay and others who sided with China have not been back. heck Victoria did not even go to Japan for the final f(x) performance.

 

[athenaaa]

There is controversy and controversy.
there is a reason Victoria , Lay and others who sided with China have not been back. heck Victoria did not even go to Japan for the final f(x) performance.

Varying levels of controversy of course. Nobody was gonna be 100% happy with this lineup - it was more hypothetical than anything.
As for Victoria - I don't know the story there as I never followed f(x).