Who benefited from not debuting from a survival show? (1 Viewer)

[athenaaa]

Adela from Dream Academy is thriving as a soloist. Honestly if she had been in Katseye, she would’ve been held back creatively. Jeemin from R U Next is thriving in Izna, I don’t think she would have thrived as much in ILLIT.​

 

[LoveYooShaSha]

Natty from Sixteen, now in Kiss of Life.

 

[alo]

since natty has been mentioned i'll go ahead and say lee haein - the real #1 winner of idol school who was one of the many people rigged out... but now she's the creative director of kiof, a job she loves and puts a lot of effort into. and she's also a judge on another survival show, jtbc's project 7

 

[Magician]

Well, Gunwook was eliminated in the first survival show he participated and I think it's a blessing that he debuted in ZB1

 

[Nina]

Soyeon
I can't imagine her following a company's format like the produce groups. I feel like getting eliminated made her even more determined to carve her own path and we all know Gidle is Soyeon's, not Cube's

 

[RandAlThor]

Soyeon
I can't imagine her following a company's format like the produce groups. I feel like getting eliminated made her even more determined to carve her own path and we all know Gidle is Soyeon's, not Cube's

who i would have gone to first.

 

[RandAlThor]

Yunjin from ssera is a wash.

pretty hard to beat being in iz one.

Miu is prob better off in Me:i than Kep1er. we will have to see.

 

[Nina]

who i would have gone to first.

I hope the girls get what they want when contracts are up especially if they don't decide to resign.
But with Cube's history I already know theyre gonna put more effort into giving them hell than ever they ever did in helping with a comeback.
They never let the Beast name go either.

 

[RandAlThor]

I hope the girls get what they want when contracts are up especially if they don't decide to resign.
But with Cube's history I already know theyre gonna put more effort into giving them hell than ever they ever did in helping with a comeback.
They never let the Beast name go either.

she already said they all resigned during MMA though?

 

[Nina]

she already said they all resigned during MMA though?

oh really???

I hope they all are getting what they want.
A part of me was hoping theyd leave and bring Soojin back but I know that would never happen even if they left.I still hold out for the same with MX and iKON.

 

[RandAlThor]

oh really???

I hope they all are getting what they want.
A part of me was hoping theyd leave and bring Soojin back but I know that would never happen even if they left.I still hold out for the same with MX and iKON.

i posted a short clip i am sure there is a subbed version of her speech somewhere.

 

[Ahsoka]

Maybe AleXa? It’s hard to say if she would be more better off in IZONE but her current stuff is definitely extremely different than IZONE

 

[Swan42]

If Daniel Jikal had debuted in TNX (P Nation's Loud group), he wouldn't be on Lin-Manuel Miranda's new concept album.

 

[Chiara]

Kamden in Ampers&One, even if they're a nugu group afaik lol

 

[velvet]

Minkyun (MK) was in the show that formed Monsta X but I can't see him in anything else but ONF.

Edit: A bit off topic but Cravity is also the biggest silver lining from X1's disbandment

 

[badcrookshanks]

i feel like hanbin is better appreciated in tempest than he would be in enhypen

 

[centen]

ILLIT would have been a great opportunity of course, but I think Chanelle and Yewon really shine in Fifty Fifty.

And I also think Natty found the perfect spot with Kiss of Life. It sucks for her that she went through multiple survival shows, but she was way too young for Twice, and tbh, may come out ahead in KIOF as compared to the survival show that made fromis_9, based on all of those members choosing to not re-sign.

 

[athenaaa]

ILLIT would have been a great opportunity of course, but I think Chanelle and Yewon really shine in Fifty Fifty.

And I also think Natty found the perfect spot with Kiss of Life. It sucks for her that she went through multiple survival shows, but she was way too young for Twice, and tbh, may come out ahead in KIOF as compared to the survival show that made fromis_9, based on all of those members choosing to not re-sign.

I completely agree! Chanelle and Yewon both really shine in Fifty Fifty and they have great chemistry with the members