Appreciation What 4th gen GG would release a song like this? (1 Viewer)

[Day]

Everglow came to mind tbh.

Everglow 2023 comeback announcement when I need them to come back and save kpop

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Same for me

Concept wise everglow or loona I could see doing it

But the song is a very vocal based song and the vocally oriented 4th gen ggs either I don't see doing this type of music, or have minors

I mean like OP said they would want this concept to be pursued when the idols are adults and I take that stance too.
If I were to look at more vocal groups in the 4th gen who could MAYBE pull this off I'd picture maybe Le Sserafim and that is mainly to do with the confidence they already have at this age. I can only picture it would grow with maturity (aka when they become adults) and could then pull this off.

 

[Dreamer_of_Songs]

WAIT
WHAT??

Blackswan is a rebranded version of Rania (and also BP Rania).

 

[Day]

Blackswan is a rebranded version of Rania (and also BP Rania).

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

WAIT
WHAT??

I am SO SO sorry that THIS is how you found out they ruined this group.

 

[litc]

I mean like OP said they would want this concept to be pursued when the idols are adults and I take that stance too.
If I were to look at more vocal groups in the 4th gen who could MAYBE pull this off I'd picture maybe Le Sserafim and that is mainly to do with the confidence they already have at this age. I can only picture it would grow with maturity (aka when they become adults) and could then pull this off.

For Le Sserafim only Eunchae is a minor now that Garam had to leave

so it's not like a mainly minors group

I'm interested in how Weeekly or Nmixx (if they FINALLY release a song without rapping PLZ) as ADULTS would do vocally

 

[Day]

For Le Sserafim only Eunchae is a minor now that Garam had to leave

so it's not like a mainly minors group

I'm interested in how Weeekly or Nmixx (if they FINALLY release a song without rapping PLZ) as ADULTS would do vocally

I just know Monday would slay this vocally

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

For Le Sserafim only Eunchae is a minor now that Garam had to leave

so it's not like a mainly minors group

I'm interested in how Weeekly or Nmixx (if they FINALLY release a song without rapping PLZ) as ADULTS would do vocally

I can't picture NMIXX doing sexy-maybe it's because some of the lines in their songs now I can't take seriously and as a result, I can't picture them doing a sexier concept down the line.

As much as I love Weeekly seeing them do Ven Para (even though I liked that song) made me realize they do better with more fun & upbeat retro songs. I can't picture them doing sexy either.

 

[litc]

I just know Monday would slay this vocally

Vocally I can definitely hear Weeekly doing this

Concept wise, no

M/V wise with groin shots NO

And Zoa is a BABY

They better not do this rn

If Monday and Soeun cover this on some show where they do vocal covers I wouldn't mind

 

[RandAlThor]

i only know one dr feelgood....

guess i should used an 'official' version..


but as to the question..
if ya count idle. i guess its in the ball park.

 

[Dreamer_of_Songs]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

I am sorry for saying this. I had no idea you didn’t know about Rania-Blackswan

Spoiler

Also, why does this feel like a Santa Claus isn’t real discussion

 

[Day]

I can't picture NMIXX doing sexy-maybe it's because some of the lines in their songs now I can't take seriously and as a result, I can't picture them doing a sexier concept down the line.

As much as I love Weeekly seeing them do Ven Para (even though I liked that song) made me realize they do better with more fun & upbeat retro songs. I can't picture them doing sexy either.

Vocally I can definitely hear Weeekly doing this

Concept wise, no

M/V wise with groin shots NO

And Zoa is a BABY

They better not do this rn

If Monday and Soeun cover this on some show where they do vocal covers I wouldn't mind

You two are very wise I think to find the answer we could also look at 4th gen idols who stan 2nd gen queens. I don't think 4th gen has covered Hyo's Dally but the answer would probably be found there or possibly some of Sunmi's recent works?

 

[Day]

I am sorry for saying this. I had no idea you didn’t know about Rania-Blackswan

Spoiler

Also, why does this feel like a Santa Claus isn’t real discussion

It's so funny but it's not

 

[litc]

I can't picture NMIXX doing sexy-maybe it's because some of the lines in their songs now I can't take seriously and as a result, I can't picture them doing a sexier concept down the line.

As much as I love Weeekly seeing them do Ven Para (even though I liked that song) made me realize they do better with more fun & upbeat retro songs. I can't picture them doing sexy either.

Yeah, that's what I was saying, they are vocal groups but I don't see them doing this concept/sound and they have minors

Yeah Ven Para was smth new but not even sexy

I definitely do think they could pull dark concepts wise (Weeekly) even if their older music is my preference as well bc of the VERSATILITY

(ninja challenge part)

 

[litc]

You two are very wise I think to find the answer we could also look at 4th gen idols who stan 2nd gen queens. I don't think 4th gen has covered Hyo's Dally but the answer would probably be found there or possibly some of Sunmi's recent works?

Honestly there's a lot of 4th gen ggs that aren't minors considering 2018 and 2019 debuts are being considered 4th gen ig

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Honestly there's a lot of 4th gen ggs that aren't minors considering 2018 and 2019 debuts are being considered 4th gen ig

Based on research any group that debuted in 2017 or earlier is 3rd gen and then it goes from there. So yeah 2018 to present is 4th generation.


MAYBE we should look at boy groups. I think ONEUS should cover this song. I think they'd do well.

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

I am sorry for saying this. I had no idea you didn’t know about Rania-Blackswan

Spoiler

Also, why does this feel like a Santa Claus isn’t real discussion

I'M THE ONE WHO RUINED CHRISTMAS

 

[Dreamer_of_Songs]

I'M THE ONE WHO RUINED CHRISTMAS

We both did technically

 

[litc]

Based on research any group that debuted in 2017 or earlier is 3rd gen and then it goes from there. So yeah 2018 to present is 4th generation.


MAYBE we should look at boy groups. I think ONEUS should cover this song. I think they'd do well.

Who other than loona and everglow and itzy are ggs who debuted before 2020, are not disbanded, and weren't mentioned

I'm no gg expert

 

[Lovely_Cornchips]

Who other than loona and everglow and itzy are ggs who debuted before 2020, are not disbanded, and weren't mentioned

I'm no gg expert

You disappoint me anytime I remember you're not a GG stan.