Skill or Attitude (1 Viewer)

[VillageIdiot]

Be honest: which one matters the most to you?
Would you tolerate a talentless (ie the least capable in all things: singing, dancing, rapping, performance) idol with good attitude on varieties/interviews?
Or an idol extremely skilled in what ever field you value the most but is disinterested 100% of the time if they aren't on stage?

Discuss
There's no judgement here

 

[Jimimis]

Talent is useless if you’re BORING this is supposed to be ENTERTAINMENT

 

[Hajima]

attitude can't stand people with issues.....

 

[RandAlThor]

neiither

 

[baekk]

Skill is cool but I think attitude matters the most to me in order for me to like them, they would be boring if they had no charisma.

 

[blueberries]

It kinda depends what I'm looking for? Lot of artist and even idols and some groups I don't really watch in interviews and variety shows, I just listen to their music. And of course the talent (and artistry) is the most important thing then. In other hand I have some idols I like and even groups like 2PM for example, who I'm not that interested music wise (not that I don't like many songs they have but in general), but I think they are the funniest group in varieties.

In general though, music comes first to me.

 

[Skinnny]

The former.

 

[bulletproof]

Ofc skills are very important for an idol, but arogance or unpoliteness are turn offs so for me attittude is more important

 

[mirella]

I'd rather have a mix of both in the group. Skilled and entertaining/ positive attitude.

The group itself has a good vibe and are fun on variety, but their recorded music is great as well (good vocals, rap, etc.). I listen to their music after all.

I think some groups are like this already. It's the best possibility imo.

 

[Emanresu]

Attitude/Personality.


I Stan idols based exclusively on personality and looks and that I like them as a person.

For groups I have to like their music and enjoy their performance. But I don't really care as much that they have the best raw talent.

 

[kuro]

Talent is useless if you’re BORING this is supposed to be ENTERTAINMENT

first good thing out of your mouth

 

[Kelly]

Talent that is not accompanied by a good attitude doesn't mean much to me. In some cases, I would still listen to the music of an idol who is very talented but seems disinterested off stage, but I wouldn't pay much attention to them beyond that tbh.

 

[Evergreen]

Talent. Varieties shows are fun to watch but I am here for the music but there are limits to what I can accepte from an idol. Seungri and co are cancelled.

 

[maruberry]

The 1st thing I want is talent, that is what makes me want to get to know them. But attitude is what makes me love them.

But I don't care for the variety attitude, as long as they are sweet and nice!