Rap or Vocal? (1 Viewer)

[VillageIdiot]

Which one matters more in a group you Stan?

Spoiler

In a majority of the groups I Stan, (SNSD, Gfriend sorry DJ Sowon, Cherry Bullet, Girl's Day etc) dont have a rapline or have decent rappers at best. Not only that but I usually prefer the rappers to sing
I'm not that into go Khiphop tbh

 

[Jimimis]

Faces

 

[Somnia]

Tbh I do not care about rap in the groups I like. There don't need to be any in a song for me personally.

 

[NogaNono]

Vocal in some groups but rap in others, I guess. In SNSD it's definitely vocal. In CLC, I'd say vocal and rap are both critical elements to their songs.

 

[leesooman]

some songs are better off without raps while vocals make up the song itself.

 

[Abeamus]

Well all the groups I stan and even the soloists have good vocals (Solji, Yuju, Wheein, Seunghee, Chuu, Ailee & NC.A) however only 3 groups have good rap (LE, Moonbyul & Mimi) with the other 2 groups having average to no rap.

 

[lostinwvnderland]

It depend on the group I am listening to. For gg, I care more about the vocal and usually don't care much for the rap part. For bg, it depend on the group and I also male rapper with deep voice.

 

[Ahsoka]

Vocals are significantly more important imo, I don't tend to like rapping except in rare cases

 

[lexus]

I like both, but I prefer vocals.

 

[mirella]

Vocals are more important.
(But ideally, both.)

Vocals generally take up more of the track and for Kpop I prefer melodic songs more. It's hard to tolerate bad vocals.

Ironically a lot of the groups I stan are good or better at rap, like B.A.P, Block B, Monsta X, iKON...

I really like K-hiphop though (for non-idol artists).

 

[Wingfrost]

Vocals, if a group doesn’t have that strong of rappers then I’m fine with that but if I don’t like their vocals I probably wouldn’t really like their music.

 

[Midnight]

Vocals for all the artists I listen to.

 

[Evergreen]

I care more about vocals in the groups that I stan except for Winner and BTS.

 

[InTooManyFandoms]

I enjoy vocals more because some rappers make the song sound un flowy. lol. But I also really love some rappers, and they MAKE the song, so idk.

 

[Darkseid]

Vocals are more important.
(But ideally, both.)

Vocals generally take up more of the track and for Kpop I prefer melodic songs more. It's hard to tolerate bad vocals.

Ironically a lot of the groups I stan are good or better at rap, like B.A.P, Block B, Monsta X, iKON...

I really like K-hiphop though (for non-idol artists).

Lol this is the most surprising reply in this thread

 

[yeji]

I love KHH but when it comes down to idol groups I rather have them not rap than just anyone doing a rap part just because the company feels like it's needed.
Vocals are what makes or breaks the song. It's what needs alot of attention.

 

[baekk]

Vocals

 

[mirella]

Lol this is the most surprising reply in this thread

@goyo said the same thing!

 

[Darkseid]

@goyo said the same thing!

Lol it's TRUE though