Would you want a co-ed Produce series? (1 Viewer)

[Yoohyeon]

Or any idol producer series with co-ed in?
So, say like if they had 50 female idols and 50 male idols and the final group consists of 6 female idols and 6 male idols, would anyone want something like that? And if so, do you think it would be popular?

 

[yeji]

YES I WANT THAT

but honestly doubt it will happen. co-ed doesn’t do that well anymore

 

[Yoohyeon]

YES I WANT THAT

but honestly doubt it will happen. co-ed doesn’t do that well anymore

True, but I think that if they were made from a reality series like produce, I think it could be popular as the public would choose their favourites (if there were no rigging lol)

 

[maruberry]

I live for coed group so yes please!

 

[Myco]

YES I WANT THAT

but honestly doubt it will happen. co-ed doesn’t do that well anymore

they'd especially get a ton of hate and dating rumors besides the fact they don't do too well, altho a coed group from produce might just do as well as some more popular groups but not as much as the ones before.

There's also the fact about how well the chemistry can be, like for example lets just take KARD, it will be pretty much impossible to create the atmosphere and chemistry the four of them have with a whole 11-12 members, i doubt it will be as harmonic as it is with like with KARD and that will show in their music and MVs.

Coed School always had the differentiating with male and female in their MVs and Songs from what I've seen and heard and it would most likely be like that for a produce group as well

 

[Jichuus]

Not sure. It already gets ugly competition wise when it’s only one gender. Would it be 1/2 boys and girls (12 members instead of 11)? Or see who makes it at the end?

 

[Yoohyeon]

Not sure. It already gets ugly competition wise when it’s only one gender. Would it be 1/2 boys and girls (12 members instead of 11)? Or see who makes it at the end?

It would be 12 members, half male and half female.
However, it probably wouldn't work.

 

[JakeyWantsCakey]

YES I WANT THAT

but honestly doubt it will happen. co-ed doesn’t do that well anymore

Did they ever really do well in Korea though?

I know in the UK we had groups like Steps & S Club 7 but I can't really think of any SUCCESSFUL co-ed groups in kpop, the most successful one that I know of is KARD...

 

[yeji]

Did they ever really do well in Korea though?

I know in the UK we had groups like Steps & S Club 7 but I can't really think of any SUCCESSFUL co-ed groups in kpop, the most successful one that I know of is KARD...

in the past there were groups like Roo‘ra which are pretty iconic and popular.

 

[Evergreen]

they'd especially get a ton of hate and dating rumors besides the fact they don't do too well, altho a coed group from produce might just do as well as some more popular groups but not as much as the ones before.

There's also the fact about how well the chemistry can be, like for example lets just take KARD, it will be pretty much impossible to create the atmosphere and chemistry the four of them have with a whole 11-12 members, i doubt it will be as harmonic as it is with like with KARD and that will show in their music and MVs.

Coed School always had the differentiating with male and female in their MVs and Songs from what I've seen and heard and it would most likely be like that for a produce group as well

I think that too. It would probably work but with a smaller group.

 

[Yoohyeon]

I think that too. It would probably work but with a smaller group.

Then you'd have to make the series smaller with a smaller amount of participants, right?

 

[Evergreen]

Then you'd have to make the series smaller with a smaller amount of participants, right?

80 trainees maybe to respect the Produce series habit to have a lot of contestants ( though I think it’s a bit too much).

 

[RandAlThor]

Never.
And the boys would dominate the voting so every girl would be shaded to the moon and back.

Kpop is meant to be male or female aside from outliers like say akmu who are siblings.
KARD has like no presence in Korea.

 

[Yoohyeon]

Never.
And the boys would dominate the voting so every girl would be shaded to the moon and back.

Kpop is meant to be male or female aside from outliers like say akmu who are siblings.
KARD has like no presence in Korea.

That is true actually! I also think that the girls would have way lower votes than the boys as Korea seems to love BG's much better than GG's even if the GG concepts/music is better than the BG concepts/music.
It's only been kinda recently where female idols have been a bit more popular as they were before because they are more diverse now, but it'll still be unfair.

 

[Swan42]

I have nothing against co-ed groups, but I don't want any more groups from survival shows.