The issue that fans, players, retired players and others had about the proposed ESL, was that it was going to be an exclusive league for these so called elite clubs.
The English and European leagues has always had a promotion/relegation format, and entry to competitions such as the Champions League and the Europa League were always based on performance and not because you deemed yourself to be 'the best'...
More than 10 years ago, the team I support had the chance of playing AC Milan at home in one of these competitions. My team aren't a very big club, but they won the Fa Cup and were rewarded with getting to play against a team as big as AC Milan.
However, if this ESL existed at that time, my team wouldn't of had the opportunity of playing against AC Milan.
And this is what outraged everyone. Football fans, regardless of the size of their club, dreams of playing against the big clubs in these competitions. And this ESL was spitting all over those dreams. Dreams that made football into the sport that it is today.
I get that if your say a Sheffield united fan. but if you are a man city fan instead to getting drawn to pools with 3 other pretty lame teams.
you get to see em play barca, real inter bryern heads up and if they make the play offs it will be crazy.
although with as much money and stuff as they had the roll out was unbelievably awful.
if they were going to do it drop the 15 names and the 5 year adds all together
ofc i would not want to see it become what American sports are now (basically just an excuse for fantasy games)
but it seemed a solid idea for a product they want to market world wide.
i guess they are upset about process, in practice how often do the 'super teams ' especially the European monsters not qualify?
If early reports were right teams like the Leicester City from a few years back and now would still be good.
i guess the prem league is more volatile than the others. and there is a long history of assorted cups some of which would get squeezed out but the extra games the ESL were planning.
and i get why players were mad it pretty much made those 15 clubs the ones you had to be on to be someone.