Official AOA Card Voting: Mina and Jimin (1 Viewer)

[Ahsoka]

We would like to hold a vote with AOA cards this time, due to changes in the Mina and Jimin situation we will hold a vote to see if people want their cards to continue to be included in the set. You can vote once, and voting will be closed in one week, after which the majority will rule as to whether the cards are added or removed. If you currently hold a Mina card, you will be reimbursed with a common card if her card is removed, or you will have the option of receiving a Jimin card if her card goes through. The only required question is the username, if you don't have an opinion about them you can skip them.

AOA Card Voting

forms.gle

@Cards Users

 

[shika]

minah doesnt deserve a card after all she put aoa jimin and the people around her through. jimin has been in the dark for too long :D glad we will hopefully get a change in the aoa cards ! :D

 

[athenaaa]

As much as I don't agree with Mina's actions in the situation, at the end of the day she is still considered an AOA member so ig give her a card. It's up to individuals whether they want to collect her or not. But put it at the end of the set and accept it as complete if they choose not to collect it

 

[Boyo]

As much as I don't agree with Mina's actions in the situation, at the end of the day she is still considered an AOA member so ig give her a card. It's up to individuals whether they want to collect her or not. But put it at the end of the set and accept it as complete if they choose to collect it

I deeply agree with what you said about putting it at the end of the set if people vote for it to be in.
Like, users voted for Woojin to be in the Stray Kids set again and I didn't want to collect his cards, but there is no choice since he is #1 in the set and the whole set looks incomplete without the first card.

 

[Areum]

I vote anonymously so I don't get any backlash except for the cards team
I did put my un on the form tho

 

[athenaaa]

I deeply agree with what you said about putting it at the end of the set if people vote for it to be in.
Like, users voted for Woojin to be in the Stray Kids set again and I didn't want to collect his cards, but there is no choice since he is #1 in the set and the whole set looks incomplete without the first card.

I think that's what should be done with all members with serious controversies that have been agreed to be put back in, like Woojin as you mentioned, or Youngmin of Ab6ix or Giselle of Asepa as I know some people don't support them. I understand that is a lot of work but at the same time, the sets do look incomplete. It's just a suggestion that could be considered in the future.

 

[RandAlThor]

Voted

 

[yeji]

voted

 

[litc]

As much as I don't agree with Mina's actions in the situation, at the end of the day she is still considered an AOA member so ig give her a card. It's up to individuals whether they want to collect her or not. But put it at the end of the set and accept it as complete if they choose not to collect it

I deeply agree with what you said about putting it at the end of the set if people vote for it to be in.
Like, users voted for Woojin to be in the Stray Kids set again and I didn't want to collect his cards, but there is no choice since he is #1 in the set and the whole set looks incomplete without the first card.

To this I'll say, Woojin's cards were put back bc he was proven innocent and was still once a member of the group, but other idols with serious scandals have had their cards removed

Mina's actions are as severe as the ones who had their cards removed as she

Spoiler: tw cutting

took pictures off of a russian website of cutting scars on arms, and posted them as if they were here own for attention. It's been proven.

And that's just one thing she's done.

I don't think most people looked more into it after jumping on Jimin though, including the proof of Mina bullying Jimin over text while Jimin chose not to engage.

 

[athenaaa]

To this I'll say, Woojin's cards were put back bc he was proven innocent and was still once a member of the group, but other idols with serious scandals have had their cards removed

Mina's actions are as severe as the ones who had their cards removed as she

Spoiler: tw cutting

took pictures off of a russian website of cutting scars on arms, and posted them as if they were here own for attention. It's been proven.

And that's just one thing she's done.

I don't think most people looked more into it after jumping on Jimin though, including the proof of Mina bullying Jimin over text while Jimin chose not to engage.

I support Woojin - however, my point was that although proven innocent, some people are still uncomfortable with him. And then with Mina, I'm sure there's some people who do still believe her. And I'm sure there's people who are against Jimin as well. I'm just saying there should still be a option to collect that member but not making it a requirement to complete the set.

 

[Abeamus]

Not going to vote as I wouldn't collect AOA myself regardless but I am not sure either of them are completely innocent so without a neutral member of AOA revealing the truth it's hard to know where to stand.

 

[Boyo]

To this I'll say, Woojin's cards were put back bc he was proven innocent and was still once a member of the group, but other idols with serious scandals have had their cards removed

Mina's actions are as severe as the ones who had their cards removed as she

Spoiler: tw cutting

took pictures off of a russian website of cutting scars on arms, and posted them as if they were here own for attention. It's been proven.

And that's just one thing she's done.

I don't think most people looked more into it after jumping on Jimin though, including the proof of Mina bullying Jimin over text while Jimin chose not to engage.

I follow the news, no need to prove that what Mina did is wrong. Nobody questions this, I think.
About Woojin; he is kicked out of the group and maybe we still don't know the whole story behind it. Who knows.
Minkie's and my point was about that it would be better to put those idols' cards as last in the sets, not about questioning it what they did is serious or not. Like, I think Woojin is not in Stray Kids anymore for reasons and you think he is okay, we probably will never agree on this. I just say if something similar happens with an idol group member in the future, maybe it would be better not to put her/his card as like #1, etc. in a set, but last.

 

[litc]

I follow the news, no need to prove that what Mina did is wrong. Nobody questions this, I think.
About Woojin; he is kicked out of the group and maybe we still don't know the whole story behind it. Who knows.
Minkie's and my point was about that it would be better to put those idols' cards as last in the sets, not about questioning it what they did is serious or not. Like, I think Woojin is not in Stray Kids anymore for reasons and you think he is okay, we probably will never agree on this. I just say if something similar happens with an idol group member in the future, maybe it would be better not to put her/his card as like #1, etc. in a set, but last.

I want Mina removed more than I want Jimin added, it's that idols who haven't done as bad as her, like Lucas, have had their cards removed but she still has hers.

It's just Woojin was removed for the accusations which were proven false, so he was added back. If former members were removed there would be no point in keeping Hyuna in Wonder Girls since she was only in the group for a few months and is most known for her solos and 4minute, but former members are kept unless there's a serious scandal. There are former members who had disagreements with the group or company that still have cards in the set as well.

Having former members last is an interesting idea from you though.

 

[Exi]

As someone that has had not alive attempts and thoughts , what Mina did was and will always be disturbing and disrespectful along with being triggering. Compared to woojin and the other ‘problematic’ idols , Mina’s scandals are very much real and have proof to back it up as @litc stated. If you want to support such a disturbed person y’all can go ahead but I can’t.

 

[Abeamus]

I want Mina removed more than I want Jimin added, it's that idols who haven't done as bad as her, like Lucas, have had their cards removed but she still has hers.

It's just Woojin was removed for the accusations which were proven false, so he was added back. If former members were removed there would be no point in keeping Hyuna in Wonder Girls since she was only in the group for a few months and is most known for her solos and 4minute, but former members are kept unless there's a serious scandal. There are former members who had disagreements with the group or company that still have cards in the set as well.

Having former members last is an interesting idea from you though.

Well that's not entirely true as EXID doesn't have their former members that went on to be BESTie but that's the only one that I can recall although that's another topic as I do feel an argument could be made for keeping the iconic lineup of groups what is needed for the main set barring major scandals of course

 

[Boyo]

I want Mina removed more than I want Jimin added, it's that idols who haven't done as bad as her, like Lucas, have had their cards removed but she still has hers.

It's just Woojin was removed for the accusations which were proven false, so he was added back. If former members were removed there would be no point in keeping Hyuna in Wonder Girls since she was only in the group for a few months and is most none for her solos and 4minute, but former members are kept unless there's a serious scandal. There are former members who had disagreements with the group or company that still have cards in the set as well.

Having former members last is an interesting idea from you though.

I get it and I agree with you 100%. Lucas' case is not even officially proved and he has no card. Mina is on another level, it's better not to state my opinion about her.

True, there are groups where removing former members would feel bad. Like, in EXO removing Luhan or Tao would make me bitter, not gonna lie. However, removing Kris is an other case. Every group's case is different and ofc, people see things differently, too.

One thing is sure, I agree with you on Mina.

 

[litc]

Well that's not entirely true as EXID doesn't have their former members that went on to be BESTie but that's the only one that I can recall although that's another topic as I do feel an argument could be made for keeping the iconic lineup of groups what is needed for the main set barring major scandals of course

Oh right I forgot they didn’t have them. Why not if they have hyuna in wonder girls and sunghee in kara

 

[litc]

I get it and I agree with you 100%. Lucas' case is not even officially proved and he has no card. Mina is on another level, it's better not to state my opinion about her.

True, there are groups where removing former members would feel bad. Like, in EXO removing Luhan or Tao would make me bitter, not gonna lie. However, removing Kris is an other case. Every group's case is different and ofc, people see things differently, too.

One thing is sure, I agree with you on Mina.

Yes I definitely agree with you, bibi

 

[litc]

As someone that has had not alive attempts and thoughts , what Mina did was and will always be disturbing and disrespectful along with being triggering. Compared to woojin and the other ‘problematic’ idols , Mina’s scandals are very much real and have proof to back it up as @litc stated. If you want to support such a disturbed person y’all can go ahead but I can’t.

Thank you exi. I like some aoa songs a lot and would want their set in the future but I wouldn’t want to have aoa Mina’s card at all

 

[Abeamus]

Oh right I forgot they didn’t have them. Why not if they have hyuna in wonder girls and sunghee in kara

No idea how that conversation went honestly as well no one ever really cared to ask about them and while I'd only want OT5 EXID myself I also don't see BESTie getting cards so making members like that optional could've been a compromise in case anyone does like BESTie without making people have to get members they wouldn't want.