My 10 Favorite 2nd & 3rd Gen Girl Groups (1 Viewer)

[Drew_B]

Not saying these are the best. Just that these are my favorite.

Second gen:

1. f(x)
2. Crayon Pop
3. Kara
4. T-ara
5. AOA
6. Wonder Girls
7. Girls Generation
8. Rainbow
9. 9 Muses
10. Stellar

Third gen:

1. Sonamoo
2. Itzy
3. Berry Good
4. Gugudan
5. Pristin
6. Limesoda
7. Saturday
8. Fanatics
9. Momoland
10. Busters

What do you think of this list?

 

[Mayday]

Honestly I don't really consider anyone after 2017 "3rd gen".

 

[Drew_B]

Honestly I don't really consider anyone after 2017 "3rd gen".

Why not though? Theres no difference between 2017 and previous years.

 

[Mayday]

Why not though? Theres no difference between 2017 and previous years.

Yeah but I wouldn't consider a 2013 group and a 2019 group to be of the same gen at all.

 

[RandAlThor]

Honestly I don't really consider anyone after 2017 "3rd gen".

See i am worse i kill second gen at the debut of rainbow and fx.
WonSoKa proved that gg could hang and make money.
So the big companies dropped another GG kicking off the next gen.
and 3rd gen at RV/2014 the year of change.
Gen 4 stopped at itzy pd 48
Welcome to gg gen 5. physicals are cool again.

That said.
2
SNSD
Kara
Tara (pre fx debut, but you could make a case that they are a response to wonsoka success also. pre those 3 few companies were willing to try gg)
WG
The Grace
the rest of gen 2 crashed and burned mostly baring jewlery

3
fx
Apink
Secret
Orange Caramel
Sistar
Rainbow
AS
EXID
Fiestar
Laboum

4
RV
Lovelyz
Gugudan
weki miki
fromis 9
dreamnote
pristin
April
OMG
MMM

5
IZ*one
Rocket Punch
Cherry bullet (on the fence hands up worries me first the digital only and second the style)

that is it off the top of my head.

 

[Drew_B]

See i am worse i kill second gen at the debut of rainbow and fx.
WonSoKa proved that gg could hang and make money.
So the big companies dropped another GG kicking off the next gen.
and 3rd gen at RV/2014 the year of change.
Gen 4 stopped at itzy pd 48
Welcome to gg gen 5. physicals are cool again.

That said.
2
SNSD
Kara
Tara (pre fx debut, but you could make a case that they are a response to wonsoka success also. pre those 3 few companies were willing to try gg)
WG
The Grace

3
fx
Apink
Secret
Sistar
Rainbow
EXID
Fiestar
Laboum

4
RV
Lovelyz
Gugudan
weki miki
fromis 9
dreamnote
pristin
April
OMG
MMM

5
IZ*one
Rocket Punch
Cherry bullet (on the fence hands up worries me first the digital only and second the style)

that is it off the top of my head.

Damn. You are already in 5th gen??

 

[RandAlThor]

Damn. You are already in 5th gen??

look at it how many 1st/2nd/3rd gen bg are still active like really active. Super junior still sell very well. TVXQ and JYJ's pieces sell crazy in japan for concerts especially.

no girls have that life span putting boys and girls in the same gen is disingenuous.
Apink is going to be the champ cruising past snsd for longevity (unless snsd actually starts releasing music that sells once again .)

Wonder girls had more rotation than After school a rotational group.
if you last 4-5 years as a gg you are special.
Look at the groups at the bottom of gen 2 both fiestar and Laboum made it 5 but i believe both said they had no money to speak of after it was over.
take random bg from those years like say teen top or the group ts screwed up. the kids at least have some money after the run.

 

[yeji]

so tasteful Drew