Information SHINee 14th Anniversary B-Side Tournament [Master Thread] (3 Viewers)

[Lawol]

the tag didn't work for some reason but I came bc I had the thread on watch

oh I wonder why it didn't I might have to tag again then cuz this is kinda important to see

 

[Lawol]

Hi everyone, the group stage is technically over but since there has been multiple rounds where almost half of the participants missed the voting period I'm giving it a 3 day extension. So if you have missed any group entirely or you haven't voted for 3 songs in any, here's your chance to do it! The votes won't appear in the official polls but I'll count them in the final standing of top 32. It's up to you whether or not you want to vote, if you don't then everything stays as it is, but I want everyone to have an opportunity to do so and also it might shift the current standings. As of now, 12 songs should be advancing (the ones that have 4 votes or more) but there are 26 others all with 3 votes competing for the last 20 spots, meaning that 6 will have to be eliminated before we can move on, so we might have one or few additional single elimination rounds, I'll follow up on that later.

- The extension is only for those who are a part of the official taglist, but if someone outside of the taglist voted before these votes are valid.
- You can only vote for the rounds that you missed or add 1 or 2 more songs in case you haven't voted all 3 initially.
- Voting is text based since all of the polls are already closed and I won't edit them. You can post all your votes to multiple groups here or do so in the designated threads below, whichever works best for you.
- You can't change your original votes if you voted already.
- Extension is going to end on 24th of June (Friday) at 12 AM KST.

Group A
click
Hasn't voted yet: AmysTeri
Has votes left:

Group B
click
Hasn't voted yet:
Has votes left: litc - 1

Group C
click
Hasn't voted yet: winterstory, AmysTeri
Has votes left:

Group D
click
Hasn't voted yet: winterstory, Vikki, AmysTeri
Has votes left:

Group E
click
Hasn't voted yet: Tsukino, Vikki, litc, Goldenstar, AmysTeri
Has votes left:

Group F
click
Hasn't voted yet: Tsukino, brekker, AmysTeri
Has votes left:

Group G
click
Hasn't voted yet: Tsukino, Goldenstar, AmysTeri, brekker, Exi, Haiku
Has votes left: litc - 1

Group H
click
Hasn't voted yet: Goldenstar, AmysTeri, brekker, Haiku
Has votes left:

Group I
click
Hasn't voted yet: Goldenstar, AmysTeri, brekker, Exi, Haiku
Has votes left:

Group J
click
Hasn't voted yet: winterstory, Tsukino, AmysTeri, brekker, Haiku
Has votes left: litc - 2

Group K
click
Hasn't voted yet: winterstory, Tsukino, Goldenstar, AmysTeri, brekker
Has votes left:


​

@winterstory @Tsukino @Nina @Vikki @litc @Goldenstar @AmysTeri @brekker @Exi @Haiku

re-tagging in case you didn't get the first notification​

 

[Kamistar]

@winterstory @Tsukino @Nina @Vikki @litc @Goldenstar @AmysTeri @brekker @Exi @Haiku

re-tagging in case you didn't get the first notification​

Thank you, twin!

 

[Kamistar]

@Lawol you're so organized

 

[Lawol]

Extension is over and so is the group stage. After adding up all votes these are the final results. As you can see we got 14 songs that already advanced to the elimination stage, however, there are other 30 songs all tied with 3 votes and we only need 18 more to fill the top 32 bracket. It means that we will have to narrow down from 30 to 18 or in other words eliminate 12, so you can also look at it as getting rid of your least favorites.

What I'm thinking now is we could either have an additional single elimination round of 2 groups by 15 and try to finish it that way or we could do it the oldschool team-like draft where every participant choose their favorites and they automatically advance on a first come first serve basis meaning that one song can only be chosen once and then the next person chooses from the remaining songs on the list. Personally I think the second way would be easier because of a limited number of active participants. Additional group stages doesn't guarantee that everyone chooses different songs and 18 of them go through, it's more likely that people vote for the same songs again and we are stuck with this never ending cycle of more rounds The second option means that a song only needs one vote (one person to pick it) to advance and that's it, and it would be text based probably right here on the main thread. We would decide a time when it starts and then everyone could just post their picks whenever they want/are free. Since we basically only got like 6 people still actively participating everyone would have to choose 3 songs to get 18. But let me know what you think, maybe you have some other ideas.
Bottom line is we can't move on to the top 32 elimination round until we actually have top 32 songs

Song title - Votes (number after + indicates extension votes)

Advancing songs:

Evil - 7
Odd Eye - 6
Colorful - 5
Hitchhiking 4+1 - 5
Body Rhythm 4+1 - 5
The Reason - 4
SHIFT - 4
Spoiler - 4
Wanted - 4
Like a Fire - 4
To Your Heart - 4
Undercover - 4
Ready or Not 3+1 - 4
Clue 3+1 - 4

Tied songs:

Chocolate - 3
Beautiful - 3
Selene 6.23 - 3
Melody - 3
Love Pain - 3
Savior - 3
Heart Attack - 3
Love Sick - 3
Tonight - 3
Kiss Kiss - 3
Attention - 3
Password - 3
Quasimodo - 3
Electric - 3
Who Waits For Love - 3
Romeo + Juliette - 3
Chemistry - 3
Note - 3
Sleepless Night - 3
I Really Want You - 3
A-Yo - 3
CODE - 3
Queen of New York - 3
You & I - 3
Diamond Sky 2+1 - 3
Don't Let Me Go 2+1 - 3
Area 2+1 - 3
JoJo 2+1 - 3
Days and Years 2+1 - 3
Obsession 2+1 - 3

 

[Lawol]

Extension is over and so is the group stage. After adding up all votes these are the final results. As you can see we got 14 songs that already advanced to the elimination stage, however, there are other 30 songs all tied with 3 votes and we only need 18 more to fill the top 32 bracket. It means that we will have to narrow down from 30 to 18 or in other words eliminate 12, so you can also look at it as getting rid of your least favorites.

What I'm thinking now is we could either have an additional single elimination round of 2 groups by 15 and try to finish it that way or we could do it the oldschool team-like draft where every participant choose their favorites and they automatically advance in a first come first serve basis meaning that one song can only be chosen once and then the next person chooses from the remaining songs on the list. Personally I think the second way would be easier because of a limited number of active participants. Additional group stages doesn't guarantee that everyone chooses different songs and 18 of them go through, it's more likely that people vote for the same songs again and we are stuck with this never ending cycle of more rounds The second option means that a song only needs one vote (one person to pick it) to advance and that's it, and it would be text based probably right here on the main thread. We would decide a time when it starts and then everyone could just post their picks whenever they want/are free. Since we basically only got like 6 people still actively participating everyone would have to choose 3 songs to get 18. But let me know what you think, maybe you have some other ideas. Bottom line is we can't move on to the top 32 elimination round until we actually have top 32 songs


​

@winterstory @Tsukino @Nina @Vikki @litc @Goldenstar @AmysTeri @brekker @Exi @Haiku​

 

[litc]

@winterstory @Tsukino @Nina @Vikki @litc @Goldenstar @AmysTeri @brekker @Exi @Haiku​

and I'll do it

 

[Ahsoka]

@winterstory @Tsukino @Nina @Vikki @litc @Goldenstar @AmysTeri @brekker @Exi @Haiku​

The second one sounds the easiest to me

 

[Nina]

Yeah going with the second one.

less calculating a whole mess of thingamabobs

 

[Lawol]

The second one sounds the easiest to me

Yeah going with the second one.

less calculating a whole mess of thingamabobs

alright! I also think that it's way easier and we are guaranteed to pick 18 songs as long as 6 people post their 3 picks.

 

[Lawol]

Chocolate
Beautiful
Selene 6.23
Melody
Love Pain
Savior
Heart Attack
Love Sick
Tonight
Kiss Kiss
Attention
Password
Quasimodo
Electric
Who Waits For Love
Romeo + Juliette
Chemistry
Note
Sleepless Night
I Really Want You
A-Yo
CODE
Queen of New York
You & I
Diamond Sky
Don't Let Me Go
Area
JoJo
Days and Years
Obsession

- Let's proceed then. Please choose 3 songs in no particular order from the list above, that you want to see in the next (elimination) stage and post them here.
- It's first come first serve basis, meaning that whenever one picks their 3 songs they automatically advance and the following person chooses from the remaining song pool and so on.
- There's no time limit and it will end whenever we have 18 songs drafted, in other words, when 6 people make their picks.
- Please choose wisely because you are not allowed to change them and it affects other people votes.
- A song can only be chosen once, meaning that your vote won't count if you choose something that has already advanced, so please carefully check the posts before you.
- If it helps think of it as getting rid of your least favorites from the bunch, and if the remaining songs aren't the ones you love just choose the least worst.

@winterstory @Tsukino @Nina @Vikki @litc @Goldenstar @AmysTeri @brekker @Exi @Haiku
​

 

[Kamistar]

CODE

Obsession

JoJo

Done

 

[Ahsoka]

Beautiful, savior, diamond sky

 

[Haiku]

A-yo, Love Pain, and Quasimodo

 

[litc]

heart attack, kiss kiss, chemistry

 

[Nina]

who waits for love
sleepless night
Note

 

[Exi]

Attention , obsession , code

 

[Lawol]

Done

Beautiful, savior, diamond sky

A-yo, Love Pain, and Quasimodo

heart attack, kiss kiss, chemistry

who waits for love
sleepless night
Note

All of the above advance

Attention , obsession , code

Attention advances but Obsession and CODE were already chosen by Kami so you gotta pick another 2 Exi

these are the remaining songs you can choose from:

Chocolate
Selene 6.23
Melody
Love Sick
Tonight
Password
Electric
Romeo + Juliette
I Really Want You
Queen of New York
You & I
Don't Let Me Go
Area
Days and Years

 

[Exi]

All of the above advance

Attention advances but Obsession and CODE were already chosen by Kami so you gotta pick another 2 Exi

these are the remaining songs you can choose from:

Chocolate
Selene 6.23
Melody
Love Sick
Tonight
Password
Electric
Romeo + Juliette
I Really Want You
Queen of New York
You & I
Don't Let Me Go
Area
Days and Years

Love sick and area ?

 

[Lawol]

Love sick and area ?

Yes great we got all 18 missing songs now. Will start top 32 elimination stage in a couple of days.