An actually competent vocal coach analyses Rosé's vocals! (1 Viewer)

[maruberry]

This guy makes all kinds of reaction videos to singers etc and gives his opinion! He sometimes also reacts to kpop idols and the time has come for Rosé! He says how things are and doesn't really care about what fans think, he says what he hears!

His conclusion: It's not good, but it isn't bad either!

PS: This has eng subs!

 

[la_mort_pour_vous]

Rosé has weak support upto G#4 I think, almost a nonexistent supported range.
She's not as bad as she's made out to be but she's weak.
She has the best pitch in BLACKPINK though.
She used to be better when she employed a natural voice, but now she tries to emulate a chipmunk-ey & chesty voice, which is damaging & limits her development, although not as damaging as Bom's.
That's what I hear from Rosé, but I'm no professional.

 

[trulychoi]

I always thought it was funny that ever since BLACKPINK came into the scene everybody and their mother's became vocal coaches. But hey, that's just a theory...

 

[Evergreen]

Haters exaggerate the hate about her vocals anyways. She has some strengths and if she still need training, she has potential.

 

[maruberry]

Haters exaggerate the hate about her vocals anyways. She has some strengths and if she still training, she has potential.

Exactly, it isn't like she has 0 training at all and is flopping around helplessly with her singing!