Official Cards Suggestions (2 Viewers)

[Ahsoka]

Would you consider blocking getting the 3 cards you reroll with for a while? It would seem really unlucky if u got any of them directly again for daily task reward or sth

Well it would suck but the chance of getting it is no more than the chance of getting a really popular card is. They all have equal chances

 

[OnlyCalB]

Rather than a cap we're leaning towards implementing a system where you can get a card in exchange for 3 or so cards. So if you have 3 unwanted cards you can reroll basically, and get a new card. We haven't figured it out perfectly yet but we prefer this over the cap for a few reasons, but we think this will solve the issue just in a different way.

This is a very good idea!

However, what if someone gets a card that another person really wants but they immediately send it back with two other cards, thus removing what is actually a valuable/wanted card from the game before an offer for a trade could have even been given?

@Vikki May I recommend then that you consider allowing only cards that have been in someone's hands for at least 3 days to be returned. That way it shows no offers have been made for that card, thus the card can be deemed unwanted/hard to trade at the present time.

So, for example, if I was to send back 3 cards for a re-roll to get one card back, my 3 cards must have been held by me for at least 3 days.

@Reo @Yili
What do you think about this? You think it will be a good thing to have this rule as to stop people just giving back potentially wanted cards without even trying to make trades/receive offers?

 

[Myco]

Rather than a cap we're leaning towards implementing a system where you can get a card in exchange for 3 or so cards. So if you have 3 unwanted cards you can reroll basically, and get a new card. We haven't figured it out perfectly yet but we prefer this over the cap for a few reasons, but we think this will solve the issue just in a different way.

this is a really fun idea

It does seem fun and is interactive again which I really like

Idk how to say this without sounding really critical/nitpicky or sth,
I really don't intend to but that system should be mostly used to "get rid" of the extremely common cards then since no soft cap,
I'd find the "work" that goes into three days for three cards should still be somewhat considered when you reroll, like if i would put in IZ*ONE Nako, NCT YangYang and a Zico 5 to end up getting someone like MAMAMOO Hwasa seems a bit counterproductive with a method like that to me?

 

[Myco]

This is a very good idea!

However, what if someone gets a card that another person really wants but they immediately send it back with two other cards, thus removing what is actually a valuable/wanted card from the game before an offer for a trade could have even been given?

@Vikki May I recommend then that you consider allowing only cards that have been in someone's hands for at least 3 days to be returned. That way it shows no offers have been made for that card, thus the card can be deemed unwanted/hard to trade at the present time.

So, for example, if I was to send back 3 cards for a re-roll to get one card back, my 3 cards must have been held by me for at least 3 days.

@Reo @Yili
What do you think about this? You think it will be a good thing to have this rule as to stop people just giving back potentially wanted cards without even trying to make trades/receive offers?

Yeah that would tie in a bit with my idea of returning/rerolling a card u would have for a month which i posted yesterday or so, i definitely think there should be some time limit for it too

 

[Yili]

This is a very good idea!

However, what if someone gets a card that another person really wants but they immediately send it back with two other cards, thus removing what is actually a valuable/wanted card from the game before an offer for a trade could have even been given?

@Vikki May I recommend then that you consider allowing only cards that have been in someone's hands for at least 3 days to be returned. That way it shows no offers have been made for that card, thus the card can be deemed unwanted/hard to trade at the present time.

So, for example, if I was to send back 3 cards for a re-roll to get one card back, my 3 cards must have been held by me for at least 3 days.

@Reo @Yili
What do you think about this? You think it will be a good thing to have this rule as to stop people just giving back potentially wanted cards without even trying to make trades/receive offers?

i approve of the waiting system too, at least 3 days before you can return a card. it shouldn't be too hard to track since we all can see what days we received our cards.

 

[Ahsoka]

but Vikki doesnt have one either

This is a very good idea!

However, what if someone gets a card that another person really wants but they immediately send it back with two other cards, thus removing what is actually a valuable/wanted card from the game before an offer for a trade could have even been given?

@Vikki May I recommend then that you consider allowing only cards that have been in someone's hands for at least 3 days to be returned. That way it shows no offers have been made for that card, thus the card can be deemed unwanted/hard to trade at the present time.

So, for example, if I was to send back 3 cards for a re-roll to get one card back, my 3 cards must have been held by me for at least 3 days.

@Reo @Yili
What do you think about this? You think it will be a good thing to have this rule as to stop people just giving back potentially wanted cards without even trying to make trades/receive offers?

Yeah in our idea I think we had the idea that they had to be held for a certain amount of time before we let you return it.

It does seem fun and is interactive again which I really like

Idk how to say this without sounding really critical/nitpicky or sth,
I really don't intend to but that system should be mostly used to "get rid" of the extremely common cards then since no soft cap,
I'd find the "work" that goes into three days for three cards should still be somewhat considered when you reroll, like if i would put in IZ*ONE Nako, NCT YangYang and a Zico 5 to end up getting someone like MAMAMOO Hwasa seems a bit counterproductive with a method like that to me?

I get where you're coming from and we're coming up with another feature that'll take that more into account. The chance of getting an unwanted card isn't that high though, this is just to get rid of the most unwanted. I can't say more about the other feature because its very in the works but ill say that even unwanted cards will be desired then

 

[Myco]

Yeah in our idea I think we had the idea that they had to be held for a certain amount of time before we let you return it.



I get where you're coming from and we're coming up with another feature that'll take that more into account. The chance of getting an unwanted card isn't that high though, this is just to get rid of the most unwanted. I can't say more about the other feature because its very in the works but ill say that even unwanted cards will be desired then

patiently waiting then

 

[OnlyCalB]

i approve of the waiting system too, at least 3 days before you can return a card. it shouldn't be too hard to track since we all can see what days we received our cards.

Very true.


Because imagine this:

You are waiting for one more card for set completion -> Someone else receives that card via task completion but they are frustrated it's not what they wanted -> So they send the card back with two others they have within minutes for a re-roll -> Yet you come back online and before you even had the opportunity to make a trade with that person or let them know it's important, that card is gone. Ouch. lol

 

[Myco]

I can't say more about the other feature because its very in the works but ill say that even unwanted cards will be desired then

idk if I'm just BIG BRAIN rn but I could imagine that you would need unwanted cards to upgrade the rarity like say, I'd need 3 A.C.E Jun to upgrade him to rare or something but you said that you can't have more than 1 of the same card but maybe u figured it out idk

 

[OnlyCalB]

Yeah in our idea I think we had the idea that they had to be held for a certain amount of time before we let you return it.



I get where you're coming from and we're coming up with another feature that'll take that more into account. The chance of getting an unwanted card isn't that high though, this is just to get rid of the most unwanted. I can't say more about the other feature because its very in the works but ill say that even unwanted cards will be desired then

Awesome. Seems like you guys are really giving this some thought and it will have a good/appropriate system to it.

Thank you for your hard work.

 

[Yili]

Very true.


Because imagine this:

You are waiting for one more card for set completion -> Someone else receives that card via task completion but they are frustrated it's not what they wanted -> So they send the card back with two others they have within minutes for a re-roll -> Yet you come back online and before you even had the opportunity to make a trade with that person or let them know it's important, that card is gone. Ouch. lol

it'd happen too often to a lot of the more nugu groups for sure, "i don't even know who this is" *sends it back*

idk if I'm just BIG BRAIN rn but I could imagine that you would need unwanted cards to upgrade the rarity like say, I'd need 3 A.C.E Jun to upgrade him to rare or something but you said that you can't have more than 1 of the same card but maybe u figured it out idk

i need a 5 star han card now

 

[Myco]

Awesome. Seems like you guys are really giving this some thought and it will have a good/appropriate system to it.

Thank you for your hard work.

i actually like this much more than a usual "we'll take that into consideration" response, not necessarily here on KS just what I remember from another forum that can't be named

 

[Myco]

IDK if it's too late to implement this now, or maybe you still could in the future, but I wonder how the card system works if it was under like a "Season" title,

say that different groups would be available in different Seasons,

The first batch and the 2nd one now you released a few weeks ago would be Season 1, and maybe the next batch you release would be Season 2.
The more cards we get and you guys plan to do you could do many different variants of which sets would be available in different seasons.

Which could also maybe help with the many unwanted cards etc.. It's kind of like a "stop" till they are available again.
I think the variety of cards would offer much more fun for trading and playing in the card roulette etc.

just an idea that I suddenly had

 

[OnlyCalB]

IDK if it's too late to implement this now, or maybe you still could in the future, but I wonder how the card system works if it was under like a "Season" title,

say that different groups would be available in different Seasons,

The first batch and the 2nd one now you released a few weeks ago would be Season 1, and maybe the next batch you release would be Season 2.
The more cards we get and you guys plan to do you could do many different variants of which sets would be available in different seasons.

Which could also maybe help with the many unwanted cards etc.. It's kind of like a "stop" till they are available again.
I think the variety of cards would offer much more fun for trading and playing in the card roulette etc.

just an idea that I suddenly had

This isn't a bad idea at all. But for the rarer card sets we get in the future. It will help certain cards sets feel "rarer" if they are only available during "seasons". I like your thinking Reo.


These current common cards sets shouldn't be part of the system though, as they are "common" and thus should always be made available. The system of giving three common cards to receive one card again is good enough for these common set of cards.

 

[LoveYooShaSha]

Idk where else to post this as i dint want to clutter the roulette thread:
Was gonna edit but heck it:[(Edit:)actually not] in the spirit of this roulette, could there be a different thread created to explore possibility of trades AFTER the roulette round is complete, like i hv 2 cards i wont mention im interested in but i dint hv the cards to offer b4 the roulette so they ended up here. Frex, if i offered their owners the same cards i offer here b4 the roulette or different cards tat i dont want to enter the roulette, maybe itd be more conducive to a trade(either b4 or after every round of roulette, itd need a more dedicated OP, or the OP neednt be hands on?) Just a thot abt the roulette as i dint take part previously in as i was undecided as to its utility then.
@Reo n whoever else is involved in the roulette/roulette users pls give ur thots. Thnx. (I dint edit to make it fit this suggestion thread srry if its awkward)

 

[OnlyCalB]

Idk where else to post this as i dint want to clutter the roulette thread:
Was gonna edit but heck it:[(Edit:)actually not] in the spirit of this roulette, could there be a different thread created to explore possibility of trades AFTER the roulette round is complete, like i hv 2 cards i wont mention im interested in but i dint hv the cards to offer b4 the roulette so they ended up here. Frex, if i offered their owners the same cards i offer here b4 the roulette or different cards tat i dont want to enter the roulette, maybe itd be more conducive to a trade(either b4 or after every round of roulette, itd need a more dedicated OP, or the OP neednt be hands on?) Just a thot abt the roulette as i dint take part previously in as i was undecided as to its utility then.
@Reo n whoever else is involved in the roulette/roulette users pls give ur thots. Thnx. (I dint edit to make it fit this suggestion thread srry if its awkward)

I'm also part of the Roulette, I help Reo out with it. I'm actually the one doing it tomorrow/later today.

I like this idea. I'll talk about this further with Reo and see what he thinks about it.

A few things needs to be considered with this. But a place for participants to go and discuss possible trades when cards are received sounds good. At least then it's all in one place and organised.

 

[Panda]

maybe have an event where we can give back cards to the Cards team and get another set of randomly generated cards

that way we can get rid of the cards that are unpopular and in the circulation around here?

 

[SHlNEE]

an idea to bring the card game to the next level and help the forum to gain more quality content;

how about giving people an option to gain more than just 1 card a day?
how would that create more quality content? simple

give people 2 cards a day by cracking up the requirements like for example;
if you manage to create 3 threads about 3 subjects that have never been posted before you get 2 instead of 1
and if you do the above + all of your 20 posts contain at least 50 or something words, you can earn yourself 3 cards a day


sounds difficult? not really
people CAN use the search function and on xenforo it is easy enough, not a difficult search system
and by using the search function you can easily find out if something has been asked or talked about yet

this will increase activity perhaps even more, gives people even more of a rewarding feeling, fills the forum with less duplicate threads aka making it less random messy type of vibe around here that @Drew_B and others are not super fan of and i say they make sense...
and people actually then get rewarded for real good hard effort even though it is not really that hard at all but at least people then have a reason to put more effort into their posting which a lot do not do for their tasks, including myself SOMETIMES because i was like wtf imma slack too as a lot of others do too most of the time by posting not much at all and still getting rewarded for spammy like content sometimes

and these ideas is just to add... so like people can still earn 1 card a day by doing the default
but if they wanna level up more quickly , make them work for it
and it also benefits the forums , gaining more quality content at the same time, hopefully anyways

DOES THIS IDEA SUCK OR NOT?
let me know folks
@Abeamus @Reo @Yukibana @Yili @Vikki @bulletproof @OnlyCalB @Lovely_Cornchips @Peachy_Tae @karina @uwuWinter @brekker @catqirljooe @mysteric @Mangoey @Taehyun @eclipsoul @Panda @DarlingBlue @kinnie @Caramel_Mochi917 @Tickita @Xeulgi @Ozymandias @lexus @marublade @NASA @RainbowDevil


EDIT
staff can easily check the words requirements with a website , all you have to do is copy paste
but if that is too much work which i can understand , then make it instead of 50 words just ''20 posts that contain at least 7 full sentences'' or something i dont know lol

 

[ADORA]

Sounds kind of crazy but I love the idea

 

[nyaajooe]

Spoiler

an idea to bring the card game to the next level and help the forum to gain more quality content;

how about giving people an option to gain more than just 1 card a day?
how would that create more quality content? simple

give people 2 cards a day by cracking up the requirements like for example;
if you manage to create 3 threads about 3 subjects that have never been posted before you get 2 instead of 1
and if you do the above + all of your 20 posts contain at least 50 or something words, you can earn yourself 3 cards a day


sounds difficult? not really
people CAN use the search function and on xenforo it is easy enough, not a difficult search system
and by using the search function you can easily find out if something has been asked or talked about yet

this will increase activity perhaps even more, gives people even more of a rewarding feeling, fills the forum with less duplicate threads aka making it less random messy type of vibe around here that @Drew_B and others are not super fan of and i say they make sense...
and people actually then get rewarded for real good hard effort even though it is not really that hard at all but at least people then have a reason to put more effort into their posting which a lot do not do for their tasks, including myself SOMETIMES because i was like wtf imma slack too as a lot of others do too most of the time by posting not much at all and still getting rewarded for spammy like content sometimes

and these ideas is just to add... so like people can still earn 1 card a day by doing the default
but if they wanna level up more quickly , make them work for it
and it also benefits the forums , gaining more quality content at the same time, hopefully anyways

DOES THIS IDEA SUCK OR NOT?
let me know folks
@Abeamus @Reo @Yukibana @Yili @Vikki @bulletproof @OnlyCalB @Lovely_Cornchips @Peachy_Tae @karina @uwuWinter @brekker @catqirljooe @mysteric @Mangoey @Taehyun @eclipsoul @Panda @DarlingBlue @kinnie @Caramel_Mochi917 @Tickita @Xeulgi @Ozymandias @lexus @marublade @NASA @RainbowDevil

yes, actually.