Is the new generation rebel against the perfect GG? (2 Viewers)

[twentyfivedollar]

What I mean is I noticed that the new gen of GGs are release songs that are different from the usual cute concept. Only Itzy is really striving from the new sound but that’s probably because of big3 privilege. Examples - Butterfly by Loona & Senorita by G idle.

 

[RandAlThor]

What I mean is I noticed that the new gen of GGs are release songs that are different from the usual cute concept. Only Itzy is really striving from the new sound but that’s probably because of big3 privilege. Examples - Butterfly by Loona & Senorita by G idle.

no there were folks around the edges 4 min, after school, beg ect.
and how well are they doing with that?
Those 2 may be ok because they seem to have larger fanbases to soak that up.
The fear is alway next time.
pristin and We me were there too how did that go?

 

[joshuaology]

Who's Afterschool and Orange Caramel? And Sistar, 2NE1, f(x), (oh come on, I could go on for a long time...)

 

[twentyfivedollar]

no there were folks around the edges 4 min, after school, beg ect.
and how well are they doing with that?
Those 2 may be ok because they seem to have larger fanbases to soak that up.
The fear is alway next time.
pristin and We me were there too how did that go?

I feel with Pristin the reason they officially didn’t do well is because the company literally dropped promotion of the group all together. I feel iz*onne might be the salvation and bring cute concepts but I also feel they might just be classy concepts instead of cute.

 

[twentyfivedollar]

Who's Afterschool and Orange Caramel? And Sistar, 2NE1, f(x), (oh come on, I could go on for a long time...)

But that’s a different topic. 2nd gen is 2nd gen. SNSD, Kara & WG still was poppin with cute concepts. While this gen nobody really pulling a cute concept

 

[joshuaology]

But that’s a different topic. 2nd gen is 2nd gen. SNSD, Kara & WG still was poppin with cute concepts. While this gen nobody really pulling a cute concept

Ohhhhhhh

 

[twentyfivedollar]

Ohhhhhhh

But I mean I guess it too early to say. But my hypothesis is that Cute concepts might not be popular this gen and see might see more cute Girl Crush concept like Dalla Dalla

 

[RandAlThor]

I feel with Pristin the reason they officially didn’t do well is because the company literally dropped promotion of the group all together. I feel iz*onne might be the salvation and bring cute concepts but I also feel they might just be classy concepts instead of cute.

Sales dropped by so much in each comeback that is a sign and not a good one.
physical then digital

V physical get it did not chart at all.

Oh so you want cute.
Gfriend is cuteish still but they are 4 years old now.
Dreamnote's debut was cute and really good, but to that point they got no traction.
Cute is actually hard, the kids have to be good to make it work.

Iz one could do better with Oh My! type stuff selling to the GP i feel. LVR was fine but its not what they really wanted.
You will notice that 1 person from rumor made the group.
As much as some liked that song, that is not what the folks making the group (gp ) want.

 

[RandAlThor]

But I mean I guess it too early to say. But my hypothesis is that Cute concepts might not be popular this gen and see might see more cute Girl Crush concept like Dalla Dalla

i really hope not but it could be, kinda like the sexy era was. I will just muddle thru until its over.

 

[feepit]

So does this mean that Red Velvet rebels every other comeback?

 

[VillageIdiot]

Good
Less competition
RISE FROMIS_9 & CHERRY BULLET

 

[VillageIdiot]

On topic: I think the oversaturation is taking a toll so companies have to find new and inventive ways to make their groups stand out. Non Big 3 groups stuck in traditional concepts (cute/g crush) are essentially fucked. Oh My Girl, Laboum, Nature etc are going to struggle because the top dogs right now, Twice/Gfriend, Blackpink/Red Velvet/MMM, essentially left no room for competition. And multifandomism isn't prevalent in Korea.

Loona's concept is extremely unique, no group is ever going to take away from their fandom nor do they have to compete with anybody.
Finding an exclusive niche is probably the easiest way to go at this point

 

[twentyfivedollar]

So does this mean that Red Velvet rebels every other comeback?

With there Velvet comebacks yes. RBB was the biggest left I have ever seen a top GG take tbh.

 

[twentyfivedollar]

On topic: I think the oversaturation is taking a toll so companies have to find new and inventive ways to make their groups stand out. Non Big 3 groups stuck in traditional concepts (cute/g crush) are essentially fucked. Oh My Girl, Laboum, Nature etc are going to struggle because the top dogs right now, Twice/Gfriend, Blackpink/Red Velvet/MMM, essentially left no room for competition. And multifandomism isn't prevalent in Korea.

Loona's concept is extremely unique, no group is ever going to take away from their fandom nor do they have to compete with anybody.
Finding an exclusive niche is probably the easiest way to go at this point

SEVERAL POINTS WERE MADE!!!

 

[QueenGirlCrush]

No as I think G-idle and Loona are both still in 3rd Gen and to me 3rd Gen is just polishing the established norms. But G-idle and Loona are unique. Loona in concept and finally with everything about Butterfly. G-idle is a non-traditional girl crush group.

THIS!!​

On topic: I think the oversaturation is taking a toll so companies have to find new and inventive ways to make their groups stand out. Non Big 3 groups stuck in traditional concepts (cute/g crush) are essentially fucked. Oh My Girl, Laboum, Nature etc are going to struggle because the top dogs right now, Twice/Gfriend, Blackpink/Red Velvet/MMM, essentially left no room for competition. And multifandomism isn't prevalent in Korea.

Loona's concept is extremely unique, no group is ever going to take away from their fandom nor do they have to compete with anybody.
Finding an exclusive niche is probably the easiest way to go at this point

Sort of like how the 2nd Gen had to rebound after the Asian Financial crisis and the takeover by soloist, hopefully the oversaturtaion makes 3.5 Gen and the future 4th Gen be another unique time for Kpop.

 

[amourpinks]

loona had a big budget behind them, that's the reason why they were able to experiment with different sounds and that's why their fandom is pretty solid. if other small girl groups had the money to experiment then they would probably do it but they dont. so they usually stick with the same concepts and dont stray away because they can't afford to lose money.

 

[Darkyoda47]

In short, this gen is going against the status quo because of the over-saturation in the industry right now.