Why Do People Mention Bom A Lot When Hyolyn Suffered The Same Decline? (2 Viewers)

[Walnutt]

I'll never get use to 3rd gen stans because what is a world without KARA, T-ara, Secret and SISTAR?

I didn't know what taste was until last November

 

[Darkyoda47]

I didn't know what taste was until last November

 

[QueenMilkShook]

Hmm good point

Omg, thank you. I don't make good points often lol

 

[RandAlThor]

I always thought she was rated too high, but folks love her tone.
I do not know Bom other than the fact that i cant listen 21 songs, but that vocal site had her below Krystal i believe, while H was more in the average area.

 

[Darkyoda47]

I always thought she was rated too high, but folks love her tone.
I do not know Bom other than the fact that i cant listen 21 songs, but that vocal site had her below Krystal i believe, while H was more in the average area.

Oh I do remember that site actually lol

 

[mirella]

This is coming from someone who loves both. Despite Hyolyn's decline she's still considered a skilled vocalist, whereas Bom didn't have great technique from day 1.

At Hyolyn's peak, she and Luna were arguably the best K-pop vocalists. Over the years she's gotten a bit weaker at controlling higher notes and her airiness is pretty evident, but she is still a better singer than Bom.

EDIT: I was reading the comments and just wanted to say I disagree with people who say she's overrated or not that good :/ Her strain is more noticeable because she has a really light voice and sings in a higher range which is her weak point, but plenty of singers strain more than her. She's good by K-pop standards, and the reason she's praised is mostly for her vocal agility and strength in lower notes.

I think Bom has actually improved... but again she's still below Hyolyn's level. She doesn't deserve any hate for it though, YG told her to sing that way. Plus she's a vocalist that prioritizes style and emotion, I mean she's an amazing artist in that aspect.

People don't attack Hyolyn because she's simply not a bad vocalist. It would be like attacking Mamamoo vocalists who are somewhere around her level currently.

 

[feepit]

I'll never get use to 3rd gen stans because what is a world without KARA, T-ara, Secret and SISTAR?

I feel so bad that these kids are getting so many songs that have instrumental choruses or didn't experience when Sexy Concepts were the go-to concept for girl groups.

 

[Darkyoda47]

I feel so bad that these kids are getting so many songs that have instrumental choruses or didn't experience when Sexy Concepts were the go-to concept for girl groups.

Ah the sexy wave. One of the best waves to hit Kpop. Thank you AOA/Girl's Day

 

[yeji]

Nah SISTAR were definitely as big as 2NE1. They probably had more hits than 2NE1 too. I don't get why her decline isn't highlighted though. I mean Bom's "bad vocal" name rose like towards the end of their lifespan. Something like 2014? I will say though, Hyolyn's decline is way more visible now because she's solo. It was masked since she had Soyu around. Bom didn't really have anyone else.

It was way earlier. People always compared her in We Belong Together to her way of singing in the 2ne1 songs

 

[Darkyoda47]

It was way earlier. People always compared her in We Belong Together to her way of singing in the 2ne1 songs

Girl blackjacks be calling her "best main vocal" for the longest time

 

[yeji]

Girl blackjacks be calling her "best main vocal" for the longest time

I know I was a blackjack for the lonest time lol. But people outside the fandom did talk about that

 

[Darkyoda47]

I know I was a blackjack for the lonest time lol. But people outside the fandom did talk about that

Oh really? Well I wouldn't know tbh. I stayed within my Sone circle most of the time, in the early years and we hated Bom

 

[yeji]

I do like both but honestly there are much better vocalists out there that deserve way more hype.
It is obious that starship did an amazing job with marketing Hyolyn, giving her alot of high notes, giving her opertunities like solos etc.
I think that just this image that starship potrayed of her is one factor why her decline isn't really mentioned

 

[yeji]

Oh really? Well I wouldn't know tbh. I stayed within my Sone circle most of the time, in the early years and we hated Bom

oh yeah. since I was into many goups back than too I defently saw conversations about that.

 

[Darkyoda47]

oh yeah. since I was into many goups back than too I defently saw conversations about that.

Tbh I remember Jieun being marketed the same way but she never took off as much as Hyolyn did. Probably because her voice was softer or something.

 

[Darkyoda47]

Tbh I remember Jieun being marketed the same way but she never took off as much as Hyolyn did. Probably because her voice was softer or something.

OMG THAT REMINDS ME THEY DID A COLLAB, RIGHT? LEMME SEE IF I CAN FIND THAT VIDEO

 

[Darkyoda47]

OMG THAT REMINDS ME THEY DID A COLLAB, RIGHT? LEMME SEE IF I CAN FIND THAT VIDEO

@lalaloveloona Omg do you remember this? It was iconic


Even here Hyolyn was straining
But she did sound the best ngl lol

 

[yeji]

Tbh I remember Jieun being marketed the same way but she never took off as much as Hyolyn did. Probably because her voice was softer or something.

oh yeah Jieun was marketed in a similar way. And I do think that she didn't took off due to her voice being softer and kinda more polished I would say. It's hard to describe. This defently makes me sad since she does have a beautiful voice and has some good songs too.

 

[yeji]

@lalaloveloona Omg do you remember this? It was iconic


Even here Hyolyn was straining
But she did sound the best ngl lol

omg yes I remember this

 

[Darkyoda47]

oh yeah Jieun was marketed in a similar way. And I do think that she didn't took off due to her voice being softer and kinda more polished I would say. It's hard to describe. This defently makes me sad since she does have a beautiful voice and has some good songs too.

I think the biggest problem with Jieun was, she was given and marketed for a role her voice wasn't meant for. That whole pop vocal diva thing did not suit her tone, even if she had the pipes for it. Her company probably realized that, which is why they took a different approach with her solo stuff. The one thing TS did right lol.